1
00:00:33,597 --> 00:00:38,183
Subtitles by MemoryOnSmells
http://UKsubtitles.ru.
2
00:00:43,972 --> 00:00:45,891
Billy Lamb?
What do you want?
3
00:00:45,892 --> 00:00:48,811
I'm a solicitor.
Well, that's a relief.
4
00:00:48,812 --> 00:00:51,611
It's family. I... I really need your
help.
5
00:00:51,612 --> 00:00:53,651
I need Martha Costello.
6
00:00:53,652 --> 00:00:56,732
Well, why didn't you say so?
Come in, come in.
7
00:01:07,932 --> 00:01:10,451
I came in today with verve in
my loins.
8
00:01:10,452 --> 00:01:14,771
My question is, can I make it to the
end of the day feeling the same way?
9
00:01:14,772 --> 00:01:15,971
Your grooming trial, miss...
10
00:01:15,972 --> 00:01:18,171
Yes, John?
..turned into a conspiracy.
11
00:01:18,172 --> 00:01:21,051
Just like that? Well, no-one could
get hold of you.
12
00:01:21,052 --> 00:01:23,811
And the CPS have just delivered
a batch of phone logs.
13
00:01:23,812 --> 00:01:26,531
A batch?
A... bit more than that.
14
00:01:26,532 --> 00:01:29,412
Right.
And your judge is Alan Cowdrey.
15
00:01:30,812 --> 00:01:35,051
The words I'm waiting to hear
are, "But don't worry,
16
00:01:35,052 --> 00:01:37,291
"I've got you a junior
and they're already on it."
17
00:01:37,292 --> 00:01:39,011
Sorry, miss.
18
00:01:39,012 --> 00:01:41,211
Get Jake to shift that lot.
19
00:01:41,212 --> 00:01:42,932
Jake left. Remember?
20
00:01:44,252 --> 00:01:48,571
Worth remembering, Harriet,
I'm the talent, darling.
21
00:01:48,572 --> 00:01:49,932
You're backstage.
22
00:01:57,212 --> 00:01:58,852
Miss, this is Dani Kakwani.
23
00:02:00,372 --> 00:02:02,372
Martha Costello.
24
00:02:03,452 --> 00:02:05,132
The, er... Arizona bombing.
25
00:02:08,012 --> 00:02:09,091
What about it?
26
00:02:09,092 --> 00:02:10,931
Hassan Makhdoom
was blown up in the attack.
27
00:02:10,932 --> 00:02:14,411
His brother Sajit survived
and is about to stand trial.
28
00:02:14,412 --> 00:02:16,691
So...
29
00:02:16,692 --> 00:02:18,891
The US want to extradite
someone else from Wolverhampton Tech.
30
00:02:18,892 --> 00:02:22,771
My nephew Rashid,
they're saying he was involved,
31
00:02:22,772 --> 00:02:25,891
that he did some sort of
hacking to plan for their attack.
32
00:02:25,892 --> 00:02:29,331
Some sort of hacking?
This is the US Government.
33
00:02:29,332 --> 00:02:30,611
They're not big on sharing
their thoughts
34
00:02:30,612 --> 00:02:32,811
with a solicitor
whose dad was born in Lahore.
35
00:02:32,812 --> 00:02:35,251
I'm not an extradition lawyer.
Nor am I,
36
00:02:35,252 --> 00:02:36,611
but Rashid's running out of
options
37
00:02:36,612 --> 00:02:39,611
and the judge doesn't want
the case reopened.
38
00:02:39,612 --> 00:02:41,971
I need someone
who's going to fight for him.
39
00:02:41,972 --> 00:02:45,812
Even if I wanted to help, you need
someone who understands the arguments.
40
00:02:47,372 --> 00:02:50,531
Clive, you've done extradition.
Once. Never again.
41
00:02:50,532 --> 00:02:52,612
Why? Because you lose.
42
00:02:56,052 --> 00:02:57,092
Can I see?
43
00:03:03,292 --> 00:03:05,971
You could argue improper
purpose.
44
00:03:05,972 --> 00:03:08,651
Looks like the US have drawn up charges
without knowing if he's involved,
45
00:03:08,652 --> 00:03:11,091
to get him into the interrogation
programme, to find out if he is.
46
00:03:11,092 --> 00:03:12,131
It's what they do.
47
00:03:12,132 --> 00:03:14,411
Lying so they can torture
people. I didn't say that.
48
00:03:14,412 --> 00:03:15,651
Yes, you did.
49
00:03:15,652 --> 00:03:18,692
Oh, good. You two have
found each other.
50
00:03:23,052 --> 00:03:24,651
His parents are good people.
51
00:03:24,652 --> 00:03:26,891
He plays cricket in the street,
for goodness' sake.
52
00:03:26,892 --> 00:03:28,892
There's no way he's mixed up
in this.
53
00:03:42,572 --> 00:03:44,612
I never even knew the brothers.
54
00:03:45,892 --> 00:03:47,572
They were at my college,
that's all.
55
00:03:49,452 --> 00:03:51,731
And I'm a follower of the
Prophet.
56
00:03:51,732 --> 00:03:54,291
Violence is haram. I could have
never done what they're saying.
57
00:03:54,292 --> 00:03:57,531
Rashid, if the US is trying to
get you there to interrogate,
58
00:03:57,532 --> 00:04:00,451
we can still argue improper
purpose.
59
00:04:00,452 --> 00:04:02,972
That's what they do
in Guantanamo, isn't it?
60
00:04:04,172 --> 00:04:07,331
They don't tell you why you're there.
They... They don't show you anything.
61
00:04:07,332 --> 00:04:10,211
But this is England.
62
00:04:10,212 --> 00:04:11,811
My father came here when he
was 18
63
00:04:11,812 --> 00:04:15,252
because he wanted to live
in the home of democracy.
64
00:04:16,972 --> 00:04:21,092
And now he has to hear
his son... called a terrorist.
65
00:04:22,292 --> 00:04:25,252
And his son can't even tell
him what the evidence is.
66
00:04:27,452 --> 00:04:28,491
Why?
67
00:04:28,492 --> 00:04:30,932
That sounds like a good place
to start.
68
00:04:33,212 --> 00:04:36,851
Asking why and not taking no
for an answer.
69
00:04:36,852 --> 00:04:41,252
If they decide to make me their
scapegoat, I will not get on that plane.
70
00:04:43,132 --> 00:04:45,332
I don't care what I have to do
to myself.
71
00:04:48,092 --> 00:04:49,132
I'll do it.
72
00:04:50,612 --> 00:04:53,171
Prosecution as the promised
land?
73
00:04:53,172 --> 00:04:54,891
You have to give the people
hope.
74
00:04:54,892 --> 00:04:57,731
Yeah, but some of the people
here have never done prosecution.
75
00:04:57,732 --> 00:05:00,251
CW is moving in on the junior
end and the squeezed middle
76
00:05:00,252 --> 00:05:02,331
cos she sees how unhappy
they are.
77
00:05:02,332 --> 00:05:05,411
She thinks a bit of agitprop
will get their votes.
78
00:05:05,412 --> 00:05:06,771
Her message is one of despair.
79
00:05:06,772 --> 00:05:08,492
What? And I'm hope?
80
00:05:09,812 --> 00:05:12,051
Well, if CW is despair and I'm
hope, what's Martha?
81
00:05:12,052 --> 00:05:13,131
I don't think she knows.
82
00:05:13,132 --> 00:05:14,892
Hello, Billy.
83
00:05:19,532 --> 00:05:21,571
In with the new.
84
00:05:21,572 --> 00:05:22,612
Out with the old.
85
00:05:25,012 --> 00:05:26,771
- What hearing?
- We sent a pupil.
86
00:05:26,772 --> 00:05:29,731
Amy Lang. It was a five-minute
application to move the trial date forward.
87
00:05:29,732 --> 00:05:33,451
To Monday. Did Ms Lang fight it?
She had your dates.
88
00:05:33,452 --> 00:05:36,171
And there's no clash in my diary,
so in your clerking brain
89
00:05:36,172 --> 00:05:39,331
the fact that I've got about 100 hours of
preparation to do...
90
00:05:39,332 --> 00:05:42,971
Miss, I'll understand if you don't
want to carry on with the campaign.
91
00:05:42,972 --> 00:05:45,051
I want you to get everyone in
chambers
92
00:05:45,052 --> 00:05:47,731
who is as fed up as I am
with this nightmare of a life
93
00:05:47,732 --> 00:05:48,771
and send them to see me.
94
00:05:48,772 --> 00:05:50,331
I am their candidate.
95
00:05:50,332 --> 00:05:55,091
I am sick and tired of being exhausted
because there's no legal aid for juniors,
96
00:05:55,092 --> 00:05:59,011
which means I stay up all night
every night working on complex trials
97
00:05:59,012 --> 00:06:01,131
only to be told I'm a fat cat
by a government
98
00:06:01,132 --> 00:06:03,771
full of the fattest cats
in the history of fatness!
99
00:06:03,772 --> 00:06:04,851
And get me Amy.
100
00:06:04,852 --> 00:06:08,891
Since she's happy for this trial
to start so soon, she can bloody well help.
101
00:06:08,892 --> 00:06:10,811
Hello, miss.
102
00:06:10,812 --> 00:06:13,251
I need you to call Damian
Garner at the Maudsley.
103
00:06:13,252 --> 00:06:15,891
I want a full psychiatric
assessment on Rashid Hirani.
104
00:06:15,892 --> 00:06:19,051
Done.
How was your con, by the way?
105
00:06:19,052 --> 00:06:23,371
Forget abuse of process. I'm going to
fight and win on mental-health grounds.
106
00:06:23,372 --> 00:06:24,611
What mental-health grounds?
107
00:06:24,612 --> 00:06:26,651
He wants to kill himself.
Martha...
108
00:06:26,652 --> 00:06:29,331
Shoe Lane. I'm sorry, but it's the
right argument.
109
00:06:29,332 --> 00:06:32,611
He's a vulnerable child and what
they're doing to him is abusive.
110
00:06:32,612 --> 00:06:34,891
He's being destroyed by an
unjust process.
111
00:06:34,892 --> 00:06:36,651
If they get him to the States, they'll get
him to say whatever they want him to.
112
00:06:36,652 --> 00:06:38,291
Hold the line, would you,
please?
113
00:06:38,292 --> 00:06:41,411
Miss, I've got an Elizabeth Forester
from the US Embassy.
114
00:06:41,412 --> 00:06:45,372
Says she'd like to speak to you and
that she could save you a lot of effort.
115
00:06:46,652 --> 00:06:48,531
Martha.
Er... Amy, sorry,
116
00:06:48,532 --> 00:06:51,411
just got to take this call.
Thank you.
117
00:06:51,412 --> 00:06:52,451
Hello, Martha Costello.
118
00:06:52,452 --> 00:06:53,612
Amy?
119
00:06:54,612 --> 00:06:58,491
What is it? Amy, can you come with
me, please?
120
00:06:58,492 --> 00:06:59,612
It's nothing.
121
00:07:03,252 --> 00:07:07,691
We don't need regulating. If we're not
good enough, we don't get the work.
122
00:07:07,692 --> 00:07:09,411
Miss?
123
00:07:09,412 --> 00:07:12,011
Amy, you're not busy,
are you? Good.
124
00:07:12,012 --> 00:07:15,051
The grooming trial you so kindly
agreed to bring forward for me.
125
00:07:15,052 --> 00:07:18,011
The evidence the police just
sent me is in there.
126
00:07:18,012 --> 00:07:21,891
Read it, schedule the hell out of it, and
tell me everything I need to know.
127
00:07:21,892 --> 00:07:23,051
We have three days.
128
00:07:23,052 --> 00:07:26,092
So, can I count on your vote,
David?
129
00:07:30,532 --> 00:07:33,052
I understand that
you saw Rashid today.
130
00:07:34,612 --> 00:07:36,411
Who told you that?
131
00:07:36,412 --> 00:07:40,171
I thought you should know that the
US takes its duty of care to prisoners,
132
00:07:40,172 --> 00:07:43,171
especially vulnerable
prisoners, very seriously...
133
00:07:43,172 --> 00:07:46,211
Who told you that I saw
Rashid today?
134
00:07:46,212 --> 00:07:48,492
..which is why I'd like you
to consider these assurances.
135
00:07:50,252 --> 00:07:54,531
First of all, we can now guarantee that
Rashid will not go to Guantanamo Bay.
136
00:07:54,532 --> 00:07:57,371
There was never any mention
of Guantanamo.
137
00:07:57,372 --> 00:07:59,851
We can also guarantee,
if you co-operate,
138
00:07:59,852 --> 00:08:03,451
that as a UK citizen, he will not
face the death penalty.
139
00:08:03,452 --> 00:08:09,331
But if he goes into your prison system
he will be living under 23-hour lockdown,
140
00:08:09,332 --> 00:08:11,131
he won't see his family,
141
00:08:11,132 --> 00:08:13,811
he won't have proper access
to legal advice,
142
00:08:13,812 --> 00:08:17,531
and, as present history suggests, you'll
be employing interrogation techniques,
143
00:08:17,532 --> 00:08:21,371
which, to be frank, are a little bit
bloody medieval.
144
00:08:21,372 --> 00:08:27,131
Martha, due to the importance of
this case, we will make more compromises.
145
00:08:27,132 --> 00:08:29,251
Why are you sounding like a
press officer?
146
00:08:29,252 --> 00:08:31,851
We can just speak English.
147
00:08:31,852 --> 00:08:35,371
Rashid will be housed
under regular US prison conditions.
148
00:08:35,372 --> 00:08:38,411
He will have 24-hour access
to medical supervision.
149
00:08:38,412 --> 00:08:40,091
We'll provide him
with his own psychologist
150
00:08:40,092 --> 00:08:44,251
and he will be free to choose his own
attorney in accordance with Arizona law.
151
00:08:44,252 --> 00:08:47,451
He's not well enough,
even with your assurances.
152
00:08:47,452 --> 00:08:48,972
Hm.
153
00:08:50,692 --> 00:08:54,931
Isn't it odd how suicide
is a terrible sin for Muslims,
154
00:08:54,932 --> 00:08:58,492
except when they're blowing
themselves up or about to face extradition?
155
00:09:00,212 --> 00:09:03,931
So, are... are you leaving?
Excuse me?
156
00:09:03,932 --> 00:09:06,491
Because I haven't finished yet.
157
00:09:06,492 --> 00:09:09,851
If we don't win on the
mental-health argument,
158
00:09:09,852 --> 00:09:12,731
we will go back to improper
purpose.
159
00:09:12,732 --> 00:09:14,611
There's not enough detail on
the charges
160
00:09:14,612 --> 00:09:17,651
to prove that you're not just
getting Rashid over for interrogation.
161
00:09:17,652 --> 00:09:20,091
OK, if that's the case,
162
00:09:20,092 --> 00:09:24,531
then the US Government is happy to
add a little flesh to the indictment.
163
00:09:24,532 --> 00:09:28,171
We know where the hacking happened,
Martha, we know when it was done,
164
00:09:28,172 --> 00:09:30,371
and the minute Rashid hits
US soil,
165
00:09:30,372 --> 00:09:34,012
he will go on trial for conspiracy
to murder innocent Americans.
166
00:09:38,652 --> 00:09:40,212
Good day.
167
00:09:43,012 --> 00:09:45,451
Sami Allahu liman Hamidah.
168
00:09:45,452 --> 00:09:47,972
Allahu Akbar.
169
00:09:49,012 --> 00:09:50,372
Allahu Akbar.
170
00:09:51,812 --> 00:09:53,972
Allahu Akbar.
171
00:09:55,252 --> 00:09:57,292
Allahu Akbar.
172
00:09:58,732 --> 00:10:02,331
Rashid, I know you've lost
faith in this process,
173
00:10:02,332 --> 00:10:05,452
but we have an opportunity
now, a small one.
174
00:10:07,252 --> 00:10:12,571
The US has added information to your
charges because they want us to give up.
175
00:10:12,572 --> 00:10:17,812
Our one hope is that somewhere in what
they've added there's a mistake or a lie.
176
00:10:20,412 --> 00:10:24,652
I need you to answer some
questions for me... truthfully.
177
00:10:29,652 --> 00:10:32,851
Were you at the college at the time
the attack was planned,
178
00:10:32,852 --> 00:10:36,212
the two-day window they've
got down here?
179
00:10:38,612 --> 00:10:39,891
Yeah.
180
00:10:39,892 --> 00:10:43,091
Were you in the hall of residence
they say, with the brothers,
181
00:10:43,092 --> 00:10:45,772
when the attack was planned,
at the time?
182
00:10:48,612 --> 00:10:51,012
Rashid, answer.
183
00:10:52,532 --> 00:10:53,572
Yeah, I was.
184
00:10:55,212 --> 00:10:56,771
And what about the room?
185
00:10:56,772 --> 00:11:02,331
See, now, they say they can pinpoint
that hacking to a specific computer
186
00:11:02,332 --> 00:11:04,332
in a specific room.
187
00:11:10,052 --> 00:11:14,371
What is it? No. No, I was never in
that room.
188
00:11:14,372 --> 00:11:17,851
And you're certain of that?
Yeah.
189
00:11:17,852 --> 00:11:19,211
The room they say I did that
hacking in,
190
00:11:19,212 --> 00:11:22,212
I...I never stepped foot in it
during the time they say.
191
00:11:23,652 --> 00:11:25,691
Abuse of process.
What?
192
00:11:25,692 --> 00:11:27,931
When you wake up in the morning,
the first three seconds of consciousness,
193
00:11:27,932 --> 00:11:29,771
do you think about the case
you're doing?
194
00:11:29,772 --> 00:11:30,811
Yes.
195
00:11:30,812 --> 00:11:33,291
Is it abuse of process,
196
00:11:33,292 --> 00:11:36,891
if I can prove the US got details
wrong on their charge summary?
197
00:11:36,892 --> 00:11:37,931
Depends what and where.
198
00:11:37,932 --> 00:11:39,211
Well, the US had put Rashid
199
00:11:39,212 --> 00:11:42,011
in a specific room at a specific
time doing this research.
200
00:11:42,012 --> 00:11:44,171
Now, he says he wasn't there.
201
00:11:44,172 --> 00:11:48,051
Martha, if they're being that
specific, then they must have proof.
202
00:11:48,052 --> 00:11:50,291
I bet you dream about them too.
203
00:11:50,292 --> 00:11:51,692
All right, Mar?
204
00:11:53,132 --> 00:11:57,611
You probably don't share
cigarettes any more, do you?
205
00:11:57,612 --> 00:12:00,771
I don't smoke roll-ups any more.
No, not here, not with this crowd.
206
00:12:00,772 --> 00:12:04,291
It's amazing in here, but it makes
you feel like you're not allowed in.
207
00:12:04,292 --> 00:12:06,453
20 years ago, you'd have said
that was anti-democratic.
208
00:12:07,652 --> 00:12:08,851
Why are you here, Sean?
209
00:12:08,852 --> 00:12:10,571
I was passing.
Oh, right, you were passing?
210
00:12:10,572 --> 00:12:12,531
I was passing, and I thought,
211
00:12:12,532 --> 00:12:15,051
"What happened to the girl
that broke my teenage heart?"
212
00:12:15,052 --> 00:12:17,891
Um... listen, I'll, er...
I'll see you in chambers.
213
00:12:17,892 --> 00:12:19,732
Yeah.
214
00:12:21,772 --> 00:12:24,891
Not your husband, is he?
And what would you say if he was?
215
00:12:24,892 --> 00:12:26,851
I'd ask you why you married a
big dolphin.
216
00:12:26,852 --> 00:12:28,651
I hope he's not the jealous type
217
00:12:28,652 --> 00:12:33,331
cos I would love to go for a coffee
with you, Martha Costello.
218
00:12:33,332 --> 00:12:38,572
First you tell me why you're here...
and then I'll think about coffee.
219
00:12:40,532 --> 00:12:41,932
Maybe another time, then.
220
00:12:55,172 --> 00:12:58,092
Who was that? Mr Mysterious.
221
00:12:59,492 --> 00:13:01,451
Sean McBride.
222
00:13:01,452 --> 00:13:04,091
Right. Thanks.
Who's Sean McBride?
223
00:13:04,092 --> 00:13:06,411
He's...
224
00:13:06,412 --> 00:13:08,492
He's what I used to be.
225
00:13:10,612 --> 00:13:13,771
Well, anyway, um...
if you want to argue abuse of process,
226
00:13:13,772 --> 00:13:15,731
it's not enough to say
that the information was false.
227
00:13:15,732 --> 00:13:18,851
You have to prove that
the US knew it was false.
228
00:13:18,852 --> 00:13:20,451
And how the hell are you
going to do that...
229
00:13:20,452 --> 00:13:21,492
Mar?
230
00:13:22,532 --> 00:13:25,691
Ah! Put extradition on the chambers
website, would you, Harriet?
231
00:13:25,692 --> 00:13:28,251
Another string to the Shoe
Lane bow.
232
00:13:28,252 --> 00:13:30,171
Well done.
Whoa!
233
00:13:30,172 --> 00:13:33,531
Was that a compliment? I always give
credit where it's due.
234
00:13:33,532 --> 00:13:38,891
Maybe it's the female mind - open, capable
of thinking beyond dull prejudice.
235
00:13:38,892 --> 00:13:40,931
What, and Clive Reader's a better
candidate than Martha Costello
236
00:13:40,932 --> 00:13:42,851
for head of chambers?
237
00:13:42,852 --> 00:13:44,011
I think so.
238
00:13:44,012 --> 00:13:46,731
Do you fancy him, Harriet? What's
that got to do with anything?
239
00:13:46,732 --> 00:13:48,851
I'm just asking.
Just sexist.
240
00:13:48,852 --> 00:13:50,491
Imagine if I asked you the
same question.
241
00:13:50,492 --> 00:13:52,691
What? Do I fancy Clive Reader?
Do you fancy Martha Costello?
242
00:13:52,692 --> 00:13:58,292
How I feel about Miss Costello
surpasseth all understanding.
243
00:14:14,292 --> 00:14:17,331
Talking of medieval,
you know what amazes me?
244
00:14:17,332 --> 00:14:18,411
How much energy you're expending
245
00:14:18,412 --> 00:14:21,611
on someone who would ban you from
working and getting an education,
246
00:14:21,612 --> 00:14:25,011
and who would expect you to walk behind
him all the way back to the 13th century.
247
00:14:25,012 --> 00:14:27,331
Have you been practising that
speech?
248
00:14:27,332 --> 00:14:30,012
Are women even allowed
to drive in Saudi Arabia?
249
00:14:31,692 --> 00:14:33,411
You see, there's a disconnect.
250
00:14:33,412 --> 00:14:37,731
Rashid is 19 years old. He's an
individual. He feels like a victim.
251
00:14:37,732 --> 00:14:39,931
But the real victims?
252
00:14:39,932 --> 00:14:44,651
Frances Brady, Adam Gilmartin,
Joey Maldini, Angel Valera.
253
00:14:44,652 --> 00:14:47,651
Four University of
West Arizona students,
254
00:14:47,652 --> 00:14:51,131
enjoying their graduation day, with
the whole of their lives ahead of them,
255
00:14:51,132 --> 00:14:53,451
when they were blown to pieces.
256
00:14:53,452 --> 00:14:54,491
Brady was pregnant.
257
00:14:54,492 --> 00:14:56,691
That's not the point.
258
00:14:56,692 --> 00:14:58,852
If that's not, what is?
259
00:15:00,332 --> 00:15:04,211
Oh, didn't you know?
I've got dual qualification.
260
00:15:04,212 --> 00:15:07,211
With this much lazy
anti-American feeling around,
261
00:15:07,212 --> 00:15:11,251
we think it's better that an
American stands up for America.
262
00:15:11,252 --> 00:15:14,291
That's the point.
Sorry?
263
00:15:14,292 --> 00:15:18,491
There's a principle that transcends
national interest and religion
264
00:15:18,492 --> 00:15:21,531
and... well, everything else.
265
00:15:21,532 --> 00:15:25,371
Habeas corpus, Elizabeth,
the right to be tried,
266
00:15:25,372 --> 00:15:30,092
the right to know what you're accused
of so that you can defend yourself.
267
00:15:35,012 --> 00:15:37,852
All rise.
268
00:15:49,932 --> 00:15:51,251
Miss Costello...
269
00:15:51,252 --> 00:15:55,531
..from what I can see from your
skeleton argument,
270
00:15:55,532 --> 00:16:01,051
you want to reopen this appeal by arguing
that there's been an abuse of process
271
00:16:01,052 --> 00:16:02,891
and forcing the United States
272
00:16:02,892 --> 00:16:06,491
to show you all the evidence they
have against Rashid Hirani?
273
00:16:06,492 --> 00:16:09,491
Your Lordship will have seen...
I'm a direct man, Miss Costello,
274
00:16:09,492 --> 00:16:11,011
and I've been told you're the
same.
275
00:16:11,012 --> 00:16:14,771
I do not want this appeal
reopened without good reason.
276
00:16:14,772 --> 00:16:16,891
Now, what is the answer to
my question?
277
00:16:16,892 --> 00:16:19,971
My client has always
maintained he was set up
278
00:16:19,972 --> 00:16:22,571
and now there's a discrepancy that
confirms that.
279
00:16:22,572 --> 00:16:25,171
Why has it taken six months
for him to remember this?
280
00:16:25,172 --> 00:16:29,531
The United States have only just
added the specific location.
281
00:16:29,532 --> 00:16:32,891
The, er... room in the hall of
residence.
282
00:16:32,892 --> 00:16:35,051
This is our first chance to
respond to it.
283
00:16:35,052 --> 00:16:38,531
This detail is crucial
284
00:16:38,532 --> 00:16:42,571
because it's the only thing that
links him to the conspiracy.
285
00:16:42,572 --> 00:16:44,691
Ms Forester?
286
00:16:44,692 --> 00:16:48,291
My lord, whatever Mr Hirani
claims,
287
00:16:48,292 --> 00:16:52,411
we are confident that he was in that room
at the time the hacking was activated.
288
00:16:52,412 --> 00:16:54,571
We can put him there.
289
00:16:54,572 --> 00:16:57,251
We're happy to let the court
see further evidence,
290
00:16:57,252 --> 00:16:59,812
if it can help
bring this process to an end.
291
00:17:01,132 --> 00:17:02,692
You have two days.
292
00:17:04,012 --> 00:17:06,052
All rise.
293
00:17:13,932 --> 00:17:14,971
What's our listing?
294
00:17:14,972 --> 00:17:17,251
Er... court nine, first on at ten.
295
00:17:17,252 --> 00:17:18,851
Time now?
Ten to.
296
00:17:18,852 --> 00:17:20,611
So, fill me in.
The phone logs?
297
00:17:20,612 --> 00:17:22,291
Er... there's lots.
298
00:17:22,292 --> 00:17:25,091
Yes, Amy. Bottom line,
is it for us or against us?
299
00:17:25,092 --> 00:17:27,371
From what I've seen, um...
300
00:17:27,372 --> 00:17:31,371
the stuff I've been able to examine has
been mainly from the men to the girl.
301
00:17:31,372 --> 00:17:32,532
OK.
302
00:17:34,252 --> 00:17:37,091
Er... I've asked you to prepare a
schedule.
303
00:17:37,092 --> 00:17:41,051
I'm guessing you haven't done that, so all
I want is a simple, clear answer instead.
304
00:17:41,052 --> 00:17:43,931
Does this work for us or not?
305
00:17:43,932 --> 00:17:47,891
The material mainly consists of calls and
texts that suggest bullying and coercion.
306
00:17:47,892 --> 00:17:49,251
So, yeah.
307
00:17:49,252 --> 00:17:51,611
Yes, I... I'd say it definitely
helps us
308
00:17:51,612 --> 00:17:53,491
in trying to prove
that there was a conspiracy.
309
00:17:53,492 --> 00:17:55,411
There.
310
00:17:55,412 --> 00:17:57,012
Wasn't so hard.
311
00:18:03,292 --> 00:18:05,371
Hello, Caroline.
312
00:18:05,372 --> 00:18:08,771
So exciting to be against you. One
just doesn't know what's coming.
313
00:18:08,772 --> 00:18:13,931
Which Albanian paedophile are you
representing?
314
00:18:13,932 --> 00:18:16,051
Touch of racism there.
315
00:18:16,052 --> 00:18:18,051
Under pressure, are we?
316
00:18:18,052 --> 00:18:21,251
I don't need to remind you that this is
the property of the US Government,
317
00:18:21,252 --> 00:18:24,371
so if you leak it or share it with
any party not involved in this case,
318
00:18:24,372 --> 00:18:27,811
you're in violation of US law
and at risk of prosecution.
319
00:18:27,812 --> 00:18:29,211
I don't know. Maybe a drink
would do it.
320
00:18:29,212 --> 00:18:30,731
What?
321
00:18:30,732 --> 00:18:34,091
Stop you making speeches
and get you talking instead.
322
00:18:34,092 --> 00:18:36,251
I know it's hard for you to accept
what Rashid was part of,
323
00:18:36,252 --> 00:18:39,731
but our investigators were pushed
to the limit finding this material.
324
00:18:39,732 --> 00:18:41,291
It was hidden deep on his
hard drive.
325
00:18:41,292 --> 00:18:45,291
Once you've had a chance to
look at that, I hope you can accept it,
326
00:18:45,292 --> 00:18:48,052
however painful that may be.
327
00:18:49,692 --> 00:18:51,731
Oh, hello.
328
00:18:51,732 --> 00:18:54,891
Clive Reader. I know.
329
00:18:54,892 --> 00:18:57,692
Thank you, Elizabeth.
I think we've got everything.
330
00:19:03,532 --> 00:19:05,692
Jesus, that woman!
331
00:19:07,172 --> 00:19:08,211
What's this?
332
00:19:08,212 --> 00:19:12,651
Evidence, apparently, that Rashid
Hirani is linked to the bombing.
333
00:19:12,652 --> 00:19:14,611
I mean, half of it's redacted.
334
00:19:14,612 --> 00:19:17,531
That's to protect the security
services who gathered it. Look.
335
00:19:17,532 --> 00:19:18,571
The MI5 seal,
336
00:19:18,572 --> 00:19:20,531
telling you that the bulk of the
evidence that the US is relying on
337
00:19:20,532 --> 00:19:22,771
has actually been gathered
by British intelligence.
338
00:19:22,772 --> 00:19:24,251
That's why they're so confident.
339
00:19:24,252 --> 00:19:26,331
So, none of this links to the
bombing.
340
00:19:26,332 --> 00:19:28,011
What are you talking about?
341
00:19:28,012 --> 00:19:30,012
Jihadi websites.
342
00:19:31,012 --> 00:19:33,771
Searches on Yemeni training
camps.
343
00:19:33,772 --> 00:19:37,371
This does not put him in room 132,
hacking into security details.
344
00:19:37,372 --> 00:19:39,971
Martha, if they've got this,
imagine what else they've got.
345
00:19:39,972 --> 00:19:41,171
Well, maybe this is everything.
346
00:19:41,172 --> 00:19:43,451
Rashid is radicalised.
Why can't you see that?
347
00:19:43,452 --> 00:19:47,331
I am only interested in whether he's
linked directly to doing that research.
348
00:19:47,332 --> 00:19:49,732
Well, is this clear enough for
you?
349
00:19:56,891 --> 00:19:58,931
You said you didn't even know
the Makhdoom brothers.
350
00:19:58,932 --> 00:20:02,932
I mean, what did you think?
They wouldn't find these?
351
00:20:07,452 --> 00:20:10,171
Answer her, Rashid!
352
00:20:10,172 --> 00:20:11,811
These photos aren't right.
353
00:20:11,812 --> 00:20:15,291
This is a picture of you in a
corridor
354
00:20:15,292 --> 00:20:17,571
with the two people who set off the
bomb in Arizona,
355
00:20:17,572 --> 00:20:19,611
and that's not all.
356
00:20:19,612 --> 00:20:21,611
They've got you outside the room
357
00:20:21,612 --> 00:20:24,651
where they say the university's
security details were hacked,
358
00:20:24,652 --> 00:20:26,971
and, this is the killer blow,
359
00:20:26,972 --> 00:20:29,251
they've got a witness
360
00:20:29,252 --> 00:20:33,411
who says they can place you in
the room where the hacking was done.
361
00:20:33,412 --> 00:20:35,451
Rashid.
362
00:20:35,452 --> 00:20:38,291
We believed you.
I promise.
363
00:20:38,292 --> 00:20:40,571
I was never in that room.
364
00:20:40,572 --> 00:20:42,612
Is that you or isn't it?
365
00:20:48,372 --> 00:20:50,052
I only met them briefly.
366
00:20:53,091 --> 00:20:55,131
I didn't admit it, because I know
how it would look,
367
00:20:55,132 --> 00:20:58,011
but I... I only met them once,
on that day.
368
00:20:58,012 --> 00:20:59,851
And what happened?
369
00:20:59,852 --> 00:21:02,251
Sorry, but if... if you've lied
about this,
370
00:21:02,252 --> 00:21:05,771
how am I supposed to believe
you're still innocent?
371
00:21:05,772 --> 00:21:08,172
Because there was
someone else there as well.
372
00:21:10,132 --> 00:21:12,373
He was the one who said that we
should meet the brothers.
373
00:21:14,772 --> 00:21:16,333
He was the one that pushed
me into it...
374
00:21:18,612 --> 00:21:21,051
..who said...
375
00:21:21,052 --> 00:21:25,811
if we were true Muslims, we'd listen
to what they had to say.
376
00:21:25,812 --> 00:21:28,731
Rashid, who are you talking
about?
377
00:21:28,732 --> 00:21:31,492
I'm talking about someone
who was there.
378
00:21:33,212 --> 00:21:35,212
I'm talking about a friend.
379
00:21:42,212 --> 00:21:43,691
He should have been in that
photo.
380
00:21:43,692 --> 00:21:47,251
He was at that meeting, and... and whoever
gave this to you has taken him out.
381
00:21:47,252 --> 00:21:49,732
What was his name, Rashid?
382
00:21:50,932 --> 00:21:51,972
I promised.
383
00:21:57,732 --> 00:22:00,651
This is how you open, Amy.
384
00:22:00,652 --> 00:22:04,411
Get it right and, by the time you sit down,
the trial can be effectively over.
385
00:22:04,412 --> 00:22:05,932
Yes, Ms Warwick?
386
00:22:07,892 --> 00:22:10,371
Ladies and gentlemen of the
jury,
387
00:22:10,372 --> 00:22:15,811
this was a case of systematic
and brutal exploitation.
388
00:22:15,812 --> 00:22:23,051
Three men identified, isolated, groomed
and terrorised a vulnerable teenager.
389
00:22:23,052 --> 00:22:26,571
They separated her from her
family
390
00:22:26,572 --> 00:22:31,451
and used her for their own
revolting sexual purposes.
391
00:22:31,452 --> 00:22:33,051
She is 17.
392
00:22:33,052 --> 00:22:35,452
They are all over 40.
393
00:22:36,492 --> 00:22:40,731
The defence will seek to portray
her actions as consenting,
394
00:22:40,732 --> 00:22:43,211
but all you need to know
395
00:22:43,212 --> 00:22:46,531
is that in one three-week
period
396
00:22:46,532 --> 00:22:54,731
this victim was bombarded by over 2,000
texts, e-mails and calls from these men,
397
00:22:54,732 --> 00:22:58,171
a relentless barrage of
disgusting demands
398
00:22:58,172 --> 00:23:01,811
that this young victim was
hopelessly ill-equipped to resist.
399
00:23:01,812 --> 00:23:06,571
These alone demonstrate
the defendants conspired to...
400
00:23:06,572 --> 00:23:10,331
This is the first time that
I've ever had to do this, my lord,
401
00:23:10,332 --> 00:23:13,891
and it gives me no pleasure,
402
00:23:13,892 --> 00:23:16,851
but I feel compelled
to interrupt my learned friend
403
00:23:16,852 --> 00:23:18,692
and ask that the jury leave the
court.
404
00:23:22,452 --> 00:23:23,852
Jury, five minutes, please.
405
00:23:31,772 --> 00:23:36,571
Never in my whole career
have I had an opening interrupted.
406
00:23:36,572 --> 00:23:39,012
You are blatantly misleading
the jury.
407
00:23:40,172 --> 00:23:47,012
In at least 40% of the material
that my learned friend is talking about...
408
00:23:48,572 --> 00:23:52,412
..it was from the complainant
to the men, not the other way round.
409
00:23:59,372 --> 00:24:02,532
I'm so sorry. I was sure I'd gone
through this box.
410
00:24:09,292 --> 00:24:11,651
These texts are from the girl.
411
00:24:11,652 --> 00:24:15,611
I thought I'd said I wasn't sure.
Look, I'm sorry, I'm just a bit stressed.
412
00:24:15,612 --> 00:24:19,412
We're all stressed, ducky.
It's the Criminal Bar.
413
00:24:21,812 --> 00:24:23,371
I'm sorry.
414
00:24:23,372 --> 00:24:25,092
And don't worry.
415
00:24:26,252 --> 00:24:27,772
It's not fatal.
416
00:24:33,212 --> 00:24:36,491
It's for Martha.
It's from the Maudsley. Thanks.
417
00:24:36,492 --> 00:24:39,252
There's a message from the
doctor. Sure.
418
00:24:41,452 --> 00:24:44,171
So, what's happened? He didn't deny
he met the brothers.
419
00:24:44,172 --> 00:24:46,171
But he says there was
someone else there,
420
00:24:46,172 --> 00:24:48,611
somebody he doesn't want to
get into trouble, who knew them better,
421
00:24:48,612 --> 00:24:51,571
and someone who was in this
image before it was altered.
422
00:24:51,572 --> 00:24:53,931
Did you believe him?
423
00:24:53,932 --> 00:24:55,012
I don't know.
424
00:24:57,412 --> 00:24:58,811
Ooh! Whose are these?
425
00:24:58,812 --> 00:25:00,931
They came for you, miss. Actually,
they were hand-delivered.
426
00:25:00,932 --> 00:25:02,932
Grateful client, maybe?
427
00:25:03,932 --> 00:25:05,132
Possibly.
428
00:25:07,292 --> 00:25:08,972
Amy?
Can I have a word?
429
00:25:18,452 --> 00:25:20,411
What's he look like, then,
flower man?
430
00:25:20,412 --> 00:25:23,251
Tall, dark, handsome.
431
00:25:23,252 --> 00:25:24,292
Northern.
432
00:25:25,772 --> 00:25:29,571
How's the trial?
Erm... not great.
433
00:25:29,572 --> 00:25:33,651
Why?
This isn't about the trial.
434
00:25:33,652 --> 00:25:36,252
I've been trying to talk to you
about this, but I didn't know how.
435
00:25:37,452 --> 00:25:39,452
What is it?
436
00:25:41,532 --> 00:25:42,572
Billy.
437
00:25:44,572 --> 00:25:45,772
What about him?
438
00:25:47,812 --> 00:25:49,411
He took me to the pub
439
00:25:49,412 --> 00:25:52,012
and when we were there he promised
that he'd get me tenancy.
440
00:25:53,012 --> 00:25:54,251
Well...
441
00:25:54,252 --> 00:25:56,091
And he said it while his hand
was on my knee,
442
00:25:56,092 --> 00:25:58,571
and the same thing
happened a second time.
443
00:25:58,572 --> 00:26:00,451
When?
444
00:26:00,452 --> 00:26:02,732
At Alan Cowdrey's party.
445
00:26:03,732 --> 00:26:05,292
Are you sure?
446
00:26:06,292 --> 00:26:09,811
Yeah, and I swear I didn't do
anything to encourage him.
447
00:26:09,812 --> 00:26:12,372
I didn't do anything to lead
him on.
448
00:26:14,612 --> 00:26:18,971
The reason I didn't tell you was because
I came here to learn from you,
449
00:26:18,972 --> 00:26:21,251
not to be a part of some
scandal,
450
00:26:21,252 --> 00:26:24,373
and because if I don't get tenancy here,
I don't know how I'm going to survive.
451
00:26:26,252 --> 00:26:28,091
Right.
452
00:26:28,092 --> 00:26:33,051
I want you to go home, get a good night's
sleep and let me take care of it.
453
00:26:33,052 --> 00:26:34,492
OK?
454
00:26:39,652 --> 00:26:40,692
Martha.
455
00:26:42,532 --> 00:26:43,611
What did you get?
456
00:26:43,612 --> 00:26:44,931
I went to the college to find
out
457
00:26:44,932 --> 00:26:47,011
who was resident in room 132
and that's what I got.
458
00:26:47,012 --> 00:26:49,971
Redacted. Did you try and...
459
00:26:49,972 --> 00:26:51,851
They're not at liberty
to share that information.
460
00:26:51,852 --> 00:26:54,171
They said a man from the
MOD had been in to see them.
461
00:26:54,172 --> 00:26:57,131
MOD is what MI5 are
when they're pretending to be normal.
462
00:26:57,132 --> 00:26:58,611
So Rashid is protecting someone.
463
00:26:58,612 --> 00:27:02,291
Yeah, but so are MI5 and, from what
I can see, they're the same person.
464
00:27:02,292 --> 00:27:03,331
Miss Costello,
465
00:27:03,332 --> 00:27:07,571
this is not a trial.
The evidence is not at issue.
466
00:27:07,572 --> 00:27:11,451
My lord, but the process by
which the evidence was acquired is.
467
00:27:11,452 --> 00:27:16,051
It appears to us that there is
another individual involved,
468
00:27:16,052 --> 00:27:18,371
someone who is right
at the heart of this case
469
00:27:18,372 --> 00:27:22,811
and whose... whose role and motive,
as of yet, we don't understand.
470
00:27:22,812 --> 00:27:26,291
My lord, this is all speculation
471
00:27:26,292 --> 00:27:29,531
and it's making the UK
extradition process look ridiculous.
472
00:27:29,532 --> 00:27:33,451
The presence of this individual and his
relationship to the security services
473
00:27:33,452 --> 00:27:36,811
opens up questions
that this court has to address.
474
00:27:36,812 --> 00:27:39,171
My client says he's innocent,
475
00:27:39,172 --> 00:27:46,051
so why did the United States pass us
MI5 material that had been falsified?
476
00:27:46,052 --> 00:27:47,731
What do you mean, falsified?
477
00:27:47,732 --> 00:27:51,971
We believe there was a fourth person
at this meeting, my lord,
478
00:27:51,972 --> 00:27:55,292
and his presence has been
obscured.
479
00:28:00,532 --> 00:28:05,171
And you say that fourth person has
been airbrushed out?
480
00:28:05,172 --> 00:28:06,532
My lord...
481
00:28:08,372 --> 00:28:14,891
Miss Costello, whatever the role
of this individual, if he or she exists,
482
00:28:14,892 --> 00:28:18,091
the court cannot grant you permission
to see everything you want to see.
483
00:28:18,092 --> 00:28:19,851
But, my lord...
A great deal
484
00:28:19,852 --> 00:28:23,731
of the material you've requested
is classified intelligence material.
485
00:28:23,732 --> 00:28:25,531
Well, until this
court examines that material,
486
00:28:25,532 --> 00:28:30,932
then none of can say whether my
client deserves to stand trial or not.
487
00:28:53,332 --> 00:28:55,372
You asked to see me?
488
00:29:06,092 --> 00:29:08,331
She's...
489
00:29:08,332 --> 00:29:10,892
very tenacious, Martha Costello.
490
00:29:12,932 --> 00:29:15,531
She's, er... committed.
491
00:29:15,532 --> 00:29:17,571
Well, as a result of her efforts,
492
00:29:17,572 --> 00:29:21,412
the Rashid Hirani extradition
is now spiralling out of control.
493
00:29:22,812 --> 00:29:27,092
She wants to see all classified
evidence against her client.
494
00:29:28,252 --> 00:29:31,812
The Americans are going berserk. They
thought they had their man on the plane.
495
00:29:33,492 --> 00:29:36,491
There is clearly an issue.
496
00:29:36,492 --> 00:29:41,852
The exact role of an informant, on
which far too much seems to rest.
497
00:29:42,812 --> 00:29:49,211
You know the usual solution in situations
that involve this much sensitive material?
498
00:29:49,212 --> 00:29:50,531
You appoint someone to look
at it,
499
00:29:50,532 --> 00:29:53,931
who then makes sure that
everyone's being fair to the defendant
500
00:29:53,932 --> 00:29:56,771
without actually telling him
what any of it says.
501
00:29:56,772 --> 00:30:00,131
I need someone independent,
Clive,
502
00:30:00,132 --> 00:30:05,331
but also someone who understands
the true complexity of the, er... situation.
503
00:30:05,332 --> 00:30:11,092
We have a treaty with the US,
a treaty we... we can't afford to damage.
504
00:30:12,732 --> 00:30:18,411
Our security services
are in a... delicate situation.
505
00:30:18,412 --> 00:30:20,371
You know I'm in chambers
with Martha Costello?
506
00:30:20,372 --> 00:30:23,771
Tiny world, the Criminal Bar.
507
00:30:23,772 --> 00:30:26,932
We'd never get anything done if you
couldn't do cases with people you know.
508
00:30:28,012 --> 00:30:32,132
And I'm sure you're entirely
independent-minded.
509
00:30:34,092 --> 00:30:36,891
Well done. We've just heard.
510
00:30:36,892 --> 00:30:39,812
Er... yeah, just between you
and me, I'd love to know how it happened.
511
00:30:41,212 --> 00:30:43,731
She knew who I was. Who?
512
00:30:43,732 --> 00:30:45,091
Elizabeth Forester.
513
00:30:45,092 --> 00:30:47,211
She must have seen your
name on chambers' website.
514
00:30:47,212 --> 00:30:51,891
The whole thing about special counsel
is it's meant to be independent, Harriet.
515
00:30:51,892 --> 00:30:53,291
Couldn't agree more.
516
00:30:53,292 --> 00:30:56,371
Ah, special counsel, sir.
Great honour.
517
00:30:56,372 --> 00:30:58,691
Who gave you the news?
Lord Justice Reynolds.
518
00:30:58,692 --> 00:31:02,291
Just you and him, was it?
Cosy little chat?
519
00:31:02,292 --> 00:31:05,851
Stood the Church clock at ten to
three? And was there honey still for tea?
520
00:31:05,852 --> 00:31:08,091
I'm my own man, Billy.
Course you are, sir.
521
00:31:08,092 --> 00:31:09,972
Of course he is.
522
00:31:25,372 --> 00:31:28,291
They came to me. I didn't approach them,
if that's what you're thinking.
523
00:31:28,292 --> 00:31:30,611
Yeah, well, you could have
said no.
524
00:31:30,612 --> 00:31:32,211
How often does something like this
come along?
525
00:31:32,212 --> 00:31:35,971
Oh, come on, Clive. You're being
incredibly naive.
526
00:31:35,972 --> 00:31:38,451
You don't think they picked you because
you're the right man for the job?
527
00:31:38,452 --> 00:31:41,491
They picked you
because they want to wind me up.
528
00:31:41,492 --> 00:31:43,731
They? Who are they?
You're being delusional.
529
00:31:43,732 --> 00:31:46,851
I saw how you reacted to the
material the US served. And what?
530
00:31:46,852 --> 00:31:49,931
All of a sudden, you're the only
person who can look at secret material
531
00:31:49,932 --> 00:31:54,411
and tell me whether someone else has
unfairly incriminated my client?
532
00:31:54,412 --> 00:31:56,092
Yes.
533
00:31:57,692 --> 00:31:59,811
How does Elizabeth know you?
She doesn't.
534
00:31:59,812 --> 00:32:01,411
And don't you think she might
be a bit more concerned
535
00:32:01,412 --> 00:32:02,932
about how well you know me?
536
00:32:07,532 --> 00:32:10,611
I knew I had to reply
immediately.
537
00:32:10,612 --> 00:32:12,571
Why?
538
00:32:12,572 --> 00:32:15,171
Because of what they would
do if I didn't.
539
00:32:15,172 --> 00:32:17,091
What was that, Ashley?
540
00:32:17,092 --> 00:32:19,891
They would threaten me,
541
00:32:19,892 --> 00:32:22,732
and when they saw me again
they would make me do things.
542
00:32:24,692 --> 00:32:25,851
What sort of things?
543
00:32:25,852 --> 00:32:28,532
They would force me to have sex.
544
00:32:32,012 --> 00:32:33,851
So,
545
00:32:33,852 --> 00:32:35,771
these...
546
00:32:35,772 --> 00:32:39,891
texts and e-mails
from you to the defendants...
547
00:32:39,892 --> 00:32:41,371
I sent them because I had to.
548
00:32:41,372 --> 00:32:47,691
Are you saying that you feel you had
no choice other than to send them?
549
00:32:47,692 --> 00:32:49,731
No.
550
00:32:49,732 --> 00:32:53,332
None. I had no choice.
I had to do whatever they wanted.
551
00:32:55,172 --> 00:32:57,212
Thank you, Ashley.
552
00:33:10,172 --> 00:33:13,251
"I sucked your cock, you fat
bastard.
553
00:33:13,252 --> 00:33:15,331
"You owe me the drugs."
554
00:33:15,332 --> 00:33:18,331
Did you write that, Ashley?
I don't remember.
555
00:33:18,332 --> 00:33:20,211
It's here in black and white,
556
00:33:20,212 --> 00:33:25,891
one of 25 texts you sent
over a two-hour period
557
00:33:25,892 --> 00:33:27,892
on June 29th.
558
00:33:29,372 --> 00:33:31,571
"Give me the drugs."
559
00:33:31,572 --> 00:33:34,731
"Where are the drugs?"
"You owe me those drugs."
560
00:33:34,732 --> 00:33:37,811
They used the drugs to control me!
The truth is, Ashley,
561
00:33:37,812 --> 00:33:40,291
that you were a prostitute.
Isn't that right?
562
00:33:40,292 --> 00:33:41,451
No.
563
00:33:41,452 --> 00:33:43,771
You were a prostitute and you
willingly gave those men
564
00:33:43,772 --> 00:33:46,131
sex for drugs. No!
565
00:33:46,132 --> 00:33:48,971
And if the frequency
of these calls proves anything,
566
00:33:48,972 --> 00:33:50,931
it proves that you were
determined
567
00:33:50,932 --> 00:33:53,011
to extract whatever payment
you could from them.
568
00:33:53,012 --> 00:33:54,251
That's not true!
569
00:33:54,252 --> 00:33:57,451
Shall I read the last text
that you sent that day?
570
00:33:57,452 --> 00:34:01,171
"Give me the drugs,
you bastards,
571
00:34:01,172 --> 00:34:05,012
"or I'll call the cops and tell them
what a bunch of paedos you are."
572
00:34:06,492 --> 00:34:09,771
That's why we're here, isn't it?
573
00:34:09,772 --> 00:34:15,172
Because these men didn't pay their
prostitute on time.
574
00:34:17,092 --> 00:34:18,932
Lunch?
575
00:34:26,132 --> 00:34:29,772
The court has appointed
someone called special counsel.
576
00:34:31,092 --> 00:34:35,251
That means all the material that's been
used to establish a case against you
577
00:34:35,252 --> 00:34:36,411
is going to be examined
578
00:34:36,412 --> 00:34:39,571
so there's no point
in protecting anyone any more.
579
00:34:39,572 --> 00:34:41,492
Do you understand?
580
00:34:42,452 --> 00:34:45,731
Now, whoever it is that you don't
want to get into trouble,
581
00:34:45,732 --> 00:34:49,411
whoever it is you thought
you were being loyal to,
582
00:34:49,412 --> 00:34:52,891
well, odds are that's who's
betrayed you
583
00:34:52,892 --> 00:34:56,451
and that's who MI5 are
working with.
584
00:34:56,452 --> 00:34:59,932
So you need to tell me
everything.
585
00:35:01,612 --> 00:35:02,652
Rashid?
586
00:35:09,732 --> 00:35:11,771
It was after...
587
00:35:11,772 --> 00:35:14,211
a big drone attack
588
00:35:14,212 --> 00:35:15,732
on the Pakistani border.
589
00:35:17,732 --> 00:35:20,652
The deaths used to get
reported in the mosque...
590
00:35:21,612 --> 00:35:23,692
..and this time a whole family
died.
591
00:35:25,532 --> 00:35:27,892
Four kids under ten.
592
00:35:31,692 --> 00:35:36,211
There was a lot of anger, people
saying someone had to do something.
593
00:35:36,212 --> 00:35:38,612
Even the imam was furious.
594
00:35:41,252 --> 00:35:46,812
Finally, as we were leaving, Salim said
he knew some people we could talk to.
595
00:35:48,372 --> 00:35:50,011
What did he say?
596
00:35:50,012 --> 00:35:52,612
He said he knew these two brothers
in our hall...
597
00:35:54,732 --> 00:35:56,171
..and they were planning
something.
598
00:35:56,172 --> 00:35:57,692
The Makhdoom brothers?
599
00:35:59,092 --> 00:36:01,132
Salim had met them before.
600
00:36:03,172 --> 00:36:05,251
We talked, we prayed.
601
00:36:05,252 --> 00:36:08,171
They told us they had a plan.
602
00:36:08,172 --> 00:36:09,891
They didn't say what.
603
00:36:09,892 --> 00:36:13,611
They said they knew
I was good with computers
604
00:36:13,612 --> 00:36:18,172
and could use the help getting security
details of the University of West Arizona.
605
00:36:21,212 --> 00:36:22,372
I agreed.
606
00:36:25,692 --> 00:36:27,292
But, straight after, I got
scared.
607
00:36:28,692 --> 00:36:30,291
I didn't want to be part of it.
608
00:36:30,292 --> 00:36:34,931
I told Salim I didn't want to do
it. I... I didn't want to be involved.
609
00:36:34,932 --> 00:36:38,171
So you were never in his
room doing that research?
610
00:36:38,172 --> 00:36:39,531
No.
611
00:36:39,532 --> 00:36:41,971
But Salim went back in.
612
00:36:41,972 --> 00:36:44,291
He must have done it, not me.
613
00:36:44,292 --> 00:36:47,291
Then what happened?
I don't know.
614
00:36:47,292 --> 00:36:51,732
After I told him I didn't want to do it,
I... I saw him with them one more time
615
00:36:54,252 --> 00:36:55,813
And then he told me he'd
pulled out too.
616
00:36:57,212 --> 00:36:58,412
Did he say why?
617
00:37:04,492 --> 00:37:06,292
A few months later,
the attacks happened.
618
00:37:07,492 --> 00:37:09,652
I mean, we couldn't believe it.
We were terrified.
619
00:37:11,252 --> 00:37:15,371
But we promised we'd never say
anything to incriminate the other.
620
00:37:15,372 --> 00:37:17,812
And you thought he'd stuck to
that?
621
00:37:21,852 --> 00:37:27,851
I thought our friendship
was part of my faith.
622
00:37:27,852 --> 00:37:30,771
You know what we
used to think in my family?
623
00:37:30,772 --> 00:37:32,851
We used to think our problem
with the next generation
624
00:37:32,852 --> 00:37:35,011
would be that they'd be too
westernised,
625
00:37:35,012 --> 00:37:38,491
that we'd struggle to get them
interested in our traditions.
626
00:37:38,492 --> 00:37:42,612
Dani, you've got contacts in
the police.
627
00:37:44,572 --> 00:37:48,212
How about we go and have our own
little conversation with Salim?
628
00:38:25,532 --> 00:38:26,611
Thank you for seeing us.
629
00:38:26,612 --> 00:38:28,291
What can I do for you?
630
00:38:28,292 --> 00:38:30,531
I'm professionally embarrassed.
631
00:38:30,532 --> 00:38:32,691
What do you mean? How?
632
00:38:32,692 --> 00:38:35,051
In the short adjournment,
I went to the robing room.
633
00:38:35,052 --> 00:38:38,051
On the desk next to my bag,
there was a sheet of paper.
634
00:38:38,052 --> 00:38:40,251
I wasn't thinking,
and I started to read it.
635
00:38:40,252 --> 00:38:42,131
Well, what was it?
636
00:38:42,132 --> 00:38:44,731
The first defendant's proof of
evidence.
637
00:38:44,732 --> 00:38:49,731
I'm afraid I have completely inadvertently
given myself a huge advantage,
638
00:38:49,732 --> 00:38:53,811
essentially meaning that these
defendants wouldn't get a fair trial,
639
00:38:53,812 --> 00:38:55,051
were I to continue prosecuting.
640
00:38:55,052 --> 00:39:01,051
It is with great reluctance,
I am obliged to withdraw,
641
00:39:01,052 --> 00:39:03,251
as the bishop said to the
actress.
642
00:39:03,252 --> 00:39:05,572
Mr Lever?
643
00:39:06,852 --> 00:39:10,331
I'm not sure my learned friend is so
embarrassed she can't continue.
644
00:39:10,332 --> 00:39:12,851
What you mean is that it's going
really well for you right now
645
00:39:12,852 --> 00:39:14,731
and the last thing you want to
do is stop.
646
00:39:14,732 --> 00:39:18,132
She's got a junior.
Did she read the defendant's proof?
647
00:39:19,092 --> 00:39:20,491
The whole point of having a
junior
648
00:39:20,492 --> 00:39:23,852
is that they can take over
in a situation like this.
649
00:39:26,092 --> 00:39:28,611
No, she didn't read it.
650
00:39:28,612 --> 00:39:30,412
But...
651
00:39:32,412 --> 00:39:34,492
..I did tell her what I'd read.
652
00:39:37,332 --> 00:39:39,491
Then I have no choice
but to discharge the jury
653
00:39:39,492 --> 00:39:43,011
and order a new trial as soon
as possible.
654
00:39:43,012 --> 00:39:48,532
It is with huge regret that I'm afraid
I just don't see any other way out.
655
00:39:58,292 --> 00:40:00,372
Salim. What are you reading?
656
00:40:01,692 --> 00:40:03,492
Politics?
657
00:40:05,532 --> 00:40:08,292
After the attack, I didn't sleep
for days.
658
00:40:09,412 --> 00:40:12,652
Rashid had gone home,
but I was still at college.
659
00:40:13,892 --> 00:40:16,011
It only took 'em 48 hours to
pick me up
660
00:40:16,012 --> 00:40:18,891
and then it was straight
to Paddington Green,
661
00:40:18,892 --> 00:40:20,731
14 days' detention,
662
00:40:20,732 --> 00:40:24,291
and every day being told
they've got evidence
663
00:40:24,292 --> 00:40:27,931
that could have me facing
150 years in a US jail.
664
00:40:27,932 --> 00:40:31,211
I know what I'd do. I'd say anything
to get out of there.
665
00:40:31,212 --> 00:40:33,411
- I didn't say anything.
- But you did.
666
00:40:33,412 --> 00:40:34,491
You told them
667
00:40:34,492 --> 00:40:38,051
that Rashid had hacked into the
university security plans for the brothers.
668
00:40:38,052 --> 00:40:42,131
How could I have done it? He was the
one who knew how to do that, not me.
669
00:40:42,132 --> 00:40:44,171
Did you see him? I mean,
did you actually see him,
670
00:40:44,172 --> 00:40:47,171
in your room, at your machine,
doing that research?
671
00:40:47,172 --> 00:40:49,931
You think Rashid is innocent,
because he's awkward and shy,
672
00:40:49,932 --> 00:40:52,451
but you don't know him.
673
00:40:52,452 --> 00:40:55,851
You didn't hear him talk
every night when we read the Koran.
674
00:40:55,852 --> 00:40:58,451
He was the one who said infidels
would get what they deserved.
675
00:40:58,452 --> 00:41:02,451
Did you see him or not, Salim?
I pulled out, OK?
676
00:41:02,452 --> 00:41:03,771
Once I heard the details,
677
00:41:03,772 --> 00:41:05,891
I didn't want anything to do with
what the brothers were planning.
678
00:41:05,892 --> 00:41:11,011
Neither did Rashid, so why incriminate him?
Why do a deal with MI5?
679
00:41:11,012 --> 00:41:14,811
You don't understand. I... I don't
like what I've done to him,
680
00:41:14,812 --> 00:41:16,811
but... but I had no choice.
681
00:41:16,812 --> 00:41:19,051
No, you did,
682
00:41:19,052 --> 00:41:21,651
and you still have.
683
00:41:21,652 --> 00:41:23,211
You can come to court.
684
00:41:23,212 --> 00:41:28,092
Come to court and admit that you
never saw him do that hacking.
685
00:41:31,252 --> 00:41:32,812
It's too late for that.
686
00:41:55,532 --> 00:41:57,092
I went to see Salim Dasti.
687
00:41:58,292 --> 00:42:00,371
What?
This whole case
688
00:42:00,372 --> 00:42:03,891
rests on the word of one terrified
boy against another,
689
00:42:03,892 --> 00:42:05,971
and no proof of which
is telling the truth.
690
00:42:05,972 --> 00:42:07,491
Martha, enough.
691
00:42:07,492 --> 00:42:11,531
Look, come on, Clive.
Nobody's listening.
692
00:42:11,532 --> 00:42:15,412
Why don't you talk to me properly?
What have you seen?
693
00:42:18,292 --> 00:42:21,851
All I'll say is, is that somebody
helped the brothers.
694
00:42:21,852 --> 00:42:23,331
They didn't plan the attack
alone.
695
00:42:23,332 --> 00:42:26,851
Salim was at the same
meeting as Rashid,
696
00:42:26,852 --> 00:42:29,211
so why not charge both boys?
697
00:42:29,212 --> 00:42:31,572
Why work with one and
punish the other?
698
00:42:33,012 --> 00:42:36,851
What if I told you that there was
something in the files
699
00:42:36,852 --> 00:42:39,891
that has convinced me
that Rashid was involved?
700
00:42:39,892 --> 00:42:41,971
I wouldn't believe you.
701
00:42:41,972 --> 00:42:44,132
You don't think I'd be honest
with you?
702
00:42:45,852 --> 00:42:51,132
I'm going to call Salim to give
evidence, make him tell the truth.
703
00:42:53,692 --> 00:42:55,612
Want a drink, miss?
704
00:42:58,172 --> 00:42:59,852
Excuse me.
705
00:43:03,532 --> 00:43:06,491
Billy, Amy came to see me.
706
00:43:06,492 --> 00:43:09,371
About what?
You promising her tenancy.
707
00:43:09,372 --> 00:43:11,411
So?
708
00:43:11,412 --> 00:43:13,651
With your hand on her knee.
709
00:43:13,652 --> 00:43:15,331
Hang on!
710
00:43:15,332 --> 00:43:17,692
She's very upset, Billy.
Well, she's got it wrong.
711
00:43:19,292 --> 00:43:20,851
How?
It's not what it looks like.
712
00:43:20,852 --> 00:43:23,971
Then what the hell is it? I couldn't
have done anything like that.
713
00:43:23,972 --> 00:43:27,932
I... Miss, since I've had the
implants, I can't even...
714
00:43:29,372 --> 00:43:32,371
This is how it is for me now.
Oh, Billy.
715
00:43:32,372 --> 00:43:34,611
No, I don't want your pity,
miss,
716
00:43:34,612 --> 00:43:40,291
but I want you to know that I didn't do
anything ugly or untoward with Miss Lang.
717
00:43:40,292 --> 00:43:41,571
That is a misunderstanding.
718
00:43:41,572 --> 00:43:45,051
Well, you need to apologise
and tell her what's going on.
719
00:43:45,052 --> 00:43:46,491
Miss?
720
00:43:46,492 --> 00:43:51,972
You promised me that if this was
affecting Shoe Lane, you would tell me.
721
00:43:54,772 --> 00:43:57,092
If Amy makes an official
complaint...
722
00:43:59,612 --> 00:44:01,932
It's the only way, Billy.
723
00:44:24,732 --> 00:44:26,811
Miss.
724
00:44:26,812 --> 00:44:28,971
Miss.
725
00:44:28,972 --> 00:44:31,772
I've told Amy you've got
something to say.
726
00:44:33,052 --> 00:44:34,852
Something you want to explain.
727
00:44:40,612 --> 00:44:42,612
I can't.
728
00:44:45,692 --> 00:44:49,492
Just... Just give him
till the end of the day, please.
729
00:44:58,132 --> 00:45:00,852
Salim?
He hasn't shown.
730
00:45:02,252 --> 00:45:08,211
My client now admits he was at a
meeting with the Makhdoom brothers.
731
00:45:08,212 --> 00:45:11,091
However, it was at someone
else's behest
732
00:45:11,092 --> 00:45:13,891
and that was the full limit
of his involvement.
733
00:45:13,892 --> 00:45:15,731
My lord, I'm afraid that is not a
position
734
00:45:15,732 --> 00:45:17,772
which is supported
by the redacted material.
735
00:45:18,812 --> 00:45:23,291
My lord, sorry, is there any chance of
the court actually seeing this evidence?
736
00:45:23,292 --> 00:45:24,891
If you don't have proof
737
00:45:24,892 --> 00:45:27,971
that your client has been implicated
through an abuse of process,
738
00:45:27,972 --> 00:45:31,571
then I'm afraid
this application is at an end.
739
00:45:31,572 --> 00:45:33,851
We're going to adjourn for ten
minutes,
740
00:45:33,852 --> 00:45:37,452
during which I want you
to consider your position.
741
00:45:38,652 --> 00:45:39,692
All rise.
742
00:45:55,052 --> 00:45:58,011
You're doing their job for them,
and I don't understand why.
743
00:45:58,012 --> 00:46:00,852
I'm telling the court what I've
seen. That's all.
744
00:46:02,452 --> 00:46:04,492
Well, let's find out the truth.
745
00:46:08,652 --> 00:46:10,692
My name is Salim Dasti.
746
00:46:11,852 --> 00:46:15,292
I was at college with Rashid
and... I was his friend.
747
00:46:16,932 --> 00:46:20,651
Have you ever been at a meeting
with the Makhdoom brothers?
748
00:46:20,652 --> 00:46:22,532
Yes.
749
00:46:23,972 --> 00:46:27,251
Who else was there?
Rashid.
750
00:46:27,252 --> 00:46:30,052
And can you tell the court
what happened at that meeting?
751
00:46:31,172 --> 00:46:34,171
Rashid and I talked with the
brothers,
752
00:46:34,172 --> 00:46:35,731
and, um... they explained
753
00:46:35,732 --> 00:46:40,412
that they were serious about using
their student exchange to do something...
754
00:46:41,412 --> 00:46:44,611
..something that would show
the Americans how we felt
755
00:46:44,612 --> 00:46:46,612
about the way innocent Muslims
were being killed.
756
00:46:47,652 --> 00:46:50,411
And then what happened?
757
00:46:50,412 --> 00:46:53,772
They said that, if we were
serious, we had to prove it.
758
00:46:54,772 --> 00:46:57,611
Rashid and I had to help them get
security details for their attack.
759
00:46:57,612 --> 00:47:00,652
But Rashid didn't go through
with it, did he?
760
00:47:01,692 --> 00:47:06,371
You went ahead, but Rashid
backed out.
761
00:47:06,372 --> 00:47:08,211
No.
762
00:47:08,212 --> 00:47:10,211
It was the other way around.
763
00:47:10,212 --> 00:47:12,051
I backed out.
764
00:47:12,052 --> 00:47:14,051
I told him I didn't
want to go through with it,
765
00:47:14,052 --> 00:47:15,411
and then I went back into my
room.
766
00:47:15,412 --> 00:47:16,891
Then why did you tell this court
767
00:47:16,892 --> 00:47:20,491
that Rashid did the research
from the same room?
768
00:47:20,492 --> 00:47:24,171
Because he did. The evidence they
showed me proved he did.
769
00:47:24,172 --> 00:47:26,571
Your claim doesn't make any
sense.
770
00:47:26,572 --> 00:47:29,771
You've said that you went
back to your room alone,
771
00:47:29,772 --> 00:47:33,171
and then you insisted that this is
where Rashid did his research.
772
00:47:33,172 --> 00:47:35,411
I mean, how can you
expect us to believe you?
773
00:47:35,412 --> 00:47:39,451
Because when I told him I wanted to
back out, he told me he wouldn't.
774
00:47:39,452 --> 00:47:42,771
He said he didn't care
if I didn't have the guts.
775
00:47:42,772 --> 00:47:44,251
He would show the brothers
he wasn't scared.
776
00:47:44,252 --> 00:47:46,251
He's lying!
You know what you said.
777
00:47:46,252 --> 00:47:49,251
Calm down.
I'm warning both of you.
778
00:47:49,252 --> 00:47:53,171
You're lying, Salim, and MI5
know that,
779
00:47:53,172 --> 00:47:56,691
and that's why they've done everything
they can to hide your involvement.
780
00:47:56,692 --> 00:47:58,931
No, that's... that's not true.
781
00:47:58,932 --> 00:48:04,091
I don't know how he did that hacking
from my computer, but he did it,
782
00:48:04,092 --> 00:48:07,211
and the reason MI5 protected
me is nothing to do with that.
783
00:48:07,212 --> 00:48:09,931
Then what is it? I mean, why cover
up your presence?
784
00:48:09,932 --> 00:48:12,692
Why remove you from the
photographs?
785
00:48:16,172 --> 00:48:19,892
Salim, you are obliged
to give this court an answer.
786
00:48:22,412 --> 00:48:25,292
Because I didn't just back out.
I called them.
787
00:48:26,692 --> 00:48:30,172
After that meeting with the
brothers, I panicked.
788
00:48:32,372 --> 00:48:35,092
I found a number and I...
I called a helpline...
789
00:48:37,292 --> 00:48:40,292
..and I told the person I spoke to
that something might happen.
790
00:48:42,532 --> 00:48:44,852
And what did they do?
791
00:48:45,932 --> 00:48:46,972
Nothing.
792
00:48:48,652 --> 00:48:52,772
They took my details and they said
they'd call back, but they never called me.
793
00:48:53,932 --> 00:48:56,131
That's why we're all here,
794
00:48:56,132 --> 00:49:00,011
because our intelligence services
were too busy to make a call,
795
00:49:00,012 --> 00:49:03,452
and then, because they knew how it
looked, they offered me a deal.
796
00:49:05,212 --> 00:49:08,091
They hauled me in after the
bomb went off,
797
00:49:08,092 --> 00:49:11,532
and they told me that they had
enough to send me to prison.
798
00:49:12,852 --> 00:49:16,291
They said that if I could give them
enough about Rashid's role,
799
00:49:16,292 --> 00:49:18,932
then... then I could avoid it,
because...
800
00:49:19,932 --> 00:49:23,133
..because then, at least, the US would
have a proper conspirator to put on trial.
801
00:49:33,052 --> 00:49:36,091
Can I point out that this admission
doesn't change the fact
802
00:49:36,092 --> 00:49:38,531
that Rashid Hirani was at that
meeting?
803
00:49:38,532 --> 00:49:41,451
He agreed to do research
on the proposed attack
804
00:49:41,452 --> 00:49:44,212
and there is no other person
who could have done it.
805
00:49:46,332 --> 00:49:49,051
We will retire to consider our
decision.
806
00:49:49,052 --> 00:49:52,452
Mr Reader, we may call on you for
assistance.
807
00:49:53,732 --> 00:49:55,772
All rise.
808
00:50:01,052 --> 00:50:02,931
So that's what this has been
about?
809
00:50:02,932 --> 00:50:06,771
Sending my nephew to America so
no-one would know MI5 screwed up?
810
00:50:06,772 --> 00:50:07,811
I can't comment,
811
00:50:07,812 --> 00:50:10,411
except to say that from what I've
seen Rashid deserves to stand trial.
812
00:50:10,412 --> 00:50:11,451
If we lose this,
813
00:50:11,452 --> 00:50:15,851
I'll make sure journalists on both sides
of the Atlantic know about Salim's call,
814
00:50:15,852 --> 00:50:18,611
and then we'll know
what the public cares about,
815
00:50:18,612 --> 00:50:24,212
a kid who made the mistake of going to
one meeting or MI5 letting a bomb go off.
816
00:50:29,411 --> 00:50:31,091
I hope you're not
going to let him do that.
817
00:50:31,092 --> 00:50:32,811
What else can he do?
818
00:50:32,812 --> 00:50:36,091
Martha, it's human error. Trust me.
How many calls do MI5 get right?
819
00:50:36,092 --> 00:50:38,851
How many great decisions have they made
that we've never even heard about?
820
00:50:38,852 --> 00:50:41,171
Rashid Hirani is my client
821
00:50:41,172 --> 00:50:44,292
and Rashid's been made to
suffer to cover MI5's cock-up.
822
00:50:48,092 --> 00:50:51,212
Billy, did we ever get
that psych report for Rashid?
823
00:51:06,172 --> 00:51:07,811
Miss!
824
00:51:07,812 --> 00:51:10,411
Billy.
It was in your in-tray.
825
00:51:10,412 --> 00:51:13,132
Thank you.
Uh.
826
00:51:14,132 --> 00:51:15,572
Oh...
827
00:51:23,652 --> 00:51:24,692
Clive.
828
00:51:26,292 --> 00:51:27,332
Clive.
829
00:51:34,412 --> 00:51:38,331
This is your solution?
It's a solution.
830
00:51:38,332 --> 00:51:42,132
And it's better than MI5 looking
stupid over an innocent kid.
831
00:52:00,092 --> 00:52:02,211
I just came to see how you were.
832
00:52:02,212 --> 00:52:03,651
Why?
833
00:52:03,652 --> 00:52:07,211
Well, it's unusual for prosecuting
counsel to be embarrassed.
834
00:52:07,212 --> 00:52:09,491
Well, I was.
835
00:52:09,492 --> 00:52:11,371
Right.
836
00:52:11,372 --> 00:52:13,611
So, how's chambers?
837
00:52:13,612 --> 00:52:18,171
Dysfunctional, riven with
political internal infighting.
838
00:52:18,172 --> 00:52:20,851
Nothing changes, then.
839
00:52:20,852 --> 00:52:23,531
Maybe what you need is a break.
840
00:52:23,532 --> 00:52:26,131
I've never felt less like taking
a break.
841
00:52:26,132 --> 00:52:29,771
I'm going to stand in this election to
replace you, and I intend to win it,
842
00:52:29,772 --> 00:52:31,692
and when I do, things are
going to change.
843
00:52:34,292 --> 00:52:37,092
Matt Busby made it hard
for everyone who followed him.
844
00:52:38,092 --> 00:52:39,651
What?
845
00:52:39,652 --> 00:52:42,691
We probably don't need
an elder statesman coming back,
846
00:52:42,692 --> 00:52:45,012
giving sage-like advice, Alan.
847
00:52:47,412 --> 00:52:50,012
Well, then, all I can do is wish
you luck.
848
00:53:26,772 --> 00:53:29,571
We have arrived at our decision.
849
00:53:29,572 --> 00:53:34,171
Our judgment has been
strongly affected
850
00:53:34,172 --> 00:53:40,011
by the report into the psychiatric
condition of the applicant, Rashid Hirani.
851
00:53:40,012 --> 00:53:43,691
We are particularly influenced
by the fact
852
00:53:43,692 --> 00:53:48,891
that, although it was commissioned
by Mr Hirani's legal team,
853
00:53:48,892 --> 00:53:52,572
it is also endorsed
by the security services.
854
00:53:54,332 --> 00:53:57,131
We rule that Rashid Hirani
855
00:53:57,132 --> 00:54:01,051
is not fit to endure conditions
he would find in US custody
856
00:54:01,052 --> 00:54:03,891
and must remain here.
857
00:54:03,892 --> 00:54:08,571
Since there are no charges
against you here, Mr Hirani,
858
00:54:08,572 --> 00:54:13,212
it is my duty to inform you
that you are now a free man.
859
00:54:18,692 --> 00:54:19,732
All rise.
860
00:54:23,612 --> 00:54:26,371
Martha, well done.
Thank you.
861
00:54:26,372 --> 00:54:28,332
Thank you.
862
00:54:31,092 --> 00:54:33,891
This would be the heart,
wouldn't it, if you had to say?
863
00:54:33,892 --> 00:54:35,291
Hm?
864
00:54:35,292 --> 00:54:37,651
This place would be
the heart of our legal system,
865
00:54:37,652 --> 00:54:40,732
and there's nobody here,
just you and me and the truth.
866
00:54:42,052 --> 00:54:44,731
There was no evidence
to link him to that hacking.
867
00:54:44,732 --> 00:54:47,611
The evidence was still being uncovered.
That's not the same thing.
868
00:54:47,612 --> 00:54:50,251
Clive, they couldn't put him in
that room where the research was done.
869
00:54:50,252 --> 00:54:52,211
It is as simple as that.
870
00:54:52,212 --> 00:54:54,491
Is it?
871
00:54:54,492 --> 00:54:56,931
What's this?
872
00:54:56,932 --> 00:54:58,491
It's a string of code from a
Trojan virus,
873
00:54:58,492 --> 00:55:01,731
found by forensic officers
examining Salim's hard drive.
874
00:55:01,732 --> 00:55:03,371
His computer was infected
with software,
875
00:55:03,372 --> 00:55:05,451
which allowed somebody
to control it remotely
876
00:55:05,452 --> 00:55:07,572
and then destroy all traces of
their work.
877
00:55:09,172 --> 00:55:13,491
Now, there's nothing to link it to Rashid,
yet, which is why I couldn't use it.
878
00:55:13,492 --> 00:55:16,572
But I can't think of anyone
else who could have put it there, can you?
879
00:55:21,972 --> 00:55:24,653
There's more than one way for him
to have been in that room, Martha.
880
00:55:25,732 --> 00:55:27,811
Yeah, it's a great talent,
881
00:55:27,812 --> 00:55:30,611
the ability to convince people
that you're a helpless victim,
882
00:55:30,612 --> 00:55:33,452
when you're pulling
the strings all the way.
883
00:56:32,252 --> 00:56:34,332
I'd like to make an official
complaint...
884
00:56:37,492 --> 00:56:38,812
...against Billy.
885
00:56:58,772 --> 00:57:00,372
I won't blame you, miss...
886
00:57:01,612 --> 00:57:04,212
..if you feel you can't stand
by me on this one.
887
00:57:05,532 --> 00:57:06,572
I'll understand.
888
00:57:14,532 --> 00:57:16,932
Help me, please, miss.
889
00:57:17,420 --> 00:58:07,265
Subtitles by MemoryOnSmells
http://UKsubtitles.ru.