1
00:00:00,680 --> 00:00:03,319
In New York City's war on crime
2
00:00:03,320 --> 00:00:05,470
the worst criminal
offenders are pursued
3
00:00:05,471 --> 00:00:08,238
by the detectives of
the Major Case Squad.
4
00:00:08,239 --> 00:00:10,424
These are their stories.
5
00:00:14,432 --> 00:00:15,466
- All right, Theresa.
6
00:00:15,467 --> 00:00:18,569
Your turn.
7
00:00:18,570 --> 00:00:20,204
- Tell everybody to duck.
8
00:00:26,010 --> 00:00:28,612
- Wow. Nicely done.
9
00:00:28,613 --> 00:00:30,914
- Thanks.
10
00:00:30,915 --> 00:00:32,850
- The priest sent
me an apology note.
11
00:00:32,851 --> 00:00:35,753
As though I'm supposed
to absolve him.
12
00:00:35,754 --> 00:00:39,056
For years I carried the
shame of that abuse
13
00:00:39,057 --> 00:00:41,158
without telling a soul.
14
00:00:41,159 --> 00:00:42,826
And I can't do it anymore.
15
00:00:42,827 --> 00:00:47,030
It's-it's time to come clean.
16
00:00:47,031 --> 00:00:49,233
- Guess what I found out today.
17
00:00:59,144 --> 00:01:01,678
Oh. Hello.
18
00:01:25,703 --> 00:01:28,272
- But I say to you,
love your enemies,
19
00:01:28,273 --> 00:01:31,608
and pray for those
who persecute you,
20
00:01:31,609 --> 00:01:35,379
that you may be children
of your heavenly father,
21
00:01:35,380 --> 00:01:39,249
for he makes the sun rise
on the bad and the good.
22
00:01:39,250 --> 00:01:43,020
And causes rain to
fall on the just
23
00:01:43,021 --> 00:01:45,656
and the unjust.
24
00:01:45,657 --> 00:01:48,425
- All right, talk about
the blind date from hell.
25
00:01:48,426 --> 00:01:51,662
First he takes me to a blood
bank to donate plasma,
26
00:01:51,663 --> 00:01:54,765
then Tequila shots.
27
00:01:54,766 --> 00:01:58,202
What?
28
00:01:59,237 --> 00:02:01,505
Theresa, why?
29
00:02:01,506 --> 00:02:03,674
- Monsignor, at
your convenience,
30
00:02:03,675 --> 00:02:04,708
I'd love the chance to talk.
31
00:02:04,709 --> 00:02:05,876
- Oh, it's taken care of.
32
00:02:05,877 --> 00:02:08,645
- Excuse me?
33
00:02:08,646 --> 00:02:11,915
- John, relax.
It's all taken care of.
34
00:02:17,021 --> 00:02:19,256
- I'm not supposed
to let you in.
35
00:02:19,257 --> 00:02:23,927
- I know.
I really appreciate it.
36
00:02:23,928 --> 00:02:27,231
Theresa?
37
00:02:27,232 --> 00:02:29,266
Theresa?
38
00:02:31,269 --> 00:02:35,239
You awake?
39
00:02:35,240 --> 00:02:37,241
I'm coming in.
40
00:02:50,242 --> 00:02:52,942
Adriano_CSI www.addic7ed.com
41
00:03:30,880 --> 00:03:32,973
Name's Theresa Esperna.
42
00:03:32,974 --> 00:03:34,642
None of the neighbors
hears the shot.
43
00:03:34,643 --> 00:03:36,610
No security cameras
in the building.
44
00:03:36,611 --> 00:03:39,713
We found this tucked in the
folder of her iPad case.
45
00:03:39,714 --> 00:03:41,081
It's why we called.
46
00:03:41,082 --> 00:03:43,817
- Wire transfer
from bank salerno
47
00:03:43,818 --> 00:03:45,419
to a numbered offshore account.
48
00:03:45,420 --> 00:03:48,022
2.7 million dollars.
49
00:03:48,023 --> 00:03:51,425
- Uh, who...
50
00:03:55,096 --> 00:03:56,463
Who moved the body?
51
00:03:56,464 --> 00:03:59,099
- Nobody.
52
00:03:59,100 --> 00:04:01,402
Her friend and the building
super found her like this.
53
00:04:01,403 --> 00:04:03,137
There's no forced entry.
54
00:04:03,138 --> 00:04:04,138
It looks self-inflicted.
55
00:04:04,139 --> 00:04:06,173
- Thanks, detective.
56
00:04:08,543 --> 00:04:10,311
- Well, we have an entry wound.
57
00:04:10,312 --> 00:04:11,979
Below the right ear,
58
00:04:11,980 --> 00:04:15,649
right under the hairline.
59
00:04:15,650 --> 00:04:17,451
But the gun is over there.
60
00:04:23,725 --> 00:04:26,827
Gun powder.
61
00:04:26,828 --> 00:04:30,130
There's flakes under
her fingernails.
62
00:04:30,131 --> 00:04:31,665
Both hands.
- Soap?
63
00:04:31,666 --> 00:04:34,068
- Maybe.
64
00:04:34,069 --> 00:04:36,337
Has a sweet smell, but
not a common fragrance.
65
00:04:36,338 --> 00:04:39,006
It-it's unusual,
like, uh, balsam.
66
00:04:39,007 --> 00:04:42,276
- Some kind of botanical?
67
00:04:42,277 --> 00:04:45,713
- I'm not sure.
Can we bag both her hands?
68
00:04:45,714 --> 00:04:48,082
- You're not thinking suicide.
69
00:04:48,083 --> 00:04:49,183
- You are?
70
00:04:49,184 --> 00:04:54,154
- The gun could have
bounced when she fell.
71
00:04:54,155 --> 00:04:55,789
Suicide that looks
like a murder?
72
00:04:55,790 --> 00:04:57,891
- Or a murder that
looks like a suicide.
73
00:05:12,640 --> 00:05:14,375
- We were supposed to
meet for breakfast.
74
00:05:14,376 --> 00:05:16,377
She said she needed my advice.
75
00:05:16,378 --> 00:05:17,378
- About what?
76
00:05:17,379 --> 00:05:20,247
- Uh, probably a man.
77
00:05:20,248 --> 00:05:24,251
When she didn't answer
her cell, I came by.
78
00:05:24,252 --> 00:05:26,620
Why would someone kill Theresa?
79
00:05:26,621 --> 00:05:29,022
- What makes you
think it was murder?
80
00:05:29,023 --> 00:05:30,357
- Because suicide's
a mortal sin,
81
00:05:30,358 --> 00:05:33,394
and your friend was
old school catholic.
82
00:05:33,395 --> 00:05:37,064
She has a crucifix in her room,
83
00:05:37,065 --> 00:05:38,565
catholic dating
service on her iPad.
84
00:05:38,566 --> 00:05:41,268
- Um, Tess was raised in
a super strict family.
85
00:05:46,875 --> 00:05:48,776
- Notice there's not much
paper in this apartment.
86
00:05:48,777 --> 00:05:50,244
She-she was a techie?
87
00:05:50,245 --> 00:05:53,247
- Yeah, on her iPad 24-7, 365.
88
00:05:53,248 --> 00:05:54,681
- We did find one
scrap of paper.
89
00:05:54,682 --> 00:05:56,784
A wire transfer
from bank salerno?
90
00:05:56,785 --> 00:05:58,852
- That's where she worked.
91
00:06:01,589 --> 00:06:04,158
- It's horrifying.
Theresa was a Saint.
92
00:06:04,159 --> 00:06:06,760
- What time did she leave
your office last night?
93
00:06:06,761 --> 00:06:07,928
- Just after 6:00.
94
00:06:07,929 --> 00:06:09,029
Said she had a business meeting.
95
00:06:09,030 --> 00:06:10,297
Didn't say with whom.
96
00:06:10,298 --> 00:06:12,599
- You know, I notice
the papal crest
97
00:06:12,600 --> 00:06:14,201
just after the alcove there.
98
00:06:14,202 --> 00:06:17,371
That's a obvious
display of faith.
99
00:06:17,372 --> 00:06:20,641
Aren't you afraid that
might alienate clients?
100
00:06:20,642 --> 00:06:25,913
Unless, of course, the client
is the catholic church?
101
00:06:25,914 --> 00:06:28,449
- We'll know for sure once
we subpoena your records.
102
00:06:28,450 --> 00:06:31,285
This isn't Switzerland.
103
00:06:31,286 --> 00:06:33,387
- Theresa was senior v.P.
104
00:06:33,388 --> 00:06:35,222
In charge of the victims
settlement account
105
00:06:35,223 --> 00:06:37,591
established by the
archdiocese of New York.
106
00:06:37,592 --> 00:06:40,327
- Victims of abuse by priests.
107
00:06:40,328 --> 00:06:43,664
- Yes.
108
00:06:43,665 --> 00:06:48,535
- Now, aren't there any
better jobs in this bank
109
00:06:48,536 --> 00:06:56,677
for a woman of, you
know, her skills?
110
00:06:56,678 --> 00:06:59,780
- Theresa felt very strongly
about remunerating victims.
111
00:06:59,781 --> 00:07:01,315
She wanted to make amends
112
00:07:01,316 --> 00:07:03,283
and restore the good
name of the church.
113
00:07:03,284 --> 00:07:06,887
- So the wire transfer was a
settlement to bn individual?
114
00:07:06,888 --> 00:07:08,755
- Yes.
115
00:07:08,756 --> 00:07:11,725
- She have any help
with that account?
116
00:07:11,726 --> 00:07:13,160
- I helped Theresa
117
00:07:13,161 --> 00:07:14,895
manage the settlement
money in the accounts.
118
00:07:14,896 --> 00:07:17,598
Kept it in t-bills,
risk-free bonds.
119
00:07:17,599 --> 00:07:19,366
- So you were close?
120
00:07:19,367 --> 00:07:21,335
- She was one of
my best friends.
121
00:07:21,336 --> 00:07:24,171
- We found a
disbursement receipt
122
00:07:24,172 --> 00:07:26,340
for $2.7 million.
123
00:07:26,341 --> 00:07:30,777
- Um, that was for Alice
garvey in mount Vernon.
124
00:07:30,778 --> 00:07:32,746
- That's a pretty big payout.
125
00:07:32,747 --> 00:07:36,550
- She was molested dozens
of times over five years.
126
00:07:36,551 --> 00:07:39,353
- This is a mediation
DVD, right?
127
00:07:39,354 --> 00:07:42,055
I mean, that's what
these are, aren't they?
128
00:07:42,056 --> 00:07:45,492
The victim tells their story
in front of a camera,
129
00:07:45,493 --> 00:07:48,795
and then a professional
mediator and Theresa,
130
00:07:48,796 --> 00:07:51,632
they determine the
settlement amounts?
131
00:07:51,633 --> 00:07:53,767
- Can't be easy
watching those stories.
132
00:07:53,768 --> 00:07:55,869
- Yeah, we watched every
single one of 'em together.
133
00:07:55,870 --> 00:07:58,071
They're tough to take.
134
00:07:58,072 --> 00:08:00,207
- College all-star.
135
00:08:00,208 --> 00:08:02,943
- I had a tryout
with the Phillies.
136
00:08:02,944 --> 00:08:04,478
They told me I'd
make a great banker.
137
00:08:04,479 --> 00:08:05,946
- Wow.
138
00:08:05,947 --> 00:08:08,916
Hey, you got little league
and you got college,
139
00:08:08,917 --> 00:08:10,083
but there's no high school.
140
00:08:10,084 --> 00:08:11,685
- Yeah, those were
my awkward years.
141
00:08:11,686 --> 00:08:13,854
I guess I'm ashamed.
142
00:08:13,855 --> 00:08:15,489
- Right.
143
00:08:15,490 --> 00:08:17,357
That's a catholic word.
144
00:08:17,358 --> 00:08:19,359
You know, "ashamed."
145
00:08:19,360 --> 00:08:20,961
- Speaking of which,
146
00:08:20,962 --> 00:08:25,332
we found a catholic dating
service on Theresa's iPad.
147
00:08:25,333 --> 00:08:27,401
- Catholic crush.
148
00:08:27,402 --> 00:08:30,504
The ad said that they would
find her God's perfect match.
149
00:08:30,505 --> 00:08:31,805
- Did they?
150
00:08:31,806 --> 00:08:36,109
- Nobody on that site could
measure up to Theresa.
151
00:08:36,110 --> 00:08:39,046
And God wasn't availle.
152
00:08:54,495 --> 00:08:56,430
- Chief of the detectives office
153
00:08:56,431 --> 00:08:59,700
just called about
those psych evals.
154
00:08:59,701 --> 00:09:03,003
You know, those shrink
sessions are non-cancelable.
155
00:09:03,004 --> 00:09:04,705
- Yeah, you got it, captain.
156
00:09:04,706 --> 00:09:07,074
- Spare me the
attitude, all right?
157
00:09:11,145 --> 00:09:12,946
- You know that it's a waste...
158
00:09:12,947 --> 00:09:15,115
- I know how non-negotiable
these sessions were
159
00:09:15,116 --> 00:09:17,384
to get your ass back
behind this desk.
160
00:09:17,385 --> 00:09:19,553
They still think
you're crazy upstairs.
161
00:09:19,554 --> 00:09:23,624
You know this.
162
00:09:23,625 --> 00:09:25,659
- Okay, thanks.
163
00:09:25,660 --> 00:09:27,561
I spoke to her father in Mexico.
164
00:09:27,562 --> 00:09:29,563
She came when she was
18 to go to college,
165
00:09:29,564 --> 00:09:32,132
went to Georgetown,
got a Harvard mba.
166
00:09:32,133 --> 00:09:34,901
Senior v.P.
On wall street at 28.
167
00:09:34,902 --> 00:09:37,738
- Immigrant success story.
168
00:09:37,739 --> 00:09:40,574
Devout catholic.
169
00:09:40,575 --> 00:09:43,877
She runs a fund to help victims.
170
00:09:43,878 --> 00:09:46,847
She's lonely. No boyfriend.
171
00:09:46,848 --> 00:09:48,882
- "God's perfect
match in 60 days
172
00:09:48,883 --> 00:09:50,350
or your money back"?
173
00:09:50,351 --> 00:09:53,487
- Wonder if I'm too old
for Catechism class.
174
00:09:53,488 --> 00:09:56,790
- Lab's analyzing the soap
flakes under her fingernails.
175
00:09:56,791 --> 00:09:58,992
This is from ballistics.
176
00:09:58,993 --> 00:10:01,795
- We got a hit on the.22
beretta.
177
00:10:04,432 --> 00:10:07,134
- All right, so anyone tell me
what an elephant sounds like?
178
00:10:08,269 --> 00:10:10,170
Right! Very good.
179
00:10:10,171 --> 00:10:11,538
All right, what do
we got down here?
180
00:10:11,539 --> 00:10:13,040
- Lizards.
- Lizard.
181
00:10:13,041 --> 00:10:14,408
- Monsignor?
- Monkey.
182
00:10:14,409 --> 00:10:15,709
- Hi.
183
00:10:15,710 --> 00:10:17,544
- Can we have a moment please?
184
00:10:17,545 --> 00:10:19,746
- Yep, that's my gun.
185
00:10:19,747 --> 00:10:20,914
I took her to the gun range
186
00:10:20,915 --> 00:10:23,550
to show her how to fire it.
187
00:10:23,551 --> 00:10:25,118
And I gave it to her
for protection.
188
00:10:25,119 --> 00:10:27,020
- Protection from who?
189
00:10:27,021 --> 00:10:28,488
- Well, a couple of months ago
190
00:10:28,489 --> 00:10:30,657
there was this out-of-state
abuse victim, and...
191
00:10:30,658 --> 00:10:32,092
His parish declared bankruptcy,
192
00:10:32,093 --> 00:10:33,660
so he made threats.
193
00:10:33,661 --> 00:10:35,328
Luckily, nothing happened.
194
00:10:35,329 --> 00:10:38,899
- So it's safe to say you're not
big on "turn the other cheek"?
195
00:10:38,900 --> 00:10:42,035
- I realize giving
her the gun was a...
196
00:10:42,036 --> 00:10:44,871
Terrible mistake.
197
00:10:44,872 --> 00:10:48,809
- We're curious about your
relationship with her.
198
00:10:48,810 --> 00:10:52,245
- Cordial. Not personal.
199
00:10:52,246 --> 00:10:55,482
I oversee settlements on
behalf of the archdiocese.
200
00:10:55,483 --> 00:10:57,918
- You mean like the
one to Alice garvey.
201
00:10:57,919 --> 00:11:01,354
- Yes. But, as you know,
202
00:11:01,355 --> 00:11:03,623
I'm not at liberty
to speak about that.
203
00:11:03,624 --> 00:11:06,393
Confidentiality
agreements and all.
204
00:11:06,394 --> 00:11:08,228
- Monsignor, we're ready.
205
00:11:08,229 --> 00:11:10,831
- Okay, I'm coming.
206
00:11:10,832 --> 00:11:12,532
Look, I've got a whole
ward full of kids
207
00:11:12,533 --> 00:11:15,001
that need my help today,
so if you don't mind...
208
00:11:15,002 --> 00:11:18,004
- Sure.
209
00:11:18,005 --> 00:11:21,374
- The wound's consistent
with female gunshot suicides
210
00:11:21,375 --> 00:11:22,909
in one respect...
211
00:11:22,910 --> 00:11:25,078
behind the ear, below hairline.
212
00:11:25,079 --> 00:11:27,347
- She wanted an
open-casket funeral.
213
00:11:27,348 --> 00:11:30,117
- No note, no
motive for suicide.
214
00:11:30,118 --> 00:11:32,853
- Only one in six leave a note.
You know that.
215
00:11:32,854 --> 00:11:34,421
- Uh, we found two varieties
216
00:11:34,422 --> 00:11:36,890
of soap flakes under
her fingernails.
217
00:11:36,891 --> 00:11:38,725
Her skin's very exfoliated.
218
00:11:38,726 --> 00:11:42,596
Heavy scrubbing on
the inner thighs.
219
00:11:42,597 --> 00:11:45,699
- Looks like she
used a pumice stone.
220
00:11:45,700 --> 00:11:48,001
- There's no pumice
stone in her shower.
221
00:11:48,002 --> 00:11:51,838
But her washcloth was wet.
222
00:11:51,839 --> 00:11:55,275
- She showered at home,
and also somewhere else.
223
00:11:57,178 --> 00:11:58,979
She felt unclean.
224
00:11:58,980 --> 00:12:00,881
You do a rape kit?
225
00:12:00,882 --> 00:12:02,382
- Yeah.
226
00:12:02,383 --> 00:12:03,550
She did have sex the
night of the murder,
227
00:12:03,551 --> 00:12:06,887
but there's no tearing,
no bruising,
228
00:12:06,888 --> 00:12:08,922
no signs of force.
229
00:12:08,923 --> 00:12:10,724
Her partner used a condom.
230
00:12:10,725 --> 00:12:13,226
It looks consensual.
231
00:12:18,933 --> 00:12:22,002
- Olive oil on the skin?
232
00:12:22,003 --> 00:12:24,571
- Yeah, balsam too.
233
00:12:24,572 --> 00:12:27,274
- Mixed with olive oil...
Makes myrrh.
234
00:12:29,877 --> 00:12:34,414
So she had sex.
She showered twice.
235
00:12:34,415 --> 00:12:37,250
Scrubbed herself raw.
236
00:12:37,251 --> 00:12:40,687
And anointed herself
with holy oil.
237
00:12:42,657 --> 00:12:44,391
- Two showers?
238
00:12:44,392 --> 00:12:45,725
Well, maybe she's got o.C.D.
239
00:12:45,726 --> 00:12:46,993
- Captain, the lab broke down
240
00:12:46,994 --> 00:12:48,361
the soap residue
under her nails.
241
00:12:48,362 --> 00:12:49,396
This isn't commercial.
242
00:12:49,397 --> 00:12:50,997
It's custom, luxury soap.
243
00:12:50,998 --> 00:12:54,234
Distributor says only three
hotels in Manhattan use it.
244
00:12:57,972 --> 00:12:59,639
- So she was sitting here?
245
00:12:59,640 --> 00:13:02,642
- Yes, the waiter said she
bought an orange juice.
246
00:13:02,643 --> 00:13:04,144
She seemed nervous.
247
00:13:04,145 --> 00:13:06,680
Security just downloaded
lobby camera footage.
248
00:13:08,983 --> 00:13:11,418
Here's where the gentleman you
see on the screen showed up.
249
00:13:17,458 --> 00:13:20,093
- Can you freeze that?
250
00:13:24,866 --> 00:13:28,968
Cordial, not personal.
251
00:13:34,022 --> 00:13:35,423
Checked the floor indicator.
252
00:13:35,424 --> 00:13:38,759
It stopped at two and
four and now seven.
253
00:13:38,760 --> 00:13:40,995
- The hotel manager
said the monsignor
254
00:13:40,996 --> 00:13:44,098
registered under the name Mr.
Jenkins.
255
00:13:44,099 --> 00:13:46,033
- Did they leave together?
256
00:13:48,070 --> 00:13:49,937
- There she is. Alone.
257
00:13:49,938 --> 00:13:51,472
- She has wet hair.
258
00:13:51,473 --> 00:13:52,573
- Shower number one was here,
259
00:13:52,574 --> 00:13:54,241
number two was at home.
- Mm.
260
00:13:54,242 --> 00:13:58,613
- The toxicology found 800
micrograms of Diazepam,
261
00:13:58,614 --> 00:14:01,315
and blood alcohol was.04.
262
00:14:01,316 --> 00:14:03,351
- Means she was putty.
263
00:14:03,352 --> 00:14:05,419
The killer could have
put a gun in her hand,
264
00:14:05,420 --> 00:14:06,721
made it look like suicide.
265
00:14:06,722 --> 00:14:10,491
- Well, before we
jump to conclusions,
266
00:14:10,492 --> 00:14:12,994
let's find out more
about our monsignor.
267
00:14:15,831 --> 00:14:18,566
- Monsignor McTeal
started soup kitchens,
268
00:14:18,567 --> 00:14:20,735
food banks, orphanages.
269
00:14:20,736 --> 00:14:22,003
He's dynamo.
270
00:14:22,004 --> 00:14:24,271
- We saw him at
children's hospital.
271
00:14:24,272 --> 00:14:27,341
- In church circles, they
call him "the consoler."
272
00:14:27,342 --> 00:14:28,943
- Does he also console women
273
00:14:28,944 --> 00:14:31,479
in their time of emotional need?
274
00:14:35,317 --> 00:14:38,719
- But no official complaints
against the monsignor?
275
00:14:38,720 --> 00:14:41,188
- There was an
unrelated complaint
276
00:14:41,189 --> 00:14:42,857
we passed on to his office.
277
00:14:42,858 --> 00:14:44,792
Someone said that they hadn't
received their settlement
278
00:14:44,793 --> 00:14:47,662
from the archdiocese.
279
00:14:47,663 --> 00:14:48,963
- Alice garvey?
280
00:14:48,964 --> 00:14:52,233
- For years, I carried
the shame of that abuse
281
00:14:52,234 --> 00:14:54,602
without telling a soul.
282
00:14:54,603 --> 00:14:56,037
And I can't do it anymore.
283
00:14:56,038 --> 00:14:59,607
It's-it's time to come clean.
284
00:14:59,608 --> 00:15:02,443
It feels good.
285
00:15:02,444 --> 00:15:05,913
Hiding a secret like that...
286
00:15:05,914 --> 00:15:07,715
Festers.
287
00:15:07,716 --> 00:15:10,317
Makes you rotten inside.
288
00:15:13,755 --> 00:15:16,357
- I'm Ilana, Alice's niece.
289
00:15:16,358 --> 00:15:19,226
- She's in here?
- Yes.
290
00:15:21,596 --> 00:15:24,398
- She was in a car accident
a couple months ago.
291
00:15:24,399 --> 00:15:26,567
Traumatic brain injury.
292
00:15:26,568 --> 00:15:30,938
She could be like this
the rest of her life.
293
00:15:30,939 --> 00:15:34,375
- Body of Christ.
294
00:15:34,376 --> 00:15:38,245
Body of Christ.
- Amen.
295
00:15:38,246 --> 00:15:41,482
The body of Christ.
296
00:15:41,483 --> 00:15:43,784
- I know what you did.
297
00:15:47,789 --> 00:15:51,325
- Last year she won a ten-year
legal battle with the church.
298
00:15:51,326 --> 00:15:53,194
That was before the accident.
299
00:15:53,195 --> 00:15:54,995
- The money never c came.
300
00:15:54,996 --> 00:15:58,499
- Hmm. Does it look it?
301
00:15:58,500 --> 00:16:00,735
- So she won a legal battle,
302
00:16:00,736 --> 00:16:02,803
but then lost her
mental faculties
303
00:16:02,804 --> 00:16:04,105
before she could collect?
304
00:16:04,106 --> 00:16:06,307
- Did you file a complaint
305
00:16:06,308 --> 00:16:09,110
with monsignor McTeal's office?
306
00:16:09,111 --> 00:16:11,045
- He represents the archdiocese.
307
00:16:11,046 --> 00:16:12,813
They said the money was paid,
308
00:16:12,814 --> 00:16:14,548
but that's just not true.
309
00:16:21,923 --> 00:16:24,658
- Monsignor.
310
00:16:24,659 --> 00:16:26,360
- Detectives.
311
00:16:26,361 --> 00:16:30,631
- You met Theresa at the St.
Regis after business hours.
312
00:16:30,632 --> 00:16:33,801
- Yes, we worked together
on a settlement account.
313
00:16:33,802 --> 00:16:36,637
- And what was Mr.
Jenkins doing?
314
00:16:36,638 --> 00:16:39,306
- My anonymity is
sometimes necessary
315
00:16:39,307 --> 00:16:40,841
for sensitive discussions.
316
00:16:40,842 --> 00:16:42,710
- And midnight trysts.
317
00:16:50,185 --> 00:16:52,186
- We discussed business.
318
00:16:52,187 --> 00:16:53,988
- In the shower.
319
00:16:53,989 --> 00:16:56,390
- I'm sorry. Should I know
what you're talking about?
320
00:16:56,391 --> 00:17:00,361
- Yes, you should.
She took a shower.
321
00:17:02,998 --> 00:17:06,333
The business that
you, uh, discussed,
322
00:17:06,334 --> 00:17:08,602
was that Alice
garvey's settlement?
323
00:17:08,603 --> 00:17:11,472
'Cause we just met her niece.
324
00:17:11,473 --> 00:17:14,475
- A relative of Alice garvey's
325
00:17:14,476 --> 00:17:17,645
filed a complaint that she had
not yet received her money.
326
00:17:17,646 --> 00:17:20,014
So I looked into it.
327
00:17:20,015 --> 00:17:21,916
Theresa's pass code was used
328
00:17:21,917 --> 00:17:26,420
to wire Alice garvey's money
into an offshore bank.
329
00:17:26,421 --> 00:17:29,857
- Theresa embezzled
$2.7 million?
330
00:17:29,858 --> 00:17:31,492
- Well, I didn't ask her
to confirm or deny.
331
00:17:31,493 --> 00:17:32,960
I just told her that
she had five days
332
00:17:32,961 --> 00:17:35,296
to put that money back
into the account.
333
00:17:35,297 --> 00:17:37,565
- Spends her career
helping victims
334
00:17:37,566 --> 00:17:39,433
and then she steals
a settlement?
335
00:17:39,434 --> 00:17:41,035
- She found out
garvey was non compos
336
00:17:41,036 --> 00:17:43,070
and grabbed the opportunity.
337
00:17:43,071 --> 00:17:44,772
- Well, if she stole the money,
338
00:17:44,773 --> 00:17:46,473
she-she had to have a reason.
339
00:17:46,474 --> 00:17:47,808
- Greed?
340
00:17:47,809 --> 00:17:49,276
- Yeah, but she lives
within her means.
341
00:17:49,277 --> 00:17:51,111
I mean, she had three pairs
of shoes in her closet.
342
00:17:51,112 --> 00:17:53,047
- Maybe she was sick of it.
343
00:17:53,048 --> 00:17:54,748
- I.T. Retrieved and catalogued
344
00:17:54,749 --> 00:17:59,019
everything on Theresa's
home and office computers.
345
00:18:01,690 --> 00:18:03,657
This was erased from her iPad.
346
00:18:03,658 --> 00:18:06,193
We had to pull it
off the server.
347
00:18:06,194 --> 00:18:08,429
- "To whom it may concern.
348
00:18:08,430 --> 00:18:11,131
I took the money."
349
00:18:11,132 --> 00:18:14,001
Theresa's suicide note?
350
00:18:14,002 --> 00:18:16,837
- Looks like your
case just closed.
351
00:18:21,808 --> 00:18:22,775
We don't buy it.
352
00:18:22,776 --> 00:18:24,043
We need to go further
353
00:18:24,044 --> 00:18:25,511
before we can close
this as a suicide.
354
00:18:25,512 --> 00:18:27,613
- Why, because the
note's on an iPad?
355
00:18:27,614 --> 00:18:30,616
- Because of the embezzlement.
356
00:18:30,617 --> 00:18:32,584
- With that suicide note,
357
00:18:32,585 --> 00:18:36,322
no D.A.
In his right mind would file.
358
00:18:36,323 --> 00:18:40,359
Joe, don't be a moron.
We have legit suspects.
359
00:18:47,334 --> 00:18:49,768
- You give us the room a minute?
360
00:19:01,715 --> 00:19:03,949
Bobby, I appreciate
you coming back.
361
00:19:03,950 --> 00:19:06,352
I really do.
362
00:19:06,353 --> 00:19:11,256
But this doesn't work.
363
00:19:11,257 --> 00:19:13,025
I know what you do.
364
00:19:13,026 --> 00:19:16,028
And you know what I do.
365
00:19:16,029 --> 00:19:18,097
I've got your back,
366
00:19:18,098 --> 00:19:21,900
and you respect my face
and don't get in it.
367
00:19:28,074 --> 00:19:29,675
- Detective goren?
368
00:19:29,676 --> 00:19:31,443
I'm Paula geisen.
369
00:19:31,444 --> 00:19:33,445
Come on in.
370
00:19:33,446 --> 00:19:35,848
- Sorry I'm late.
371
00:19:35,849 --> 00:19:37,649
- Well, it's tough to
get away from your job.
372
00:19:37,650 --> 00:19:42,287
- No excuse.
373
00:19:42,288 --> 00:19:45,224
Your office, it's, uh, striking.
374
00:19:45,225 --> 00:19:46,325
- Thank you.
375
00:19:46,326 --> 00:19:48,694
- These two doors,
376
00:19:48,695 --> 00:19:51,530
they remind me of a riddle.
377
00:19:51,531 --> 00:19:53,098
You know the one?
378
00:19:53,099 --> 00:19:56,168
Two identical doors.
379
00:19:56,169 --> 00:19:58,637
Two identical guards.
380
00:19:58,638 --> 00:20:01,940
One guard is an angel
guarding heaven,
381
00:20:01,941 --> 00:20:03,909
he always tells the truth.
382
00:20:03,910 --> 00:20:07,046
And the other guard is
a devil guarding hell.
383
00:20:07,047 --> 00:20:08,814
He always has to lie.
384
00:20:08,815 --> 00:20:11,116
You have one question to ask
385
00:20:11,117 --> 00:20:14,720
to get into heaven.
386
00:20:14,721 --> 00:20:17,790
What would that question be?
387
00:20:17,791 --> 00:20:18,824
You'll never get it.
388
00:20:18,825 --> 00:20:22,094
It's...You'll...
389
00:20:22,095 --> 00:20:23,896
- Give me time.
390
00:20:23,897 --> 00:20:27,699
- Uh, also the
missed appointments,
391
00:20:27,700 --> 00:20:30,135
I apologize.
392
00:20:30,136 --> 00:20:34,006
- I'm sure you had good
reasons not to come.
393
00:20:34,007 --> 00:20:35,441
- You don't have to do that.
394
00:20:35,442 --> 00:20:38,510
- How do you mean?
- Empathize with me.
395
00:20:38,511 --> 00:20:40,979
- Is that what you
think I'm doing?
396
00:20:40,980 --> 00:20:43,282
- Yeah, "I'm sure you had
reason not to come."
397
00:20:43,283 --> 00:20:45,918
You know, "your job
is too tough...
398
00:20:45,919 --> 00:20:47,386
To get away from."
399
00:20:47,387 --> 00:20:50,789
You're trying to gain my trust.
400
00:20:50,790 --> 00:20:53,926
- I don't think that would
be that easy to do.
401
00:20:56,729 --> 00:20:58,964
- Is that what it
says in my file?
402
00:20:58,965 --> 00:21:00,566
- That?
403
00:21:00,567 --> 00:21:04,203
That's only part of your file.
404
00:21:04,204 --> 00:21:06,905
- Did you accept to do this
405
00:21:06,906 --> 00:21:09,374
before or after you read it?
406
00:21:09,375 --> 00:21:10,843
- After.
407
00:21:10,844 --> 00:21:12,878
- And after the more
experienced psychiatrists
408
00:21:12,879 --> 00:21:13,979
begged off?
409
00:21:13,980 --> 00:21:19,451
- I didn't have to
fight to get you.
410
00:21:19,452 --> 00:21:21,753
And it wasn't only the files.
411
00:21:24,357 --> 00:21:26,558
Seven employer-mandated sessions
412
00:21:26,559 --> 00:21:29,394
with someone...
413
00:21:29,395 --> 00:21:30,729
As challenging as you...
414
00:21:30,730 --> 00:21:35,300
- You were gonna say
"crazy," weren't you?
415
00:21:35,301 --> 00:21:37,503
- Why do you think that?
416
00:21:37,504 --> 00:21:41,440
- Do you think I'm crazy?
417
00:21:41,441 --> 00:21:43,609
- I think you are a person
418
00:21:43,610 --> 00:21:46,979
who is aware that the world
is a dangerous place.
419
00:21:46,980 --> 00:21:49,314
You found a way of surviving,
420
00:21:49,315 --> 00:21:53,218
but your way can
make other people
421
00:21:53,219 --> 00:21:55,521
feel uncomfortable.
422
00:21:58,191 --> 00:22:01,793
- "Challenging" and, you
know, "uncomfortable."
423
00:22:01,794 --> 00:22:04,596
You're walking on egg
shells with me, aren't you?
424
00:22:04,597 --> 00:22:07,266
- Isn't that how you like it?
Hmm?
425
00:22:07,267 --> 00:22:09,434
It's part of your skill set,
426
00:22:09,435 --> 00:22:12,070
like being able to
read people quickly.
427
00:22:15,441 --> 00:22:16,675
- It's my job.
428
00:22:16,676 --> 00:22:17,776
- Sure.
429
00:22:17,777 --> 00:22:19,645
It's protected you.
430
00:22:19,646 --> 00:22:22,181
But it's also taken its toll
431
00:22:22,182 --> 00:22:26,218
on those around you
and on yourself.
432
00:22:26,219 --> 00:22:28,921
You are exceptional
at analyzing others.
433
00:22:28,922 --> 00:22:32,791
Exceptional.
434
00:22:32,792 --> 00:22:35,594
So what is it that you
think will happen
435
00:22:35,595 --> 00:22:37,996
if you start looking
at yourself?
436
00:22:45,572 --> 00:22:47,172
- I didn't tell you
about the embezzlement
437
00:22:47,173 --> 00:22:48,740
because I didn't know.
438
00:22:48,741 --> 00:22:51,610
- So overseeing accounts isn't
part of the job description?
439
00:22:51,611 --> 00:22:53,612
- Oversee, not monitor
every transaction.
440
00:22:53,613 --> 00:22:56,582
- 2.7 million didn't
warrant your attention?
441
00:22:56,583 --> 00:22:57,983
- It's a great deal of money,
442
00:22:57,984 --> 00:22:59,451
but it's not an
atypical settlement.
443
00:22:59,452 --> 00:23:01,353
- Plus we thought we'd
settled with Alice garvey.
444
00:23:01,354 --> 00:23:02,821
We sent her the papers.
445
00:23:02,822 --> 00:23:07,859
- You said that you watched
mediation DVDs with Theresa.
446
00:23:07,860 --> 00:23:10,095
- Yeah, I did.
447
00:23:10,096 --> 00:23:12,097
- She was looking for
God's perfect match.
448
00:23:12,098 --> 00:23:13,865
Maybe you were it.
449
00:23:13,866 --> 00:23:15,801
- She was my boss.
We were just friends.
450
00:23:15,802 --> 00:23:18,103
- We are gonna let our lawyers
handle things from here on in.
451
00:23:18,104 --> 00:23:20,072
Obviously, we'll be doing
our own investigation.
452
00:23:20,073 --> 00:23:21,440
- So will we.
453
00:23:21,441 --> 00:23:23,275
There was a lamp on this table,
454
00:23:23,276 --> 00:23:25,077
and her pictures are gone.
455
00:23:25,078 --> 00:23:26,478
- Johnny let a friend of hers
456
00:23:26,479 --> 00:23:28,213
come in and take some of
her personal effects.
457
00:23:28,214 --> 00:23:30,315
- Is that Natalie?
458
00:23:30,316 --> 00:23:32,117
- Uh, yeah, they were buddies.
459
00:23:32,118 --> 00:23:33,719
- You let someone remove
possible evidence
460
00:23:33,720 --> 00:23:36,054
from an ongoing investigation?
461
00:23:36,055 --> 00:23:37,823
- We're bankers, not police.
462
00:23:40,893 --> 00:23:43,228
- Uh, I went to her office
463
00:23:43,229 --> 00:23:45,497
to box up her things
for her parents.
464
00:23:45,498 --> 00:23:47,065
I ran into Johnny.
465
00:23:47,066 --> 00:23:48,667
We talked a little.
466
00:23:48,668 --> 00:23:50,736
- Googled you.
467
00:23:50,737 --> 00:23:53,972
You were 57th in the
tennis rankings at 18.
468
00:23:53,973 --> 00:23:56,508
- Oh, ancient history.
469
00:23:56,509 --> 00:24:00,012
- Then drug possession and
petty theft in your 20s.
470
00:24:00,013 --> 00:24:03,081
And now you're over
$70,000 in debt.
471
00:24:03,082 --> 00:24:08,654
- 73,600, to be exact.
472
00:24:10,556 --> 00:24:11,690
- That's a cute cat.
473
00:24:11,691 --> 00:24:14,960
- Oh, um, name's pyewacket.
474
00:24:14,961 --> 00:24:17,429
- Pyewacket?
475
00:24:17,430 --> 00:24:18,497
That's from a...
476
00:24:18,498 --> 00:24:21,233
Jimmy Stewart film.
477
00:24:21,234 --> 00:24:27,372
Yeah, the cat, it was Kim
novak's best friend.
478
00:24:27,373 --> 00:24:29,608
It's a funny movie.
479
00:24:29,609 --> 00:24:31,410
I think the cat was a wizard.
480
00:24:31,411 --> 00:24:32,377
Not very catholic.
481
00:24:32,378 --> 00:24:35,047
- It's a cat.
482
00:24:35,048 --> 00:24:38,884
- So you and Theresa were
roommates at Georgetown.
483
00:24:38,885 --> 00:24:40,585
Very catholic.
484
00:24:40,586 --> 00:24:42,854
- She got me into rehab.
485
00:24:42,855 --> 00:24:45,190
Back into the church.
486
00:24:45,191 --> 00:24:47,693
- Did you know that-
that Theresa was accused
487
00:24:47,694 --> 00:24:49,561
of, uh, stealing
millions of dollars
488
00:24:49,562 --> 00:24:51,630
from the church
settlement account?
489
00:24:55,201 --> 00:24:57,369
Yeah, I know, it...
490
00:24:57,370 --> 00:24:58,904
Doesn't make sense.
491
00:24:58,905 --> 00:25:01,506
But there must have
been a reason.
492
00:25:01,507 --> 00:25:04,643
She didn't have a lot of
experience with men, did she?
493
00:25:04,644 --> 00:25:06,778
- How many straight,
single men in their 30s
494
00:25:06,779 --> 00:25:09,414
are still practicing catholics
and not total weirdoes?
495
00:25:09,415 --> 00:25:13,385
- Johnny's pretty cute.
How about him?
496
00:25:13,386 --> 00:25:15,954
- She was his boss. No way.
497
00:25:21,127 --> 00:25:25,964
- You're lying.
498
00:25:25,965 --> 00:25:27,532
- Okay.
499
00:25:27,533 --> 00:25:29,935
I mean, maybe they
hooked up once or tw&e,
500
00:25:29,936 --> 00:25:31,470
but it-it was casual.
501
00:25:31,471 --> 00:25:32,971
- They were friends, though.
502
00:25:32,972 --> 00:25:35,874
I mean, she liked him, though.
503
00:25:35,875 --> 00:25:38,110
- Yeah.
504
00:25:38,111 --> 00:25:40,345
A lot.
505
00:25:47,353 --> 00:25:49,721
- You lied to us, Johnny.
506
00:25:53,092 --> 00:25:57,662
- Johnny.
You slept with your boss.
507
00:25:57,663 --> 00:26:00,799
- All right, I'll
be honest with you,
508
00:26:00,800 --> 00:26:04,936
I didn't want to admit it
in front of kilpatrick.
509
00:26:04,937 --> 00:26:06,538
- Can't be that dumb.
510
00:26:06,539 --> 00:26:09,908
I mean, lying to two cops in
a homicide investigation?
511
00:26:09,909 --> 00:26:13,111
Really?
Did you just cop to a felony?
512
00:26:13,112 --> 00:26:15,914
- We hooked up a month ago.
513
00:26:15,915 --> 00:26:16,915
It was no big deal.
514
00:26:16,916 --> 00:26:18,550
Once, maybe twice.
515
00:26:18,551 --> 00:26:21,319
- So the pillow talk wasn't
about where to stash the 2.7?
516
00:26:21,320 --> 00:26:23,588
- This sounds like
I need a lawyer.
517
00:26:23,589 --> 00:26:25,757
- Do you need a lawyer?
I don't know.
518
00:26:25,758 --> 00:26:26,925
Right now you're just a...
519
00:26:26,926 --> 00:26:28,460
you're a person of interest.
520
00:26:28,461 --> 00:26:32,364
Lawyer up, well, that takes you
straight up to maybe suspect.
521
00:26:32,365 --> 00:26:34,866
- You guys, I didn't
steal the money.
522
00:26:35,868 --> 00:26:37,335
The night Theresa died,
523
00:26:37,336 --> 00:26:39,137
she called me and told
me that monsignor McTeal
524
00:26:39,138 --> 00:26:41,273
accused her of embezzlement.
525
00:26:41,274 --> 00:26:43,809
The next day Natalie told me
526
00:26:43,810 --> 00:26:45,911
he asked Theresa for sex
527
00:26:45,912 --> 00:26:49,681
in exchange for giving her five
days to replace the money.
528
00:26:49,682 --> 00:26:50,949
- What was your reaction?
529
00:26:50,950 --> 00:26:53,185
- I wanted to kill the bastard.
530
00:26:53,186 --> 00:26:57,322
I figured it had to be
an accounting mistake.
531
00:26:57,323 --> 00:26:58,790
- No, no, no. She stole it.
532
00:26:58,791 --> 00:27:00,025
There's no question about that.
533
00:27:00,026 --> 00:27:03,728
- No. You're wrong.
534
00:27:03,729 --> 00:27:05,297
We both felt the same way.
535
00:27:05,298 --> 00:27:07,599
The only people that
deserved that money
536
00:27:07,600 --> 00:27:10,168
are victims.
537
00:27:11,904 --> 00:27:15,640
- So the monsignor forced
Theresa to have sex
538
00:27:15,641 --> 00:27:17,576
quid pro quo
539
00:27:17,577 --> 00:27:20,245
for giving her five days
to return the money?
540
00:27:20,246 --> 00:27:22,881
- She's so remorseful,
she kills herself.
541
00:27:25,518 --> 00:27:27,752
- Five days to return the money,
542
00:27:27,753 --> 00:27:32,591
she goes home and kills herself.
543
00:27:32,592 --> 00:27:34,593
You know, look at this.
544
00:27:34,594 --> 00:27:37,796
Uh...
545
00:27:37,797 --> 00:27:39,698
"What I have now done
546
00:27:39,699 --> 00:27:41,600
was the only path left for me."
547
00:27:41,601 --> 00:27:44,002
- So formal.
- Yeah.
548
00:27:44,003 --> 00:27:45,704
- Here all night?
549
00:27:45,705 --> 00:27:47,772
- You bring bagels?
550
00:27:47,773 --> 00:27:51,176
- See, men, women, they
leave different markers
551
00:27:51,177 --> 00:27:53,144
when they write suicide notes.
552
00:27:53,145 --> 00:27:55,981
Women seem to rely more heavily
553
00:27:55,982 --> 00:27:58,149
on expression of feelings,
554
00:27:58,150 --> 00:28:00,986
like, um, thanking someone.
555
00:28:00,987 --> 00:28:03,288
You know, polite speech.
Apologizing.
556
00:28:03,289 --> 00:28:04,656
- She was close to her parents,
557
00:28:04,657 --> 00:28:06,491
and they're not even mentioned.
558
00:28:06,492 --> 00:28:07,859
- Yes.
559
00:28:12,064 --> 00:28:15,667
"I acted out of greed
and poor character."
560
00:28:15,668 --> 00:28:17,335
See, now that's a
direct admission,
561
00:28:17,336 --> 00:28:21,006
but there's no reference
to God or the Bible,
562
00:28:21,007 --> 00:28:24,309
or any misgivings for breaking
the eighth commandment.
563
00:28:24,310 --> 00:28:28,246
- The $2.7 million question is...
564
00:28:28,247 --> 00:28:30,549
Why was it erased?
565
00:28:30,550 --> 00:28:32,784
- Yeah, I don't know.
566
00:28:32,785 --> 00:28:37,756
But I do know that
she didn't write it.
567
00:28:37,757 --> 00:28:42,127
The killer wants her death
to look like a suicide,
568
00:28:42,128 --> 00:28:46,131
but he puts the gun four
feet away from the body.
569
00:28:46,132 --> 00:28:48,667
Doesn't make any sense.
570
00:28:48,668 --> 00:28:50,368
- The cat.
571
00:28:50,369 --> 00:28:52,537
- Yes, I have pyewacket.
572
00:28:52,538 --> 00:28:54,639
I decided to keep him.
573
00:28:54,640 --> 00:28:57,175
- You ever feed him when
Theresa worked late,
574
00:28:57,176 --> 00:28:59,210
or when she was out of town?
575
00:28:59,211 --> 00:29:01,479
- Um, can I get
back to my lesson?
576
00:29:01,480 --> 00:29:03,548
- So you have your own
key to her apartment?
577
00:29:03,549 --> 00:29:05,183
- No.
578
00:29:05,184 --> 00:29:07,185
- Is that why you asked the
building super to let you in?
579
00:29:07,186 --> 00:29:08,920
- Right.
580
00:29:08,921 --> 00:29:11,323
- You wanted him
to corroborate you
581
00:29:11,324 --> 00:29:13,191
finding the dead body.
582
00:29:13,192 --> 00:29:15,694
But you already
knew she was dead.
583
00:29:15,695 --> 00:29:19,864
- I don't have a key.
584
00:29:19,865 --> 00:29:21,466
- Well, we got a warrant.
585
00:29:21,467 --> 00:29:23,702
We searched your apartment.
586
00:29:28,140 --> 00:29:31,242
- Fine. I had a key.
587
00:29:31,243 --> 00:29:34,846
- Neighbor says she saw you
heading up the stairs at 8:15.
588
00:29:34,847 --> 00:29:38,249
Constantine says you
got him at 8:35.
589
00:29:38,250 --> 00:29:40,018
Maybe you found a way
590
00:29:40,019 --> 00:29:42,354
to access Theresa's
account at work.
591
00:29:42,355 --> 00:29:45,523
When Theresa tipped onto
it, you killed her.
592
00:29:45,524 --> 00:29:49,661
- That's ridiculous.
She was my best friend.
593
00:29:49,662 --> 00:29:55,500
- Uh, now she turned
your life around.
594
00:29:55,501 --> 00:29:57,702
Didn't she?
595
00:29:57,703 --> 00:30:02,674
And you'd do anything
to protect her.
596
00:30:02,675 --> 00:30:04,442
And in the eyes of
the catholic church,
597
00:30:04,443 --> 00:30:07,178
a suicide is the same as murder.
598
00:30:13,085 --> 00:30:16,354
- When Tess didn't answer,
599
00:30:16,355 --> 00:30:19,858
I let myself in.
600
00:30:19,859 --> 00:30:22,293
I found her on the
floor of the bedroom,
601
00:30:22,294 --> 00:30:24,396
and she'd shot herself.
602
00:30:27,266 --> 00:30:29,501
She wouldn't be
able to have a mass
603
00:30:29,502 --> 00:30:32,604
or be buried in
consecrated ground.
604
00:30:32,605 --> 00:30:35,640
- So you kicked the gun away
and you repositioned the body.
605
00:30:35,641 --> 00:30:40,311
- She committed suicide, but
the monsignor was responsible.
606
00:30:40,312 --> 00:30:43,782
- That's why you erased the
suicide note on her iPad.
607
00:30:47,887 --> 00:30:50,655
- What suicide note?
608
00:30:59,355 --> 00:31:01,522
Natalie admits she
dutched the crime scene.
609
00:31:01,523 --> 00:31:02,423
That's obstruction.
610
00:31:02,458 --> 00:31:04,659
- So who erased
the suicide note?
611
00:31:04,660 --> 00:31:07,996
- Not Natalie. The killer?
612
00:31:07,997 --> 00:31:09,464
- Why?
613
00:31:09,465 --> 00:31:11,966
- As a fail-safe.
614
00:31:11,967 --> 00:31:13,902
Police close the
case as a suicide,
615
00:31:13,903 --> 00:31:15,437
then he's home free.
616
00:31:15,438 --> 00:31:17,706
If not, then he knows that
they'll scrub her computers
617
00:31:17,707 --> 00:31:19,107
and find the note.
618
00:31:19,108 --> 00:31:23,011
- Natalie said Hugh
McTeal extorted Theresa.
619
00:31:23,012 --> 00:31:25,213
- She didn't realllly
say that, captain.
620
00:31:25,214 --> 00:31:26,548
- Maybe not word for word,
621
00:31:26,549 --> 00:31:30,151
but close enough.
622
00:31:30,152 --> 00:31:32,887
Let's bring him in and sweat
him for suspicion of rape.
623
00:31:35,024 --> 00:31:39,728
- Did you rape Theresa Esperna?
624
00:31:39,729 --> 00:31:40,829
- Absolutely not.
625
00:31:40,830 --> 00:31:42,497
Is that why you
brought me in here?
626
00:31:42,498 --> 00:31:43,798
- Look, if your strategy
627
00:31:43,799 --> 00:31:45,133
is to drag the church
through the mud...
628
00:31:45,134 --> 00:31:47,702
- we have no agenda
against the church.
629
00:31:47,703 --> 00:31:49,904
For every story you
hear of misconduct,
630
00:31:49,905 --> 00:31:53,375
there are thousands of
stories of good works.
631
00:31:53,376 --> 00:31:55,210
- Well, that's the first
632
00:31:55,211 --> 00:31:58,413
true thing you've said
all day, detective.
633
00:31:58,414 --> 00:32:00,582
- You know, I was thinking,
634
00:32:00,583 --> 00:32:04,119
you know, an episcopalian
priest can...
635
00:32:04,120 --> 00:32:05,186
well, they can have a wife,
636
00:32:05,187 --> 00:32:07,422
and a lutheran pastor,
637
00:32:07,423 --> 00:32:09,124
they can date a playmate.
638
00:32:09,125 --> 00:32:12,026
You have, uh, vows of chastity.
639
00:32:12,027 --> 00:32:13,828
- Mm.
640
00:32:13,829 --> 00:32:16,698
A vocation demands sacrifice.
641
00:32:16,699 --> 00:32:20,402
- Jeez, it must be...
Frustrating.
642
00:32:22,004 --> 00:32:24,139
- Temptation is a test
643
00:32:24,140 --> 00:32:25,373
that God gives all of us.
644
00:32:25,374 --> 00:32:27,041
- Well, it seems to be
a test you're failing.
645
00:32:27,042 --> 00:32:28,543
- I'm no different
from any other man.
646
00:32:28,544 --> 00:32:30,478
How about you, detective goren?
647
00:32:30,479 --> 00:32:32,414
Any frailties of your own?
648
00:32:32,415 --> 00:32:34,015
- Look, we're within
a minute of walking
649
00:32:34,016 --> 00:32:38,353
if we don't hear a charge.
650
00:32:38,354 --> 00:32:39,788
- You can...
651
00:32:39,789 --> 00:32:43,825
Love the church for
their good works,
652
00:32:43,826 --> 00:32:45,360
or you can hate the church
653
00:32:45,361 --> 00:32:49,164
for their...Hypocrisy.
654
00:32:49,165 --> 00:32:53,568
Tick tock.
Ti- how much time do I have left?
655
00:32:53,569 --> 00:32:56,104
Go ahead. No. How much?
656
00:33:01,577 --> 00:33:05,113
But both sides agree...
657
00:33:07,349 --> 00:33:10,485
Thou shalt not kill.
658
00:33:10,486 --> 00:33:14,088
- I did not kill Theresa.
659
00:33:14,089 --> 00:33:15,990
- Okay, forget about the murder.
660
00:33:15,991 --> 00:33:19,794
Theresa's friend says you
forced her to have sex.
661
00:33:19,795 --> 00:33:21,129
- Never happened.
662
00:33:21,130 --> 00:33:24,265
- Well, there's no way we
can prove it forensically,
663
00:33:24,266 --> 00:33:28,269
because you're careful,
and used a condom.
664
00:33:28,270 --> 00:33:29,704
Oh, I forgot.
665
00:33:29,705 --> 00:33:32,707
That's another sin, isn't it?
666
00:33:32,708 --> 00:33:35,410
You're...
667
00:33:35,411 --> 00:33:36,945
The consoler?
668
00:33:36,946 --> 00:33:38,313
- Don't push it, detective.
669
00:33:38,314 --> 00:33:40,648
- You take advantage
of vulnerable women.
670
00:33:40,649 --> 00:33:43,485
Isn't that the basis
of the scandal?
671
00:33:43,486 --> 00:33:45,353
Priests taking advantage
of the vulnerable.
672
00:33:45,354 --> 00:33:46,955
- I'm not a molester.
673
00:33:46,956 --> 00:33:48,223
- But you broke your vows.
674
00:33:48,224 --> 00:33:50,859
- I feed 35,000 orphans
in five boroughs.
675
00:33:50,860 --> 00:33:52,861
- Yeah, and you're held
to a higher standard.
676
00:33:52,862 --> 00:33:54,829
- I built a cancer
hospital last year.
677
00:33:54,830 --> 00:33:58,032
- Did you know that
Theresa showered twice
678
00:33:58,033 --> 00:33:59,667
after visiting you at the St.
Regis?
679
00:34:03,572 --> 00:34:06,541
Twice.
680
00:34:06,542 --> 00:34:08,810
What do you think about
that, monsignor?
681
00:34:08,811 --> 00:34:14,516
As evidence of a guilty
mind or a tortured soul?
682
00:34:14,517 --> 00:34:17,685
She was disgusted by you.
683
00:34:17,686 --> 00:34:21,456
She scrubbed every place
that you touched her.
684
00:34:31,166 --> 00:34:32,934
- Hmm.
685
00:34:32,935 --> 00:34:36,938
Well, you got me, detective.
686
00:34:36,939 --> 00:34:39,974
Yep.
687
00:34:39,975 --> 00:34:41,676
I occasionally have
sex with women.
688
00:34:46,482 --> 00:34:49,150
Consenting women.
689
00:34:49,151 --> 00:34:50,985
It's a flaw that
I'm not proud of.
690
00:34:50,986 --> 00:34:53,821
That does not, however,
make me a murderer.
691
00:35:08,003 --> 00:35:10,838
Cardinal.
692
00:35:10,839 --> 00:35:14,142
I, uh...
693
00:35:20,749 --> 00:35:23,418
- I'll see you in my
office in the morning.
694
00:35:30,960 --> 00:35:34,429
- You got some
hail Marys coming.
695
00:35:43,672 --> 00:35:45,440
- Slime.
696
00:35:45,441 --> 00:35:47,742
- But smart.
697
00:35:47,743 --> 00:35:50,678
Picked on women who aren't
gonna go after the settlement.
698
00:35:50,679 --> 00:35:51,946
He'll stick to his story
699
00:35:51,947 --> 00:35:54,382
that Theresa was
embezzling the money.
700
00:35:54,383 --> 00:35:56,951
- Johnny admitted
Theresa told him
701
00:35:56,952 --> 00:35:59,053
about the embezzlement
before she died.
702
00:35:59,054 --> 00:36:00,488
- But not the sex.
703
00:36:00,489 --> 00:36:03,057
- She told Natalie about
sex with the monsignor.
704
00:36:03,058 --> 00:36:04,559
- But not the theft.
705
00:36:04,560 --> 00:36:06,561
- A confession in two parts.
706
00:36:06,562 --> 00:36:08,763
- Either way, she
betrayed her faith.
707
00:36:08,764 --> 00:36:12,767
- This is about her faith.
708
00:36:12,768 --> 00:36:14,002
She did it for someone.
709
00:36:14,003 --> 00:36:16,571
Someone who she thought
deserved the money.
710
00:36:40,062 --> 00:36:43,331
Sorry.
711
00:36:43,332 --> 00:36:45,566
Let me just, uh...
712
00:36:49,304 --> 00:36:51,139
Whoo!
713
00:36:56,845 --> 00:36:58,445
Okay.
714
00:37:01,650 --> 00:37:06,888
Two weeks ago, the monsignor
gave a gun to Theresa,
715
00:37:06,889 --> 00:37:10,391
because of an angry abuse victim
716
00:37:10,392 --> 00:37:14,062
who felt that he was
cheated out of, uh...
717
00:37:14,063 --> 00:37:17,165
His payoff.
718
00:37:17,166 --> 00:37:20,601
- Uh, he was harmless.
Just angry.
719
00:37:20,602 --> 00:37:22,503
- Now, that was
around the same time
720
00:37:22,504 --> 00:37:25,206
that you and Theresa were...
721
00:37:28,043 --> 00:37:31,946
Uh...
722
00:37:31,947 --> 00:37:35,550
You know, knocking boots.
723
00:37:35,551 --> 00:37:37,118
- That's crassly correct.
724
00:37:37,119 --> 00:37:39,387
- What's your point, detective?
725
00:37:42,157 --> 00:37:45,126
- Well, I think that...
726
00:37:45,127 --> 00:37:48,496
That you told Theresa something...
727
00:37:48,497 --> 00:37:51,165
That you never
told another soul.
728
00:37:57,039 --> 00:38:01,075
.451.
729
00:38:01,076 --> 00:38:02,777
Freshman year's batting average.
730
00:38:02,778 --> 00:38:04,645
I mean, wow.
731
00:38:04,646 --> 00:38:06,180
I think that's amazing.
732
00:38:06,181 --> 00:38:08,049
You know.
733
00:38:08,050 --> 00:38:10,318
All right, look.
734
00:38:10,319 --> 00:38:12,386
I mean, you must
have been, what?
735
00:38:12,387 --> 00:38:14,288
15?
736
00:38:17,092 --> 00:38:19,460
.451?
737
00:38:19,461 --> 00:38:21,696
You must have been
in great shape.
738
00:38:21,697 --> 00:38:23,164
Freshman year.
739
00:38:23,165 --> 00:38:26,167
I have, uh, this marked here.
740
00:38:26,168 --> 00:38:28,069
There's father Duffy.
741
00:38:28,070 --> 00:38:32,273
Now, he was the varsity
baseball coach
742
00:38:32,274 --> 00:38:35,476
who was fired for...
743
00:38:35,477 --> 00:38:40,414
For improper relations.
744
00:38:40,415 --> 00:38:42,650
- I remember father Duffy.
745
00:38:50,259 --> 00:38:53,661
- Do you know how much
746
00:38:53,662 --> 00:38:57,098
the Franklin county
settlement was
747
00:38:57,099 --> 00:38:59,367
to each abuse victim?
748
00:38:59,368 --> 00:39:02,570
After the parish went bankrupt?
749
00:39:02,571 --> 00:39:05,339
Do you know? It was $11,000.
750
00:39:05,340 --> 00:39:08,976
So Alice garvey got 2.7 million,
751
00:39:08,977 --> 00:39:11,212
and you got 11 grand.
752
00:39:11,213 --> 00:39:12,780
- I wasn't molested.
753
00:39:12,781 --> 00:39:16,818
- Come on, Johnny.
754
00:39:16,819 --> 00:39:18,486
Come on.
755
00:39:18,487 --> 00:39:19,921
You of all people know
756
00:39:19,922 --> 00:39:22,690
that denial is common among...
757
00:39:22,691 --> 00:39:27,428
Abuse victims.
758
00:39:27,429 --> 00:39:29,564
I mean, that's why you didn't
have any baseball pictures
759
00:39:29,565 --> 00:39:33,267
from Franklin catholic
in your office.
760
00:39:37,773 --> 00:39:42,944
Did you know that abuse victims,
761
00:39:42,945 --> 00:39:44,412
they try and attach themselves,
762
00:39:44,413 --> 00:39:48,549
in many cases, to their abuser.
763
00:39:48,550 --> 00:39:51,886
Like a man who works in a bank,
764
00:39:51,887 --> 00:39:54,889
whose main client is
the catholic church...
765
00:39:54,890 --> 00:39:56,791
- I took the job
because the church
766
00:39:56,792 --> 00:39:58,359
is helping victims of abuse.
767
00:39:58,360 --> 00:40:02,196
- Yes, that's right.
768
00:40:02,197 --> 00:40:04,165
Right.
769
00:40:04,166 --> 00:40:05,600
So there Theresa is.
770
00:40:05,601 --> 00:40:10,338
Now, she's writing multi-million
dollar settlement checks.
771
00:40:10,339 --> 00:40:11,772
Every day.
772
00:40:11,773 --> 00:40:15,209
Uh, helping people that
she didn't even know.
773
00:40:17,613 --> 00:40:19,213
And you got stiffed
in Franklin county.
774
00:40:19,214 --> 00:40:20,381
- I wasn't molested.
775
00:40:20,382 --> 00:40:24,785
- Giving you a fair
settlement was impossible.
776
00:40:24,786 --> 00:40:26,153
You know, what was she gonna do?
777
00:40:26,154 --> 00:40:29,357
You know, write you a check?
778
00:40:34,296 --> 00:40:38,633
When did you find out about
Alice garvey's car accident?
779
00:40:43,171 --> 00:40:48,042
Was that the night that you
hooked up with Theresa?
780
00:40:48,043 --> 00:40:51,479
You slithered into
this lonely woman,
781
00:40:51,480 --> 00:40:56,484
this woman who had sympathy
for the abuse you suffered.
782
00:40:56,485 --> 00:40:57,818
- That's not what happened.
783
00:40:57,819 --> 00:40:59,620
- There's absolutely no
proof that he was...
784
00:40:59,621 --> 00:41:00,821
- come on, Johnny!
785
00:41:00,822 --> 00:41:04,625
Come on!
786
00:41:04,626 --> 00:41:06,160
What could you do?
787
00:41:06,161 --> 00:41:07,762
I mean, you weren't gonna
give the money back.
788
00:41:07,763 --> 00:41:10,031
You deserved it. Right?
789
00:41:10,032 --> 00:41:13,334
You deserved it for the
vile and disgusting things
790
00:41:13,335 --> 00:41:16,270
that father Duffy did to you.
791
00:41:16,271 --> 00:41:19,807
And Theresa was the only
one that knew the truth.
792
00:41:24,413 --> 00:41:27,615
And the truth would
die with her.
793
00:41:27,616 --> 00:41:29,216
So what'd you do?
794
00:41:29,217 --> 00:41:31,786
You went over there, you
opened a bottle of wine,
795
00:41:31,787 --> 00:41:35,089
you popped a pill in her glass.
796
00:41:35,090 --> 00:41:39,260
She drank it, she got wasted.
797
00:41:39,261 --> 00:41:40,261
And boom!
798
00:41:40,262 --> 00:41:42,063
- No.
799
00:41:45,267 --> 00:41:47,268
- Father Duffy took
advantage of you.
800
00:41:47,269 --> 00:41:50,871
You took advantage of Theresa.
801
00:41:50,872 --> 00:41:53,607
And the abused
became the abuser.
802
00:42:03,552 --> 00:42:05,619
The iPad note?
803
00:42:05,620 --> 00:42:07,688
Remember that?
804
00:42:07,689 --> 00:42:10,925
You know, I always knew that...
805
00:42:10,926 --> 00:42:12,626
that she didn't write it,
806
00:42:12,627 --> 00:42:14,562
but I-I was up all night
807
00:42:14,563 --> 00:42:16,964
trying to figure out
what it really was.
808
00:42:20,202 --> 00:42:21,602
Your confession.
809
00:42:21,603 --> 00:42:24,538
"To whom it may concern.
810
00:42:24,539 --> 00:42:26,040
"I took the money.
811
00:42:26,041 --> 00:42:28,576
"I acted out of greed
812
00:42:28,577 --> 00:42:30,411
"and poor character.
813
00:42:30,412 --> 00:42:33,080
"Shame was too much to bear.
814
00:42:33,081 --> 00:42:37,518
"What I have now done was
the only path left for me.
815
00:42:37,519 --> 00:42:40,821
"I had no choice.
816
00:42:40,822 --> 00:42:45,359
Johnny."
817
00:42:45,360 --> 00:42:48,529
- I didn't mean to kill her.
818
00:42:48,530 --> 00:42:51,432
I didn't want to kill her.
819
00:43:00,509 --> 00:43:03,444
- No, you didn't mean to.
820
00:43:03,445 --> 00:43:07,181
You didn't want to.
821
00:43:07,182 --> 00:43:09,850
But you did.