1
00:00:02,302 --> 00:00:04,600
Give me everything you got! Now!
Ripped By mstoll
2
00:00:06,406 --> 00:00:07,464
Are you deaf?
3
00:00:11,711 --> 00:00:12,905
Come on!
4
00:00:14,047 --> 00:00:15,537
Please, I don't want any trouble.
5
00:00:15,715 --> 00:00:17,046
[GRUNTS]
6
00:00:30,130 --> 00:00:31,529
[GUNSHOT]
7
00:00:42,008 --> 00:00:44,875
Please, I don't want any trouble!
8
00:00:45,045 --> 00:00:46,205
[SHOUTS]
9
00:00:57,223 --> 00:00:58,781
JOEY:
Dr. Watson?
10
00:01:00,593 --> 00:01:02,322
- Joey.
- Hey.
11
00:01:02,495 --> 00:01:03,962
Hi.
12
00:01:04,130 --> 00:01:05,688
Long time. Been a while, huh?
13
00:01:05,865 --> 00:01:07,662
- Yeah. What, three years?
- Yeah.
14
00:01:07,834 --> 00:01:09,734
Uh, you remembered Dad's birthday.
15
00:01:09,903 --> 00:01:11,837
Well, a day late, but yeah.
16
00:01:12,005 --> 00:01:13,597
- Heh.
- You caught me. Heh.
17
00:01:14,641 --> 00:01:18,099
Nice thing about coming the day after,
you're less likely to run into my mom.
18
00:01:21,714 --> 00:01:25,047
It's nice of you to come
and see him.
19
00:01:26,453 --> 00:01:27,818
I liked him.
20
00:01:29,055 --> 00:01:30,613
He was a good man.
21
00:01:32,425 --> 00:01:34,120
You're a good doctor.
22
00:01:47,207 --> 00:01:49,675
Hey, let me buy you a coffee.
We can catch up.
23
00:01:49,843 --> 00:01:52,368
I'm supposed to meet
a friend I work with, so...
24
00:01:52,545 --> 00:01:53,842
Come on, just one cup.
25
00:01:58,685 --> 00:02:00,380
BELL:
I don't think we're wrapped up here.
26
00:02:00,553 --> 00:02:03,078
Why don't we make one more sweep,
make sure we got pictures?
27
00:02:03,256 --> 00:02:06,521
And then police have been stationed at
the hospital in case Benny wakes up.
28
00:02:06,693 --> 00:02:09,753
- Somebody from the team.
- Detective Bell, sorry I'm late.
29
00:02:09,929 --> 00:02:11,157
BELL:
You're not late.
30
00:02:11,331 --> 00:02:13,822
You texted me you heard on
your scanner there'd been a shooting.
31
00:02:14,000 --> 00:02:15,865
I texted back, told you
I didn't need any help.
32
00:02:16,035 --> 00:02:18,367
Actually you wrote, and I quote,
33
00:02:18,538 --> 00:02:21,473
"Yes, please, now." Triple-smiley face,
with tongue protruding.
34
00:02:21,641 --> 00:02:22,938
What?
35
00:02:23,109 --> 00:02:24,440
Yeah, see, that's not from me.
36
00:02:24,611 --> 00:02:27,307
That's from someone named Bella,
and you got it last December.
37
00:02:27,480 --> 00:02:30,677
My name is Bell, no A, but I can see
how you might have confused us.
38
00:02:30,850 --> 00:02:33,751
- Not like you're into details or anything.
- How embarrassing.
39
00:02:33,920 --> 00:02:35,911
Anyway, now that I'm here...
40
00:02:38,925 --> 00:02:43,089
Vic's name is Felix Soto.
He's a math tutor. Lives here alone.
41
00:02:47,834 --> 00:02:50,268
I was under the impression
that two men had been shot.
42
00:02:50,436 --> 00:02:53,269
Two were. Second victim,
guy named Benny Charles,
43
00:02:53,439 --> 00:02:56,602
was shot in the driveway
right out there.
44
00:02:56,776 --> 00:02:59,472
Funny thing is, far as we can tell,
they didn't know each other.
45
00:02:59,646 --> 00:03:03,104
About 90 seconds before
Mr. Charles got shot last night,
46
00:03:03,283 --> 00:03:05,012
he mugged someone
around the corner.
47
00:03:05,185 --> 00:03:07,983
I think he ducked into the driveway
to count his loot.
48
00:03:09,389 --> 00:03:11,516
Wrong place, wrong time?
49
00:03:11,958 --> 00:03:14,859
- Unless you believe in karma.
- Yeah.
50
00:03:15,895 --> 00:03:19,194
So I'm assuming from the absence
of his body that Mr. Charles survived.
51
00:03:19,365 --> 00:03:22,926
Barely. First officers on the scene
managed to stop the bleeding,
52
00:03:23,102 --> 00:03:26,003
but he never regained consciousness.
He's in surgery now.
53
00:03:26,172 --> 00:03:28,037
I'm hearing it doesn't look good.
54
00:03:28,775 --> 00:03:32,142
Hey, where's your better half
this morning?
55
00:03:32,879 --> 00:03:35,347
One mystery at a time,
detective. So...
56
00:03:37,150 --> 00:03:40,017
Not much evidence to suggest
it was a robbery gone wrong.
57
00:03:40,186 --> 00:03:42,086
Too many valuables
have been left behind.
58
00:03:42,255 --> 00:03:45,520
A neighbor heard Mr. Soto arguing
with another man a few nights ago,
59
00:03:45,692 --> 00:03:47,284
but never got a good look at the guy.
60
00:03:47,460 --> 00:03:48,893
We're reaching out to his family,
61
00:03:49,062 --> 00:03:51,155
see if they can think of anyone
who had beef with him.
62
00:03:52,799 --> 00:03:54,858
Interesting space, huh?
63
00:03:55,034 --> 00:03:56,399
Minimalist.
64
00:03:56,803 --> 00:03:59,897
The other rooms aren't.
There's art and pictures hung up.
65
00:04:00,073 --> 00:04:03,474
I wondered for a second if
maybe the shooter took some down,
66
00:04:03,643 --> 00:04:05,304
but aren't any nail holes.
67
00:04:05,478 --> 00:04:06,638
Heh.
68
00:04:07,413 --> 00:04:08,937
You always been this observant?
69
00:04:11,484 --> 00:04:12,815
I'm asking that quite sincerely.
70
00:04:12,986 --> 00:04:17,480
I was wondering if exposure to my
methods had helped you in any way.
71
00:04:17,657 --> 00:04:21,650
Actually, before you came along,
I'd never closed a case before.
72
00:04:21,828 --> 00:04:23,318
Neither had the rest
of the department.
73
00:04:23,496 --> 00:04:26,988
Most of us were thinking of packing up,
leaving, letting the city fend for itself.
74
00:04:28,668 --> 00:04:31,364
- We need to find the black light.
- The what?
75
00:04:31,537 --> 00:04:34,404
There's a chemical known
as CAM phosphor on the walls.
76
00:04:34,574 --> 00:04:37,566
Smells like spent matchsticks.
Smell it. Smell it.
77
00:04:38,478 --> 00:04:40,673
It's the primary ingredient of an ink
78
00:04:40,847 --> 00:04:43,645
which can only be seen
when exposed to...
79
00:04:45,051 --> 00:04:47,144
When exposed to...
80
00:04:49,789 --> 00:04:51,882
...ultraviolet light.
81
00:04:52,458 --> 00:04:54,358
- Hmm?
- Oh.
82
00:04:56,696 --> 00:04:57,924
HOLMES:
Thank you.
83
00:05:06,205 --> 00:05:08,105
BELL:
What is it?
84
00:05:08,274 --> 00:05:13,211
Well, I'm going to take a very literal
stab in the dark and say maths.
85
00:05:14,113 --> 00:05:19,483
Question is, does it have anything
to do with Mr. Soto's death?
86
00:05:56,456 --> 00:05:59,254
- Still can't believe you're a cop.
- I'm not a cop. I'm a consulting...
87
00:05:59,425 --> 00:06:00,687
- A consulting detective.
- Yeah.
88
00:06:00,860 --> 00:06:04,023
Still, you, like, go to crime scenes
and put away bad guys.
89
00:06:04,197 --> 00:06:06,495
Well, it's a little more complicated
than that, but yeah.
90
00:06:06,666 --> 00:06:08,395
Well, sometimes we do.
91
00:06:08,568 --> 00:06:11,128
What about you?
You're graduating this year, right?
92
00:06:12,705 --> 00:06:15,572
I don't know.
93
00:06:15,742 --> 00:06:18,802
I had kind of a rough time
junior year.
94
00:06:18,978 --> 00:06:21,037
I was thinking about my dad a lot.
95
00:06:21,214 --> 00:06:23,774
Probably partying
a little more than I should've. Heh.
96
00:06:24,584 --> 00:06:29,146
Actually, um, I left right before
my spring semester.
97
00:06:30,156 --> 00:06:32,317
- Oh.
- Yeah.
98
00:06:32,492 --> 00:06:34,858
- I'm sorry to hear that.
- It is what it is, right?
99
00:06:35,027 --> 00:06:37,222
Besides, I got some stuff going on,
100
00:06:37,397 --> 00:06:39,422
- stuff I'm very excited about.
- Yeah?
101
00:06:39,599 --> 00:06:42,932
- This is my bar.
- You bought a bar?
102
00:06:43,102 --> 00:06:45,434
JOEY: Well, I'm about to buy a bar.
Me and a buddy.
103
00:06:45,605 --> 00:06:48,506
And, uh, you know, we're just
getting together the funding right now,
104
00:06:48,674 --> 00:06:50,801
but we are this close, doc.
105
00:06:50,977 --> 00:06:53,104
Oh, Joan. You should
call me Joan now.
106
00:06:53,279 --> 00:06:56,646
- Ah. Sorry, old habits. Heh.
- It's okay.
107
00:06:59,485 --> 00:07:01,885
- You don't like it?
- No, it's just...
108
00:07:02,655 --> 00:07:05,681
I just remember how excited you were
about studying to become an engineer,
109
00:07:05,858 --> 00:07:07,587
how happy it made your dad.
110
00:07:08,428 --> 00:07:12,888
Well, the school took away
my scholarship when I dropped out,
111
00:07:13,065 --> 00:07:16,557
so without that,
can't exactly go back.
112
00:07:17,069 --> 00:07:18,195
Yeah.
113
00:07:20,840 --> 00:07:23,308
It's funny,
it's like I can't help wondering
114
00:07:23,476 --> 00:07:26,468
if we were supposed to
run into each other this morning.
115
00:07:26,646 --> 00:07:28,637
My partner and me,
we have big plans for this place.
116
00:07:28,815 --> 00:07:32,945
And I know that anyone that invests
with us is gonna double their money.
117
00:07:33,119 --> 00:07:34,552
Like, at least.
118
00:07:36,522 --> 00:07:37,989
Are you asking me for a loan?
119
00:07:38,157 --> 00:07:41,126
No, I'm offering you an opportunity.
120
00:07:41,294 --> 00:07:44,661
And you were always so good
to me, you know? You...
121
00:07:44,831 --> 00:07:47,299
You held my hand when
Dad got sick.
122
00:07:48,534 --> 00:07:51,765
Now I just, you know,
maybe I can pay you back a little.
123
00:07:51,938 --> 00:07:57,570
Hey, I even found this little spot
in the back room to hang his picture.
124
00:07:58,211 --> 00:08:00,577
Just so he can always
be there, always.
125
00:08:03,649 --> 00:08:06,117
So how much do you need?
126
00:08:21,934 --> 00:08:23,868
If you're looking for Sherlock,
he's downstairs.
127
00:08:24,036 --> 00:08:25,094
Okay.
128
00:08:30,176 --> 00:08:32,110
I will go there now.
129
00:08:36,916 --> 00:08:38,577
HOLMES:
His name is Harlan Emple.
130
00:08:38,751 --> 00:08:40,116
He is the
Rachel P. Hanson Professor
131
00:08:40,286 --> 00:08:42,254
for Applied Mathematics
at Columbia University,
132
00:08:42,421 --> 00:08:45,117
and holder of the Smithfield-endowed
Chair of Algebraic Geometry
133
00:08:45,291 --> 00:08:46,815
at the Huntington Institute.
134
00:08:46,993 --> 00:08:50,292
And he is here to help you make sense
of the equations you found. I get that.
135
00:08:50,463 --> 00:08:53,660
What I don't get is
why he isn't wearing a shirt.
136
00:08:53,833 --> 00:08:55,824
Every great thinker has a process.
In Harlan's case,
137
00:08:56,002 --> 00:08:58,800
he doesn't like anything to
come between him and the numbers.
138
00:08:58,971 --> 00:09:01,201
I know you can feel quite Victorian
about such matters,
139
00:09:01,374 --> 00:09:02,898
so I've given him a little bell to ring
140
00:09:03,075 --> 00:09:05,270
should he feel the need
to disrobe entirely.
141
00:09:05,444 --> 00:09:07,969
I can't guarantee
he won't sit on the furniture.
142
00:09:08,147 --> 00:09:09,273
How do you know him again?
143
00:09:09,849 --> 00:09:12,044
In 1999, he devised
a mathematical model
144
00:09:12,218 --> 00:09:14,743
which he believed could
accurately predict crime patterns
145
00:09:14,921 --> 00:09:16,286
in and around New York City.
146
00:09:16,455 --> 00:09:19,253
Ultimately didn't work, but
I found the premise quite fascinating.
147
00:09:19,425 --> 00:09:22,053
We've been corresponding
ever since.
148
00:09:22,228 --> 00:09:24,196
You really think this guy
was killed over math?
149
00:09:24,363 --> 00:09:27,855
Mr. Soto obviously went to great
lengths to conceal his calculations.
150
00:09:28,034 --> 00:09:29,729
Whether they have any real value,
151
00:09:29,902 --> 00:09:32,837
or are just the numerical ramblings
of a maths-obsessed madman,
152
00:09:33,005 --> 00:09:34,802
is for Harlan to determine.
153
00:09:34,974 --> 00:09:37,465
- Eggs?
- Uh, no, thanks.
154
00:09:40,212 --> 00:09:45,013
Hey, I was wondering if it was possible
to get an advance on my salary.
155
00:09:45,184 --> 00:09:47,175
Define "advance."
156
00:09:47,753 --> 00:09:48,947
Five thousand dollars.
157
00:09:51,724 --> 00:09:54,693
I ran into someone this morning.
He's the son of an old friend of mine.
158
00:09:54,860 --> 00:09:57,556
He's trying to get this business
off the ground. I thought I'd help.
159
00:09:57,730 --> 00:09:59,857
I just maxed out on my
IRA contributions,
160
00:10:00,032 --> 00:10:03,900
so I cannot take money back,
otherwise I will get massive penalties.
161
00:10:04,070 --> 00:10:07,198
You must really believe
in this young man.
162
00:10:08,374 --> 00:10:11,400
Well, I'd like to see him
take a shot at this.
163
00:10:11,577 --> 00:10:12,839
Not quite the same thing, is it?
164
00:10:13,346 --> 00:10:17,180
HARLAN: Sherlock, I know what
the formula is, and it is a doozy.
165
00:10:17,350 --> 00:10:18,942
Okay, so the first thing
you need to know
166
00:10:19,118 --> 00:10:20,847
is that the guy who wrote this
was a genius.
167
00:10:21,020 --> 00:10:24,183
"Guys" with an S. There were
two mathematicians at work here.
168
00:10:24,357 --> 00:10:27,224
One was Felix Soto.
These parts of the equation
169
00:10:27,393 --> 00:10:30,260
are a match for handwriting samples
I took from his home.
170
00:10:30,429 --> 00:10:33,523
These scribbles are from
another man yet to be identified.
171
00:10:33,699 --> 00:10:35,360
How do you know it was a man?
172
00:10:35,534 --> 00:10:37,832
There is an inconsistency
to the gradient here.
173
00:10:38,004 --> 00:10:40,234
Some letters slant to the right,
others to the left.
174
00:10:40,406 --> 00:10:43,569
Also the stem of the P here
and the D here
175
00:10:43,743 --> 00:10:45,108
are looped instead of doubled back.
176
00:10:45,277 --> 00:10:48,872
It doesn't guarantee the writer
was male, but it's a strong indicator.
177
00:10:49,048 --> 00:10:51,539
Fine, then these guys are geniuses.
178
00:10:51,717 --> 00:10:53,651
The point is,
I know what they were working on.
179
00:10:53,819 --> 00:10:56,014
It's P versus NP.
180
00:10:56,188 --> 00:10:59,021
Come on, it's one of the most
famous problems in math history.
181
00:10:59,191 --> 00:11:01,125
If we were mathematicians,
you would not be here.
182
00:11:01,293 --> 00:11:03,284
In simplest terms, P versus NP asks
183
00:11:03,462 --> 00:11:06,431
if every problem whose solution
can be quickly verified by a computer
184
00:11:06,599 --> 00:11:08,624
can also be quickly solved
by a computer.
185
00:11:08,801 --> 00:11:12,328
Sounds innocent enough, right?
Only it's not. It is filthy.
186
00:11:12,505 --> 00:11:15,030
Some experts have even theorized
that it can't be solved.
187
00:11:15,207 --> 00:11:16,640
Could it be a motive for murder?
188
00:11:16,809 --> 00:11:20,006
That depends. You think a million
dollars could be a motive for murder?
189
00:11:20,179 --> 00:11:22,477
I'm sorry, you're saying
this is worth a million dollars?
190
00:11:22,648 --> 00:11:23,945
No, but it is getting there.
191
00:11:24,116 --> 00:11:27,882
I mean, this is the farthest I have ever
seen anyone take P versus NP.
192
00:11:28,054 --> 00:11:29,282
I mean, if I had to guess,
193
00:11:29,455 --> 00:11:32,083
I would say these guys are months,
maybe weeks from solving it.
194
00:11:32,258 --> 00:11:35,193
But who'd pay a million dollars for the
solution to a mathematical problem?
195
00:11:35,361 --> 00:11:37,261
The Clay Mathematics Institute
in Rhode Island.
196
00:11:37,430 --> 00:11:40,160
They're a non-profit
dedicated to promoting math interest.
197
00:11:40,332 --> 00:11:43,267
But the thing that they are most
famous for is The Millennium Prizes.
198
00:11:43,436 --> 00:11:45,802
They offer a million dollars
to anyone who can solve
199
00:11:45,971 --> 00:11:48,405
just one of the seven hardest
problems in the world.
200
00:11:48,574 --> 00:11:50,201
And P versus NP
is one of the seven.
201
00:11:50,376 --> 00:11:52,810
We know that the dead man,
Soto, was working with a partner.
202
00:11:52,978 --> 00:11:54,969
And you said that Soto's
neighbor heard him
203
00:11:55,147 --> 00:11:57,115
arguing with another man
a few nights ago.
204
00:11:57,283 --> 00:12:00,446
Perhaps the partner thought he could
complete the problem himself.
205
00:12:00,619 --> 00:12:02,519
Take the prize money
without having to share it.
206
00:12:02,688 --> 00:12:03,746
HARLAN:
For what it's worth,
207
00:12:03,923 --> 00:12:06,824
your victim would not have been
working with just any mathematician.
208
00:12:06,992 --> 00:12:10,393
P versus NP is the kind of problem
that people devote their lives to.
209
00:12:10,563 --> 00:12:12,531
There is a whole
P versus NP community.
210
00:12:12,698 --> 00:12:14,757
A community which you could
help us gain access to.
211
00:12:14,934 --> 00:12:17,266
Well, I sort of travel
in different mathematical circles.
212
00:12:17,436 --> 00:12:19,563
But I do know somebody
who's pretty involved.
213
00:12:19,739 --> 00:12:21,969
Tanya Barrett.
She's a professor at Triboro College.
214
00:12:22,508 --> 00:12:24,999
I heard about what happened to Felix
on the news this morning.
215
00:12:25,177 --> 00:12:27,702
- I still can't believe it.
- Were you two close?
216
00:12:27,880 --> 00:12:32,180
I met him when I wrote my articles,
but that was years ago.
217
00:12:32,718 --> 00:12:34,652
It's our understanding,
Professor Barrett,
218
00:12:34,820 --> 00:12:36,845
that you are a veritable
who's who guide
219
00:12:37,022 --> 00:12:38,956
to the world of P versus NP.
220
00:12:39,125 --> 00:12:41,889
When I wrote my articles,
I profiled all the mathematicians
221
00:12:42,061 --> 00:12:44,325
who had really devoted themselves
to the problem.
222
00:12:44,497 --> 00:12:45,930
That's how I met Felix.
223
00:12:46,098 --> 00:12:49,226
Do you know if he was close to any of
the other people that you interviewed?
224
00:12:49,401 --> 00:12:50,868
I don't think so. Why?
225
00:12:51,036 --> 00:12:54,267
We believe that before he died,
he was collaborating with a partner.
226
00:12:54,440 --> 00:12:57,637
That doesn't sound like Felix.
He was very competitive.
227
00:12:57,810 --> 00:13:00,677
But I'll be happy to walk you through
the names that I do have.
228
00:13:00,846 --> 00:13:03,974
These are the journals
that published me.
229
00:13:04,583 --> 00:13:08,485
So, um, what made you start wanting
to write about P versus NP?
230
00:13:08,654 --> 00:13:11,384
When I was young
and very full of myself,
231
00:13:11,557 --> 00:13:13,991
I decided to spend a summer
trying to solve it.
232
00:13:14,160 --> 00:13:16,754
When I looked up,
three years had gone by.
233
00:13:16,929 --> 00:13:20,228
P versus NP may well be unsolvable.
234
00:13:20,399 --> 00:13:23,835
So I walked away.
235
00:13:24,537 --> 00:13:27,938
- Do you know who wrote this proof?
- Cyril Nauer, a total savant.
236
00:13:28,107 --> 00:13:30,098
- He lives in Brooklyn.
- Look familiar?
237
00:13:30,776 --> 00:13:33,267
That's the same handwriting
as our mystery mathematician.
238
00:13:33,445 --> 00:13:35,572
You wouldn't happen to have
a picture of Mr. Nauer?
239
00:13:36,115 --> 00:13:37,980
WATSON: Cyril Nauer looks like
the Unabomber.
240
00:13:38,150 --> 00:13:39,981
Both are mathematicians,
both are loners.
241
00:13:40,152 --> 00:13:43,383
Let's hope only one of them
ever aspired to mass casualties.
242
00:13:43,556 --> 00:13:44,818
Detective Bell,
243
00:13:44,990 --> 00:13:48,050
I believe we may have a strong
suspect in the murder of Felix Soto.
244
00:13:48,227 --> 00:13:51,253
That's good. I just found out
we got a second victim.
245
00:13:51,430 --> 00:13:54,365
He was shot on a sidewalk
in Hell's Kitchen last night,
246
00:13:54,533 --> 00:13:56,023
dragged into an alley.
247
00:13:56,202 --> 00:14:00,866
Initial ballistics report says it was
the same gun that killed Felix Soto.
248
00:14:01,040 --> 00:14:02,632
Any connection between
the two men?
249
00:14:02,808 --> 00:14:04,571
Right now all I have is a name.
250
00:14:05,611 --> 00:14:07,340
Cyril Nauer.
251
00:14:07,813 --> 00:14:10,873
So wanna give me the name
of your suspect?
252
00:14:21,861 --> 00:14:23,726
Two mathematicians,
253
00:14:24,530 --> 00:14:27,260
both collaborating
on the same infamous problem,
254
00:14:27,733 --> 00:14:31,464
both killed within an hour of each other
by the same shooter.
255
00:14:31,637 --> 00:14:33,571
Obviously not a coincidence.
256
00:14:34,573 --> 00:14:37,201
Your friend said that a solution
to P versus NP
257
00:14:37,376 --> 00:14:38,900
is worth a million dollars, right?
258
00:14:40,145 --> 00:14:43,774
It's hard to imagine there's
only two people trying to solve it.
259
00:14:43,983 --> 00:14:46,247
You think they were killed
by a competitor.
260
00:14:46,418 --> 00:14:48,045
Would make sense, wouldn't it?
261
00:14:48,621 --> 00:14:50,919
I mean, someone realizes
how far they've come,
262
00:14:51,090 --> 00:14:53,115
murders them
to keep them from solving it first.
263
00:14:53,626 --> 00:14:57,687
Question is, how did they realize
how far they'd come?
264
00:14:57,863 --> 00:15:00,923
Both men clearly paranoid
about having their work uncovered,
265
00:15:01,100 --> 00:15:04,001
recorded every digit in invisible ink.
266
00:15:04,169 --> 00:15:07,297
Maybe one of them bragged
to the wrong person.
267
00:15:08,173 --> 00:15:10,334
Says here that CSU
found some dog hairs
268
00:15:10,509 --> 00:15:12,374
under the arms
of Cyril Nauer's coat.
269
00:15:13,112 --> 00:15:14,739
Transferred presumably
when the shooter
270
00:15:14,914 --> 00:15:17,041
dragged Mr. Nauer
into the alleyway.
271
00:15:18,183 --> 00:15:21,118
- Is there a picture?
- Yeah.
272
00:15:23,188 --> 00:15:26,021
They sent the samples to the lab
to try to determine the dog's...
273
00:15:26,191 --> 00:15:27,658
Boston Terrier.
274
00:15:29,328 --> 00:15:30,590
So...
275
00:15:31,163 --> 00:15:34,860
Perhaps our shooter owns a dog.
276
00:15:37,303 --> 00:15:39,168
Almost something, I suppose.
277
00:15:40,973 --> 00:15:43,635
You know, we never finished
our conversation from yesterday.
278
00:15:45,744 --> 00:15:47,507
I asked you for an advance?
279
00:15:48,480 --> 00:15:50,641
Just out of curiosity, Watson,
280
00:15:51,250 --> 00:15:54,447
who exactly asked you for $5,000,
281
00:15:54,620 --> 00:15:56,110
and what is their connection
to the man
282
00:15:56,288 --> 00:15:57,880
who died under your care
three years ago?
283
00:16:02,528 --> 00:16:05,224
You told me you had
a doctor's appointment yesterday.
284
00:16:05,397 --> 00:16:08,093
That was a lie. You went to visit
your former patient's grave.
285
00:16:09,635 --> 00:16:11,899
You've done so quite regularly
since moving in with me.
286
00:16:13,772 --> 00:16:15,706
It's your sleeves.
They tend to give you away.
287
00:16:15,874 --> 00:16:18,206
I'm able to detect the fragrance
of carnations,
288
00:16:18,377 --> 00:16:20,504
but no carnations ever appear
at the brownstone.
289
00:16:21,547 --> 00:16:24,038
You leave them for him, do you not?
290
00:16:25,851 --> 00:16:28,911
I don't mean to pry.
It's just that you went there yesterday,
291
00:16:29,088 --> 00:16:32,785
and when you returned, you hoped
to secure a rather substantial loan
292
00:16:32,958 --> 00:16:35,893
for the "son of a friend," neither
of whom you wished to discuss.
293
00:16:38,397 --> 00:16:42,800
I'd wanna make sure that this person
is not taking advantage of you.
294
00:16:46,605 --> 00:16:51,304
I guess we never really
talked about this, did we?
295
00:16:58,484 --> 00:17:01,817
His name was Gerald Castoro.
He was my patient.
296
00:17:02,354 --> 00:17:04,788
He needed surgery
to remove his right adrenal gland.
297
00:17:04,957 --> 00:17:06,822
He had a tumor inside it.
298
00:17:07,593 --> 00:17:10,391
A pheochromocytoma. It's rare.
299
00:17:10,562 --> 00:17:13,827
And the procedure to remove it
is pretty straightforward.
300
00:17:17,669 --> 00:17:21,105
I nicked his vena cava.
I don't know how. I just...
301
00:17:25,444 --> 00:17:30,814
He lost his entire volume of blood
into his abdomen in seconds.
302
00:17:36,155 --> 00:17:39,352
He was a nice man.
He was a dock worker.
303
00:17:42,694 --> 00:17:45,356
Few weeks before the surgery,
I got to know his family.
304
00:17:45,531 --> 00:17:48,329
His wife, his son.
305
00:17:52,404 --> 00:17:55,271
Mrs. Castoro did what most people
would do in her situation.
306
00:17:55,441 --> 00:17:57,432
She sued me.
307
00:17:58,777 --> 00:18:00,642
I went to court.
308
00:18:01,847 --> 00:18:04,941
I had to listen to her say
a lot of terrible things about me.
309
00:18:05,117 --> 00:18:08,609
It was a difficult process,
as you can well imagine.
310
00:18:13,325 --> 00:18:15,520
Gerald's son, Joey...
311
00:18:19,431 --> 00:18:22,161
He was only 17 back then.
312
00:18:22,968 --> 00:18:24,868
He wrote me a letter.
313
00:18:26,271 --> 00:18:30,230
He said that he didn't blame me,
that it wasn't my fault.
314
00:18:31,643 --> 00:18:34,168
That he forgave me.
315
00:18:38,517 --> 00:18:41,077
At the time, it meant a lot.
316
00:18:46,358 --> 00:18:49,225
Is this the first time
he's asked you for money?
317
00:18:54,233 --> 00:18:56,531
He needed a car
to get back and forth from college.
318
00:18:56,702 --> 00:18:59,170
His mother needed him around a lot.
319
00:18:59,338 --> 00:19:01,067
[CELL PHONE RINGING]
320
00:19:09,281 --> 00:19:11,909
- Detective?
BELL: I'm at Cyril Nauer's apartment.
321
00:19:12,084 --> 00:19:14,177
There's some stuff here
I think you should see.
322
00:19:14,353 --> 00:19:18,881
Okay, so that's Cyril Nauer's place
right there, second floor.
323
00:19:19,057 --> 00:19:21,958
Figured I'd just poke around, see
if I could find any more black bulbs
324
00:19:22,127 --> 00:19:24,095
like the one you found at
Felix Soto's place.
325
00:19:24,263 --> 00:19:27,357
There weren't, but I managed
to find this in one of the fixtures.
326
00:19:27,866 --> 00:19:29,128
Is that a bug?
327
00:19:29,301 --> 00:19:31,895
CSU is going over everything
with a fine-toothed comb.
328
00:19:32,070 --> 00:19:34,903
But obviously someone
was listening in on Mr. Nauer.
329
00:19:35,073 --> 00:19:36,597
They might've been
watching him as well.
330
00:19:36,775 --> 00:19:38,572
It's a municipal building.
Cameras are theirs.
331
00:19:38,744 --> 00:19:41,804
Even the one pointing
directly at his apartment?
332
00:19:42,314 --> 00:19:43,975
Taxi!
333
00:19:48,620 --> 00:19:50,952
- Where you going?
- Up.
334
00:19:52,157 --> 00:19:53,419
MAN:
Hey!
335
00:19:54,693 --> 00:19:56,957
- What are you doing?
- Keep your vehicle perfectly still.
336
00:19:57,129 --> 00:19:59,393
I'll give you $20
for going absolutely nowhere.
337
00:20:05,938 --> 00:20:07,269
Yeah.
338
00:20:11,610 --> 00:20:15,102
Signal jumper. Someone's been using
it to hijack that camera's video feed,
339
00:20:15,280 --> 00:20:17,180
broadcast it to a remote location.
340
00:20:17,349 --> 00:20:19,510
Presumably the same person
who put a listening device
341
00:20:19,685 --> 00:20:21,710
inside Mr. Nauer's apartment.
342
00:20:21,887 --> 00:20:23,514
Good news is
the jumper's transmissions
343
00:20:23,689 --> 00:20:26,180
can be traced back to a receiver.
You find the receiver...
344
00:20:26,358 --> 00:20:28,622
Find the person
who's been spying on Nauer.
345
00:20:31,763 --> 00:20:33,287
Detective Bell?
346
00:20:34,766 --> 00:20:37,428
I'm Linus Roe. I was told
you wanted to speak with me.
347
00:20:37,603 --> 00:20:40,071
Your website says that
Roe Encryption Technologies
348
00:20:40,239 --> 00:20:42,366
offers the highest-level
encryption services
349
00:20:42,541 --> 00:20:45,339
for online retailers,
banks and investment firms.
350
00:20:45,510 --> 00:20:47,705
No mention there
of illegal surveillance.
351
00:20:47,879 --> 00:20:49,437
I can't imagine why there would be.
352
00:20:49,615 --> 00:20:52,743
Because your company's
been filming Cyril Nauer in his home.
353
00:20:52,918 --> 00:20:55,682
I'm sorry, am I supposed
to know that name?
354
00:20:55,854 --> 00:20:59,585
We found a signal jumper on a camera
just outside Mr. Nauer's apartment.
355
00:20:59,758 --> 00:21:02,352
Now, the department's Technical
Assistance Response Unit says
356
00:21:02,527 --> 00:21:04,552
it was broadcasting
to your company's server.
357
00:21:05,163 --> 00:21:06,824
Don't know anything about that.
358
00:21:06,999 --> 00:21:09,058
Well, someone here knows
something about it, Mr. Roe,
359
00:21:09,234 --> 00:21:11,725
and that person may even be
responsible for Mr. Nauer's death.
360
00:21:11,903 --> 00:21:13,302
Cyril Nauer is dead?
361
00:21:13,472 --> 00:21:15,633
I thought you said you
didn't know him.
362
00:21:17,542 --> 00:21:19,339
Okay, you're right.
363
00:21:19,511 --> 00:21:22,742
We were monitoring Cyril Nauer.
It was my idea.
364
00:21:22,914 --> 00:21:25,246
But I am telling you, no one
at this company would hurt him,
365
00:21:25,417 --> 00:21:27,078
- not in a million years.
- Well, back up.
366
00:21:27,252 --> 00:21:29,186
Start with why
you were spying on him.
367
00:21:29,354 --> 00:21:32,255
Because of his work
on something called P versus NP.
368
00:21:32,424 --> 00:21:34,187
- It's...
- Filthy maths. Virtually unsolvable,
369
00:21:34,359 --> 00:21:36,520
worth a million dollars.
Yes, we're familiar with it.
370
00:21:36,695 --> 00:21:39,596
Is that why you were surveilling him,
because your company needed money?
371
00:21:39,765 --> 00:21:41,858
You're thinking of
the Millennium Prize, right?
372
00:21:42,034 --> 00:21:46,596
No, a solve for P versus NP
is only worth a million to them.
373
00:21:46,772 --> 00:21:49,798
To us it's worth tens,
maybe hundreds more.
374
00:21:49,975 --> 00:21:52,273
Mathematicians are drawn
to P versus NP
375
00:21:52,444 --> 00:21:56,175
because it's math's
great white whale, but the truth is
376
00:21:56,348 --> 00:22:01,149
a solution would have
massive real-world implications.
377
00:22:01,386 --> 00:22:03,752
- Such as?
- A correct proof
378
00:22:03,922 --> 00:22:07,585
would essentially render
all modern encryption obsolete.
379
00:22:07,759 --> 00:22:10,626
With the right software, you could hack
into any system in the world.
380
00:22:10,796 --> 00:22:12,024
They won't be able to stop you.
381
00:22:12,197 --> 00:22:14,859
It's one equation.
How is that possible?
382
00:22:15,033 --> 00:22:18,093
Encryption consists of setting up
problems so complicated
383
00:22:18,270 --> 00:22:20,101
that a computer can't solve them.
384
00:22:20,272 --> 00:22:23,070
Solving P versus NP lets you
run through the possible answer
385
00:22:23,241 --> 00:22:24,435
fast enough to crack the code.
386
00:22:24,609 --> 00:22:27,510
You could come and go as you please
through any server on the planet.
387
00:22:27,679 --> 00:22:28,703
It's a skeleton key.
388
00:22:28,880 --> 00:22:30,507
It's the key
to building the skeleton key.
389
00:22:30,682 --> 00:22:32,240
Once you had the solution,
390
00:22:32,417 --> 00:22:34,681
you'd still need to
write the code to apply it.
391
00:22:34,853 --> 00:22:36,787
The digital world
would be your oyster.
392
00:22:36,955 --> 00:22:39,048
You're saying a solution
would make your company
393
00:22:39,224 --> 00:22:41,158
about as useful as a pet rock?
394
00:22:41,760 --> 00:22:44,752
Certainly sounds like the kind of thing
a man in your position
395
00:22:44,930 --> 00:22:47,057
- would kill to prevent.
LINUS: You don't understand.
396
00:22:47,232 --> 00:22:51,362
I wanted Cyril to solve P versus NP.
I approached him months ago
397
00:22:51,536 --> 00:22:54,232
because I believed if anyone could
solve it, it would be him.
398
00:22:54,406 --> 00:22:56,067
I offered to fund his work
on the condition
399
00:22:56,241 --> 00:22:58,471
that if he did solve it,
we'd keep the proof under wraps,
400
00:22:58,643 --> 00:23:03,171
at least until he helped me to design
cryptography to defeat it.
401
00:23:03,348 --> 00:23:05,578
So Roe Encryption
would be proof-proof.
402
00:23:05,751 --> 00:23:07,844
The only company in the world
403
00:23:08,019 --> 00:23:10,579
capable of defending against
P versus NP technology.
404
00:23:10,756 --> 00:23:12,690
Well, Cyril refused.
405
00:23:12,858 --> 00:23:14,985
Money didn't mean anything to him.
He wanted acclaim.
406
00:23:15,160 --> 00:23:20,860
But when we found out that he was
working with a man named Felix Soto,
407
00:23:21,666 --> 00:23:24,066
we infiltrated his home as well.
408
00:23:24,236 --> 00:23:27,637
We took some photos
of the work they'd done.
409
00:23:27,806 --> 00:23:30,001
It was a total waste of time.
410
00:23:30,175 --> 00:23:31,938
They weren't anywhere
near a solution.
411
00:23:32,110 --> 00:23:33,805
That's not our understanding.
412
00:23:33,979 --> 00:23:35,378
We took the pictures to an expert.
413
00:23:35,547 --> 00:23:37,777
She said they were
nowhere near figuring it out.
414
00:23:37,949 --> 00:23:39,280
Can you tell us her name?
415
00:23:39,451 --> 00:23:40,475
Tanya Barrett.
416
00:23:40,652 --> 00:23:44,053
She wrote a bunch of articles
on P versus NP a few years ago.
417
00:23:44,222 --> 00:23:46,884
You talk to her, she'll confirm
everything I just told you.
418
00:23:47,058 --> 00:23:49,788
I'm sorry I didn't tell you
everything I knew yesterday.
419
00:23:49,961 --> 00:23:51,553
I just didn't think my work with Linus
420
00:23:51,730 --> 00:23:54,130
had anything to do with
Felix Soto's death.
421
00:23:54,299 --> 00:23:56,529
Did you know when you reviewed
the pictures of their work
422
00:23:56,701 --> 00:24:00,467
- that they had been obtained illegally?
- I had a feeling, but I didn't press it.
423
00:24:00,639 --> 00:24:03,540
The university had cut two of my
classes this year. I needed the money.
424
00:24:03,708 --> 00:24:05,369
It's my understanding that
you told Mr. Roe
425
00:24:05,544 --> 00:24:06,977
that the calculations were no good.
426
00:24:08,747 --> 00:24:10,942
That was a lie, correct?
427
00:24:11,116 --> 00:24:13,414
From the second I saw it,
428
00:24:13,585 --> 00:24:15,883
I knew that the work was
Felix and Cyril's.
429
00:24:16,054 --> 00:24:19,888
They had taken P versus NP farther
than I'd ever seen anyone.
430
00:24:20,058 --> 00:24:22,549
And still they were only
a third of the way through.
431
00:24:22,727 --> 00:24:24,422
They had years of work
ahead of them.
432
00:24:24,596 --> 00:24:29,533
I thought if I told Linus that the work
was bogus, that he'd back off.
433
00:24:29,701 --> 00:24:33,102
I knew it was wrong,
but so was what Linus was doing.
434
00:24:33,271 --> 00:24:36,707
I guess I convinced myself that one
bad thing could cancel out another.
435
00:24:36,875 --> 00:24:39,036
You're a dog owner, correct?
436
00:24:39,211 --> 00:24:41,338
- Boston Terrier?
- How'd you know that?
437
00:24:41,513 --> 00:24:44,949
You registered him with the city when
you procured a pet license in 2010.
438
00:24:45,116 --> 00:24:46,913
We found some dog hairs
on Cyril Nauer's body
439
00:24:47,085 --> 00:24:48,950
that we think were transferred
from the killer.
440
00:24:49,120 --> 00:24:52,783
DNA test showed
it came from a Boston Terrier.
441
00:24:52,958 --> 00:24:55,518
Guess what else
you registered with the city.
442
00:24:55,694 --> 00:24:59,687
Nine-millimeter handgun in 2009.
Precisely the same kind of weapon
443
00:24:59,865 --> 00:25:03,323
used to perforate Misters Soto
and Nauer two nights ago.
444
00:25:03,502 --> 00:25:05,561
This gun was stolen
from my apartment last month.
445
00:25:05,737 --> 00:25:07,705
There was a burglary. I filed...
446
00:25:07,873 --> 00:25:09,431
You filed a police report.
Yes, we know.
447
00:25:09,608 --> 00:25:11,576
Only the gun wasn't stolen, was it?
448
00:25:11,743 --> 00:25:13,404
You wanted to be able to say it was
449
00:25:13,578 --> 00:25:15,876
in the event someone linked you
to the two murders.
450
00:25:16,047 --> 00:25:19,141
Maybe you thought you could build on
what Soto and Nauer had done.
451
00:25:19,317 --> 00:25:21,182
Carry their ball over the goal line.
452
00:25:21,353 --> 00:25:24,049
In great success,
you'd claim the Millennium Prize
453
00:25:24,222 --> 00:25:25,780
and 1 million dollars.
454
00:25:25,957 --> 00:25:27,720
Maybe you were hoping
to sell the solution
455
00:25:27,893 --> 00:25:30,885
to Linus Roe yourself someday,
make even more money.
456
00:25:31,062 --> 00:25:33,223
This is insane.
457
00:25:33,698 --> 00:25:35,290
I didn't kill anyone.
458
00:25:35,467 --> 00:25:38,197
Then you shouldn't have any problem
accounting for your whereabouts
459
00:25:38,370 --> 00:25:40,497
between 9 and 10 p.m.
Two nights ago.
460
00:25:40,672 --> 00:25:42,572
I was at dinner with a friend
in Midtown.
461
00:25:42,741 --> 00:25:46,074
I got to the restaurant around 8:30.
I didn't leave until after 10:30.
462
00:25:48,713 --> 00:25:51,739
My friend's name
is Wayne Kaneshiro.
463
00:25:51,917 --> 00:25:53,475
I suggest you contact him.
464
00:25:53,652 --> 00:25:56,280
So still trying to track
Wayne Kaneshiro down,
465
00:25:56,454 --> 00:25:58,581
but in the meantime,
I reached out to that restaurant
466
00:25:58,757 --> 00:26:00,019
Ms. Barrett said she went to.
467
00:26:00,559 --> 00:26:03,551
They said they'd e-mail me the
security footage from two nights ago.
468
00:26:03,728 --> 00:26:04,752
There we go.
469
00:26:08,433 --> 00:26:10,526
I see two underage drinkers,
an affair-in-progress,
470
00:26:10,702 --> 00:26:12,636
and a bartender who's been
stealing from the till.
471
00:26:12,804 --> 00:26:14,931
Not a single college professor.
472
00:26:17,175 --> 00:26:19,803
Hold up, hold up.
473
00:26:21,413 --> 00:26:22,471
WATSON:
Eight thirty-seven.
474
00:26:22,647 --> 00:26:25,343
That's about 20 minutes
before Felix Soto was shot.
475
00:26:25,517 --> 00:26:26,882
Skip to the end.
476
00:26:27,052 --> 00:26:29,043
See when she leaves.
477
00:26:38,930 --> 00:26:41,194
She was telling the truth.
478
00:26:41,366 --> 00:26:43,163
She's not our shooter.
479
00:26:54,679 --> 00:26:56,670
So you won't go for a jog
along the river,
480
00:26:56,848 --> 00:26:59,749
but you will do sit-ups
facing a wall at 2 a.m.
481
00:26:59,918 --> 00:27:02,011
Detective Bell texted to say
that he had located
482
00:27:02,187 --> 00:27:05,850
Tanya Barrett's dining companion,
Wayne Kaneshiro.
483
00:27:06,024 --> 00:27:07,685
As if the video evidence
weren't enough,
484
00:27:07,859 --> 00:27:11,158
he has confirmed that he was
with her between 8:30 and 10:30
485
00:27:11,329 --> 00:27:14,321
the night of the murders.
We remain devoid of a suspect.
486
00:27:14,499 --> 00:27:16,296
Calisthenics stimulates the heart,
487
00:27:16,468 --> 00:27:18,333
which increases blood flow
to the frontal lobe,
488
00:27:18,503 --> 00:27:19,993
which stimulates deductive thinking.
489
00:27:20,171 --> 00:27:23,072
Also the river smells like rancid cod.
490
00:27:23,241 --> 00:27:25,505
What is up with the nerd brigade?
491
00:27:25,677 --> 00:27:29,807
These are the other contenders
to the P versus NP throne.
492
00:27:29,981 --> 00:27:31,881
We may be wrong about Tanya,
493
00:27:32,050 --> 00:27:35,213
but perhaps we were right
about the killer's motive.
494
00:27:36,254 --> 00:27:40,054
How would they have known how
much progress Soto and Nauer made?
495
00:27:40,225 --> 00:27:44,093
I mean, you don't think there were
more people spying on them, do you?
496
00:27:44,796 --> 00:27:48,197
Watson, conundrum.
Conundrum, Watson.
497
00:27:48,366 --> 00:27:49,628
Ho!
498
00:27:50,101 --> 00:27:52,160
On another matter,
and against my better judgment,
499
00:27:52,337 --> 00:27:54,703
I have decided to advance you
the money that you requested.
500
00:27:54,873 --> 00:27:56,238
Oh, thanks.
501
00:27:57,709 --> 00:27:59,301
Why against your better judgment?
502
00:28:00,712 --> 00:28:02,441
You don't think it
the least bit coincidental
503
00:28:02,614 --> 00:28:05,515
that both you and young Mr. Castoro
decided to visit the cemetery
504
00:28:05,684 --> 00:28:08,448
the day after his father's birthday?
505
00:28:08,620 --> 00:28:10,781
Yes, of course I do.
506
00:28:10,955 --> 00:28:13,048
But you still wanna give him
the money.
507
00:28:14,926 --> 00:28:16,484
It's complicated.
You don't know him.
508
00:28:16,661 --> 00:28:20,256
I also know, as does he, that you
blame yourself for the man's death.
509
00:28:20,432 --> 00:28:22,400
- Because it was my fault.
- It was an accident.
510
00:28:22,567 --> 00:28:26,003
And as loathe as I am to admit it,
accidents happen.
511
00:28:27,672 --> 00:28:30,436
Joey's goodwill obviously means
a great deal to you.
512
00:28:30,608 --> 00:28:33,634
But the fact that he has, on more than
one occasion, attached a dollar figure
513
00:28:33,812 --> 00:28:35,712
reveals his character,
or at least it does to me.
514
00:28:37,148 --> 00:28:39,082
I'm an expert on poisons, Watson.
515
00:28:39,250 --> 00:28:42,083
I know virtually everything
there is to know about them.
516
00:28:42,253 --> 00:28:44,016
But I've come to learn
over the last few years
517
00:28:44,189 --> 00:28:47,681
that there is nothing on this planet
quite so toxic as guilt.
518
00:28:49,327 --> 00:28:51,090
Are you gonna advance me
the money or not?
519
00:28:51,830 --> 00:28:53,263
It's in that box.
520
00:29:05,110 --> 00:29:08,546
Hey, there's over $20,000 in here.
I only asked for 5.
521
00:29:08,713 --> 00:29:11,375
It's every scrap of cash
I currently have at my disposal.
522
00:29:11,549 --> 00:29:14,109
Consider the difference
a kind of buyout.
523
00:29:14,285 --> 00:29:15,582
A no-strings-attached transaction
524
00:29:15,754 --> 00:29:18,314
which will represent the end
of all business between you and Joey.
525
00:29:18,490 --> 00:29:21,391
- I don't understand.
- It's quite simple, really.
526
00:29:21,559 --> 00:29:24,357
I'm providing you with the means
to buy the young man out of your life.
527
00:29:24,529 --> 00:29:26,497
He gets the money he needs,
you get peace of mind,
528
00:29:26,664 --> 00:29:28,188
knowing he'll
never approach you again.
529
00:29:28,366 --> 00:29:30,732
I told you, I don't mind
that he approached me.
530
00:29:30,902 --> 00:29:33,962
I do. You've made your mistakes,
Watson. So have I.
531
00:29:34,139 --> 00:29:36,573
And if anything has become apparent
during our time together,
532
00:29:36,741 --> 00:29:40,177
it's that the majority of those mistakes
belong firmly in the past. Hmm?
533
00:29:40,345 --> 00:29:44,679
Take the money. Use it.
Consider it my gift to you.
534
00:29:53,792 --> 00:29:56,260
Have you considered that Tanya
might be working with a partner?
535
00:29:56,427 --> 00:29:58,486
Somebody who committed
the crimes for her
536
00:29:58,663 --> 00:30:00,654
while she alibied herself
in Midtown?
537
00:30:00,832 --> 00:30:02,663
Considered and discarded.
538
00:30:02,834 --> 00:30:04,995
Why go to the trouble
of allying yourself with a partner
539
00:30:05,170 --> 00:30:07,730
and then arming them with a weapon
that can be traced back to you?
540
00:30:07,906 --> 00:30:09,464
Hmm. You're right.
541
00:30:09,641 --> 00:30:12,735
That would only make it easier
to connect her to the crimes.
542
00:30:13,578 --> 00:30:15,512
Unless, of course,
that's the intention.
543
00:30:15,947 --> 00:30:18,882
What if Ms. Barrett is our lead suspect
because someone wants her to be?
544
00:30:19,050 --> 00:30:21,018
Are you saying
someone's trying to frame her?
545
00:30:24,689 --> 00:30:26,486
Professor Barrett,
might I have a word?
546
00:30:26,658 --> 00:30:28,250
I'm late for a class, Mr. Holmes,
547
00:30:28,426 --> 00:30:30,587
and I don't feel like being accused
of any more murders.
548
00:30:30,762 --> 00:30:33,253
All of my accusations were based
on multiple pieces of evidence
549
00:30:33,431 --> 00:30:35,331
pointing firmly in your direction.
550
00:30:35,500 --> 00:30:38,367
I've started to think
that might not be a coincidence.
551
00:30:38,536 --> 00:30:39,594
What are you talking about?
552
00:30:39,771 --> 00:30:41,500
Did you happen to mention
to anyone else
553
00:30:41,673 --> 00:30:44,107
that you had seen
Cyril and Felix's work?
554
00:30:44,275 --> 00:30:46,937
Anyone who might have felt
threatened by their progress?
555
00:30:47,111 --> 00:30:48,544
No, of course not.
556
00:30:48,713 --> 00:30:50,613
Do you have any enemies?
Jilted lover, perhaps?
557
00:30:50,782 --> 00:30:53,615
Or a student unhappy
with a very bad grade?
558
00:30:53,785 --> 00:30:55,650
Are you saying
you think I've been framed?
559
00:30:55,820 --> 00:30:59,847
I'm saying it might explain
why you're such an alluring suspect.
560
00:31:02,994 --> 00:31:06,327
No, this is crazy.
561
00:31:06,497 --> 00:31:09,193
You're thinking of someone.
Who is it?
562
00:31:13,471 --> 00:31:16,269
I got out of a long-term relationship
a few months ago.
563
00:31:16,441 --> 00:31:19,740
My ex, Jason, was very upset.
He sent me a couple of e-mails.
564
00:31:19,911 --> 00:31:22,311
- Threatening ones?
- I didn't take it personally.
565
00:31:22,480 --> 00:31:25,938
He's always had a temper.
I just thought he was letting off steam.
566
00:31:26,117 --> 00:31:27,846
Think I might be able to see
these e-mails?
567
00:31:28,019 --> 00:31:29,953
Give me your e-mail address
and a couple of hours,
568
00:31:30,121 --> 00:31:32,954
and I'll forward you the e-mails
when my class lets out.
569
00:31:35,226 --> 00:31:36,284
Good morning.
570
00:31:37,262 --> 00:31:39,025
JASON: I'm sorry, I don't know
either of them.
571
00:31:39,197 --> 00:31:42,291
Their names were Felix Soto
and Cyril Nauer.
572
00:31:42,467 --> 00:31:43,491
Ring any bells?
573
00:31:45,103 --> 00:31:48,470
But you were romantically involved
with Tanya Barrett.
574
00:31:48,640 --> 00:31:50,369
Yes, until a few months ago.
575
00:31:50,541 --> 00:31:53,704
- Who ended the relationship?
- Tanya. What's all this about anyway?
576
00:31:53,878 --> 00:31:57,279
It's our understanding
it was a pretty nasty split.
577
00:31:57,882 --> 00:32:02,615
There were some unpleasant
moments, like most breakups. Why?
578
00:32:03,321 --> 00:32:08,759
Tanya was nice enough to share with
us some of the e-mails that you sent.
579
00:32:08,927 --> 00:32:13,591
Ahem. On November the 11th, 2012,
you wrote,
580
00:32:13,765 --> 00:32:18,031
"You'll be sorry you let me go.
You've made a serious mistake."
581
00:32:18,202 --> 00:32:20,193
December 3rd, 2012,
582
00:32:20,371 --> 00:32:23,169
"You deserve to be hurt
the way that you hurt me."
583
00:32:23,341 --> 00:32:25,206
Is Tanya trying to get
a restraining order?
584
00:32:25,376 --> 00:32:27,867
- Because I'm telling you...
- These two men were shot and killed
585
00:32:28,046 --> 00:32:29,809
with a.9- Millimeter handgun
two days ago.
586
00:32:29,981 --> 00:32:31,471
We think that whoever
murdered them
587
00:32:31,649 --> 00:32:34,584
may be trying to frame Tanya
for the crimes.
588
00:32:35,486 --> 00:32:38,011
What are you talking about?
You think I shot these guys?
589
00:32:38,189 --> 00:32:40,817
- Just because Tanya dumped me?
BELL: Jason, we know you knew them.
590
00:32:40,992 --> 00:32:42,118
Tanya told us you met them
591
00:32:42,293 --> 00:32:44,693
back when she was
writing her articles for P versus NP.
592
00:32:44,862 --> 00:32:46,420
I've never seen these guys before.
593
00:32:46,597 --> 00:32:48,087
Your e-mails tell a different story.
594
00:32:48,266 --> 00:32:49,631
The threats you made against Tanya
595
00:32:49,801 --> 00:32:52,395
were enough for us to get a warrant
to search your account.
596
00:32:52,570 --> 00:32:55,596
In another e-mail you wrote in 2010,
you complained about
597
00:32:55,773 --> 00:32:58,207
getting dragged to interviews
she was doing for her articles,
598
00:32:58,376 --> 00:33:00,901
you mention Mr. Soto
and Mr. Nauer by name,
599
00:33:01,079 --> 00:33:04,139
and you accuse her of caring
more about P versus NP
600
00:33:04,315 --> 00:33:06,078
than she did your relationship.
601
00:33:06,884 --> 00:33:07,908
I didn't write this.
602
00:33:08,086 --> 00:33:11,419
Nor did you place an online order for
.9- Millimeter ammunition earlier today.
603
00:33:11,589 --> 00:33:15,685
BELL: Here's the confirmation, in case
you wanna re-familiarize yourself.
604
00:33:15,860 --> 00:33:17,327
Makes me think maybe you had
605
00:33:17,495 --> 00:33:19,929
a couple more mathematicians
in your crosshairs.
606
00:33:25,069 --> 00:33:28,038
- He wants a lawyer.
- One probably isn't gonna be enough.
607
00:33:28,206 --> 00:33:29,969
I just got a call from
Stuyvesant Memorial.
608
00:33:30,141 --> 00:33:32,609
That mugger that got shot
outside of Felix Soto's place?
609
00:33:32,777 --> 00:33:35,905
The one who didn't stand a chance
in hell? He's awake.
610
00:33:36,080 --> 00:33:38,571
Get his statement
before he takes another turn.
611
00:33:38,750 --> 00:33:42,743
He identifies Jason Harrison
as his shooter, we got him.
612
00:33:43,888 --> 00:33:47,415
Look, man, I'm just saying,
why don't you talk to the DA?
613
00:33:47,592 --> 00:33:49,355
Yeah, tell him to go easy on me.
614
00:33:49,527 --> 00:33:51,893
Or maybe you can describe
the person who shot you
615
00:33:52,063 --> 00:33:55,726
and take comfort in the knowledge
they won't be back to finish the job.
616
00:33:58,136 --> 00:34:01,833
She about 5'6", mid-30's,
if I had to guess.
617
00:34:02,006 --> 00:34:04,907
- You said, "she."
- Yeah, she.
618
00:34:05,076 --> 00:34:08,341
Long brown hair, glasses.
619
00:34:11,849 --> 00:34:14,147
Yeah, that's her.
That's the bitch shot me.
620
00:34:14,318 --> 00:34:16,809
Right after she shot
that other dude in the house.
621
00:34:16,988 --> 00:34:18,148
Are you positive?
622
00:34:18,322 --> 00:34:21,189
She was standing two feet
from me, all right?
623
00:34:21,359 --> 00:34:24,226
That's her, no doubt.
624
00:34:28,466 --> 00:34:31,560
Benny Charles insists
he was shot by Tanya Barrett.
625
00:34:31,736 --> 00:34:34,102
She, of course, has an alibi.
626
00:34:34,272 --> 00:34:36,399
She was dining with
Wayne Kaneshiro at the time
627
00:34:36,574 --> 00:34:40,101
and could not have shot Charles,
Soto, or Nauer.
628
00:34:40,278 --> 00:34:45,341
And yet further analysis of the hairs
found on Nauer's body
629
00:34:45,516 --> 00:34:48,417
have confirmed that they don't come
from just any Boston Terrier,
630
00:34:48,586 --> 00:34:50,986
but the one owned by Ms. Barrett.
631
00:34:51,155 --> 00:34:55,285
She also once owned the same type of
handgun used to commit the murders.
632
00:34:55,460 --> 00:34:59,396
Jason Harrison, meanwhile, he has
means and motive to frame Tanya.
633
00:34:59,564 --> 00:35:02,897
Several e-mails seem
to implicate him.
634
00:35:03,568 --> 00:35:07,004
But Benny Charles insists
he was shot by Tanya Barrett.
635
00:35:07,171 --> 00:35:09,332
Who has an alibi.
636
00:35:09,674 --> 00:35:11,369
You know we're
going in circles here, right?
637
00:35:11,542 --> 00:35:16,377
We're in a roundabout.
We just need to find the proper exit.
638
00:35:20,651 --> 00:35:22,243
You're not gonna
take my advice, are you?
639
00:35:22,420 --> 00:35:24,388
You're not gonna pay Joey
to go away.
640
00:35:25,323 --> 00:35:28,690
I think there are better ways
to spend $22,000.
641
00:35:28,860 --> 00:35:31,522
You could buy 8,800 beers,
for example.
642
00:35:31,696 --> 00:35:34,256
Tempting, but no.
643
00:35:34,832 --> 00:35:38,199
So we're gonna continue to let him
utilize you as his own personal ATM.
644
00:35:38,369 --> 00:35:39,393
I didn't say that.
645
00:35:44,742 --> 00:35:48,143
You said 8,800 beers, right?
646
00:35:48,746 --> 00:35:50,714
That's only 2.50 a beer.
647
00:35:50,882 --> 00:35:52,406
That's what the fat man paid.
648
00:35:52,583 --> 00:35:55,518
Put down 10 dollars,
left with four beers.
649
00:35:55,686 --> 00:35:58,280
WATSON: That's pretty cheap, isn't it?
- Cheap beer, presumably.
650
00:35:58,456 --> 00:36:02,620
Yeah, but this is New York,
and that isn't exactly a dive bar.
651
00:36:02,860 --> 00:36:06,057
The only time you see drinks
that cheap is during happy hour.
652
00:36:06,230 --> 00:36:08,164
But the time is exactly...
653
00:36:08,332 --> 00:36:12,234
Time stamp says 9:46.
654
00:36:12,737 --> 00:36:14,102
Yeah.
655
00:36:16,741 --> 00:36:18,834
Digital time stamp.
656
00:36:21,312 --> 00:36:23,405
You forgot to carry the one.
657
00:36:23,581 --> 00:36:27,039
Only joking.
I'm sure your maths is impeccable.
658
00:36:27,485 --> 00:36:30,045
Your plan to get away
with two murders, however...
659
00:36:30,221 --> 00:36:31,745
Are you out of your minds?
660
00:36:31,923 --> 00:36:34,949
The other day you told us you
had dinner with a friend in Midtown.
661
00:36:35,126 --> 00:36:38,653
You said you were there between
8:30 and 10:30, only you weren't.
662
00:36:38,829 --> 00:36:40,922
You were there between
5:30 and 7:30.
663
00:36:41,098 --> 00:36:42,759
Oh, that's ridiculous.
664
00:36:42,934 --> 00:36:46,062
You said you got the footage from
the security cameras in the restaurant.
665
00:36:46,237 --> 00:36:48,762
And it did confirm your alibi.
According to the date-time stamp,
666
00:36:48,940 --> 00:36:53,775
you and your friend Mr. Kaneshiro
arrive at 8:37 and leave at 10:44.
667
00:36:53,945 --> 00:36:56,470
Then I don't understand.
Why are you harassing me?
668
00:36:56,647 --> 00:37:00,083
When we met with Linus Roe
the other day, he explained to us
669
00:37:00,251 --> 00:37:03,709
that aside from its applications
in the world of theoretical maths,
670
00:37:03,888 --> 00:37:06,948
the solution to P versus NP
would have very real consequences,
671
00:37:07,124 --> 00:37:10,093
very practical consequences,
for computer science.
672
00:37:10,261 --> 00:37:13,753
It would be child's play, for example,
to hack the hard drive
673
00:37:13,931 --> 00:37:16,957
which stores and records security
footage in a Midtown restaurant
674
00:37:17,134 --> 00:37:19,125
and add three hours
to the date-time stamp.
675
00:37:19,303 --> 00:37:22,363
A few days ago, we thought that
you killed Felix Soto and Cyril Nauer
676
00:37:22,540 --> 00:37:25,509
in the hopes of solving P versus NP
yourself someday.
677
00:37:25,676 --> 00:37:28,270
Now we know you killed them
because you'd already solved it.
678
00:37:28,446 --> 00:37:30,311
HOLMES: You teamed up
with a computer programmer
679
00:37:30,481 --> 00:37:33,678
who could write the code required
to steal several hundred million dollars
680
00:37:33,851 --> 00:37:35,546
from various financial institutions.
681
00:37:35,720 --> 00:37:39,451
Problem was he needed time to write
the appropriate code for each one.
682
00:37:39,624 --> 00:37:41,592
Time that you feared you
might not have
683
00:37:41,759 --> 00:37:44,660
when you learned that Nauer and Soto
were just a hop, skip and a jump
684
00:37:44,829 --> 00:37:47,696
away from their own solution
to P versus NP.
685
00:37:47,865 --> 00:37:50,561
You killed them,
lest they take their work public
686
00:37:50,735 --> 00:37:54,068
and send shockwaves
through the digital security industry.
687
00:37:54,238 --> 00:37:55,830
I don't know where
you're getting this.
688
00:37:56,007 --> 00:37:58,066
Wayne Kaneshiro
is where we're getting this.
689
00:37:58,242 --> 00:37:59,834
Your dinner date
from the other night.
690
00:38:00,544 --> 00:38:03,809
And the computer programmer
you've been working with.
691
00:38:03,981 --> 00:38:08,577
Mr. Kaneshiro had written code which
allowed you to hack your ex's e-mail,
692
00:38:08,753 --> 00:38:10,345
plant incriminating letters.
693
00:38:10,521 --> 00:38:13,251
He'd given Detective Bell a statement
saying that the two of you
694
00:38:13,424 --> 00:38:17,690
were in the restaurant
between the hours of 8:30 and 10:30.
695
00:38:17,862 --> 00:38:21,889
Once we were able to demonstrate
that was a lie, he told us everything.
696
00:38:26,270 --> 00:38:27,760
Hey.
697
00:38:28,406 --> 00:38:30,533
- Hey, sorry I'm late.
- That's okay.
698
00:38:30,708 --> 00:38:33,233
So, uh, you said on the phone
you had news.
699
00:38:33,878 --> 00:38:35,277
I've decided to make an investment.
700
00:38:35,880 --> 00:38:38,280
This is huge.
Seriously, I told my partner...
701
00:38:38,449 --> 00:38:40,747
I'm not investing in the bar, Joey.
702
00:38:40,918 --> 00:38:42,545
I'm investing in you.
703
00:38:43,888 --> 00:38:47,483
You know, before your father's surgery,
he and I spent a lot of time together.
704
00:38:47,658 --> 00:38:50,889
But what you probably don't know
is how much we talked about you.
705
00:38:51,062 --> 00:38:53,587
He was so proud that you were gonna
become an engineer,
706
00:38:53,764 --> 00:38:56,460
and then when you earned
that scholarship, he was...
707
00:38:59,337 --> 00:39:02,500
Anyway, listen, I wanna offer you
a new scholarship.
708
00:39:02,673 --> 00:39:07,110
A check for $22,000, enough to finish
your undergraduate degree.
709
00:39:07,511 --> 00:39:12,710
Um, that is a very generous offer.
710
00:39:14,218 --> 00:39:16,550
But school just isn't for me
right now. Maybe after...
711
00:39:16,721 --> 00:39:19,781
That is the only help
that I feel comfortable offering.
712
00:39:21,592 --> 00:39:25,187
So you clearly have the cash,
713
00:39:25,396 --> 00:39:29,423
but you'll only let me have it
if I do what you think is right.
714
00:39:29,600 --> 00:39:32,660
- I wanna do what's right by your dad.
- My dad.
715
00:39:32,837 --> 00:39:36,603
The one guy who isn't here right now
to help me because of you.
716
00:39:40,478 --> 00:39:42,537
I'm sorry. Just...
717
00:39:43,114 --> 00:39:45,139
You don't deserve that.
718
00:39:50,354 --> 00:39:53,289
I will support you
in whatever you do.
719
00:39:53,457 --> 00:39:56,824
If you open up a bar,
it'll be my new watering hole.
720
00:39:56,994 --> 00:40:00,725
If you need to talk,
I am just a phone call away.
721
00:40:01,866 --> 00:40:05,632
But I am only going to pay
for your education.
722
00:40:07,271 --> 00:40:11,207
So you tell me, what do you want?
723
00:40:28,259 --> 00:40:31,251
Hey, what are you doing?
724
00:40:31,495 --> 00:40:35,591
I am taking one last look
at P versus NP.
725
00:40:35,766 --> 00:40:38,064
What do you mean, "last look"?
726
00:40:38,569 --> 00:40:42,266
The NSA has asked the N.Y.P.D.
To surrender
727
00:40:42,473 --> 00:40:45,169
everything and anything
pertaining to the problem,
728
00:40:45,342 --> 00:40:47,367
including Tanya Barrett.
729
00:40:47,545 --> 00:40:49,410
They want her in federal custody?
730
00:40:50,247 --> 00:40:53,683
They claim it's in the interest
of protecting the country
731
00:40:53,851 --> 00:40:55,546
against her breakthrough.
732
00:40:57,688 --> 00:41:00,885
She alleges
she never kept any hard copies,
733
00:41:01,058 --> 00:41:06,257
and says she will only explain her work
in exchange for a deal.
734
00:41:06,430 --> 00:41:09,263
District attorney, however,
has little interest.
735
00:41:09,433 --> 00:41:12,300
So it seems in spite of everything,
736
00:41:13,003 --> 00:41:19,875
the proof may not usher modern
encryption into obsolescence after all.
737
00:41:20,478 --> 00:41:21,570
How was coffee?
738
00:41:22,279 --> 00:41:24,440
Joey said that
he would think about my offer,
739
00:41:24,615 --> 00:41:26,310
but I am not holding my breath.
740
00:41:26,484 --> 00:41:28,850
I thought your plan was quite clever.
741
00:41:29,019 --> 00:41:30,509
You demonstrated your goodwill
742
00:41:30,688 --> 00:41:33,816
without allowing him
to take further advantage.
743
00:41:34,658 --> 00:41:36,592
You know that if he had
taken me up on that offer,
744
00:41:36,760 --> 00:41:38,193
I was going to pay you back, right?
745
00:41:38,762 --> 00:41:40,753
You know I have about as much
interest in money
746
00:41:40,931 --> 00:41:43,297
as I do Hummel figurines.
747
00:41:44,068 --> 00:41:46,764
Either way, thank you.
748
00:41:50,040 --> 00:41:53,271
You know, I'd quite like to go
with you next time.
749
00:41:57,882 --> 00:41:59,645
To the cemetery.
750
00:42:01,886 --> 00:42:05,287
Obviously the mistake
that you made,
751
00:42:06,156 --> 00:42:08,124
it, uh, changed the course
of your life.
752
00:42:10,961 --> 00:42:14,328
The man seems to have left
quite an impression, as well.
753
00:42:18,469 --> 00:42:21,063
I'd just like to pay my respects.
754
00:42:25,576 --> 00:42:27,237
I'd like that.
Ripped By mstoll